superdeterminism
An interpretation of quantum mechanics that denies measurement independence, positing correlations between hidden variables and measurement settings.
As defined in AMA | February 2024
Where it comes up · 5
- AMA | March 20222 claims
- 124 - In Search Of Reality1 claim
- 59 | Adam Becker on the Curious History of Quantum Mechanics1 claim
- AMA | February 20241 claim
- Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | September 20261 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “superdeterminism” →
- Intellectual progress requires taking some things as assumed-correct and building on them; if every academic started every project from zero assumptions they would never make progress, which is why Carroll assumes many-worlds is right and builds foundational work on it, while acknowledging this is a bet that could be wrong.AMA | March 2022
- John Bell proved that Einstein was right to be worried about quantum mechanics but that his proposed solution could not work: any theory reproducing quantum predictions in which experiments have definite outcomes (and excluding superdeterminism) must contain spooky action at a distance or something even weirder, so locality cannot be saved merely by adding hidden variables.59 | Adam Becker on the Curious History of Quantum Mechanics
- Modern foundations of quantum mechanics do not decide between 'interpretations'; many-worlds is a physical theory with definite ontology (the wave function) and rules (the Schrödinger equation), as are pilot-wave and superdeterminism theories — these are distinct physical theories, and the word 'interpretation' is old-fashioned and no longer applies. Genuinely equivalent formulations like Lagrangian vs Hamiltonian mechanics can be chosen freely by convenience.AMA | March 2022
- Superdeterminism—the idea that quantum probabilities reflect ignorance because the outcome of each measurement was fixed long ago in the universe's initial conditions—does not make quantum mechanics simpler; many-worlds already contains everything implied by a quantum state evolving via the Schrödinger equation, so superdeterminism and every other interpretation must add new structure to get rid of the other worlds, which is not obviously worth it.124 - In Search Of Reality
- The asker finds superdeterminism described primarily as a loophole in Bell's theorem and asks whether it is a standalone interpretation of quantum mechanics.Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | September 2026
- Superdeterminism is taken seriously by some physicists as a way to interpret quantum mechanics by denying measurement independence, while others regard it as completely implausible and even unscientific, making its evaluation a genuine point of disagreement.AMA | February 2024