causal
Surplus Not Necessary for Taxation
Surplus is not a prerequisite for taxation: with a seasonal cereal that must be stored for year-round survival, a tax collector backed by force can simply seize a share of the stored grain after harvest regardless of whether any true surplus exists, indifferent to whether some people consequently starve.
causalpending
Speaker
Omer MoavEvidence Quote
“this just simple thought-experiment illustrates that the idea that surplus is a prerequisite for taxation is just wrong.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:27:25 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...