surplus
Production above what is needed for subsistence, which centralized societies extracted and concentrated among elites.
As defined in Josiah Ober on the Ancient Greek Economy
Where it comes up · 6
- Omer Moav on the Emergence of the State6 claims
- Josiah Ober on the Ancient Greek Economy2 claims
- Jordan Peterson | Hierarchies, Inequality, BIG 51 claim
- Capital, Compute & AI Scaling1 claim
- Goosehead: Insuring Coverage1 claim
- Democracy at Work: Curing Capitalism | Richard Wolff | Talks at Google1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “surplus” →
- Surplus is also not a sufficient condition for taxation: a village with abundant cassava (a tuber that stays preserved in the ground but rots within days of being dug up) produces real surplus, yet that surplus cannot be efficiently appropriated, moved, or used to build pyramids or fund a military—so what truly enables a state is an easily-taxed food, not surplus.Omer Moav on the Emergence of the State
- The profound and central insight is that storability is crucial: grain is wonderful because it can be stored, but that same property makes it horrible because it can also be taxed; cassava is horrible because it cannot be stored, yet fantastic because it therefore cannot be taxed.Omer Moav on the Emergence of the State
- As soon as there is economic surplus in a society, inequality emerges; even in hunter-gatherer societies without surplus, inequality exists in friendship, health, and sexual access, but economic inequality only appears with surplus.Jordan Peterson | Hierarchies, Inequality, BIG 5
- Surplus is not a prerequisite for taxation: with a seasonal cereal that must be stored for year-round survival, a tax collector backed by force can simply seize a share of the stored grain after harvest regardless of whether any true surplus exists, indifferent to whether some people consequently starve.Omer Moav on the Emergence of the State
- The surplus theory contradicts Malthus: if Malthusian dynamics hold, any income above subsistence raises fertility and population until income per capita falls back to subsistence, meaning no persistent surplus exists—so surplus cannot be the prerequisite for taxation.Omer Moav on the Emergence of the State
- The claim that slave societies are doomed to stagnation (refusing to innovate or attract investment) is a moral argument disguised as an economic one; while slavery is morally monstrous, it is not in itself evidence of stagnation, and there is no evidence the Greeks extracted more surplus from largely unskilled slave labor than other slaveholding societies did.Josiah Ober on the Ancient Greek Economy
- The conventional theory, traceable to Adam Smith and earlier thinkers, holds that the transition to farming let farmers produce more food than they needed, creating surplus, and that this surplus is the prerequisite for taxation and the emergence of states and hierarchies.Omer Moav on the Emergence of the State
- Highly centralized ancient societies extract a small agricultural surplus and concentrate it in very few hands, so their monuments tell us about leaders but not about the average person's living conditions.Josiah Ober on the Ancient Greek Economy
- The novel theoretical contribution of the paper is the claim that the surplus argument is wrong and surplus is not needed at all; the prior idea that grains are easier to tax than tubers was already made by James Scott and researchers in the 1970s-80s, but those scholars retained the surplus framing, only adding that surplus must be of something storable.Omer Moav on the Emergence of the State
- An employer hires a worker only if that worker's output in an hour will be worth more than the hourly wage paid; therefore workers always produce more value than they receive in wages—a surplus that becomes profit and is appropriated by owners.Democracy at Work: Curing Capitalism | Richard Wolff | Talks at Google