substitution
In economics, reallocating effort or resources from one activity to another in response to incentives; here students shifting effort from reading to rewarded math.
As defined in Roland Fryer on Educational Reform
Where it comes up · 4
- Thinking, Fast and Slow | Daniel Kahneman | Talks at Google5 claims
- Paul Sabin on Ehrlich, Simon and the Bet2 claims
- An Uncertain Crisis1 claim
- Roland Fryer on Educational Reform1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “substitution” →
- Ehrlich lost partly because commodity prices were at a historically high peak at the end of the 1970s, making it a poor time to bet on continued price increases, and because specific developments—fiber optic substitution for copper, resolved labor strikes, and the collapse of an international tin cartel—drove prices down independently of population.Paul Sabin on Ehrlich, Simon and the Bet
- The substitution mechanism generates intuitions that are much less likely to be correct than expert intuitions based on learned patterns, but they come with approximately equal confidence.Thinking, Fast and Slow | Daniel Kahneman | Talks at Google
- Grantham's most favored investment is specialty metals such as cobalt and nickel, since their prices spike in shortages before substitution, redesign, and new supply bring prices back down, and the cycle moves between metals rather than producing a clean trend.An Uncertain Crisis
- Simon argued that scarcity raises prices, which calls forth innovation, substitution, and new development that then lowers prices, so resources are not finite because human ingenuity—the 'ultimate resource'—continually creates new resources and substitutes.Paul Sabin on Ehrlich, Simon and the Bet
- The intensity-matching mechanism is statistically incorrect because it is not regressive (it doesn't account for regression to the mean), yet it is psychologically compelling and is another source of intuitive errors.Thinking, Fast and Slow | Daniel Kahneman | Talks at Google
- Paying Houston students for math homework produced large math gains but an almost equal negative effect on reading—not because students lost the love of learning, but because they substituted effort between tasks, finding it cheaper to crowd out English than to crowd out time with friends.Roland Fryer on Educational Reform
- When asked a question that cannot be answered, System 1 typically substitutes an easier related question, using the answer to the wrong question in place of the answer to the asked question—a mechanism called 'substitution' that operates automatically and unconsciously.Thinking, Fast and Slow | Daniel Kahneman | Talks at Google
- The focusing illusion operates when an emotional reaction to one question (about dating frequency) is sitting active in mind, and then when a related but different question is asked (about happiness), substitution occurs: people use the emotional reaction from the dating question as the answer to the happiness question.Thinking, Fast and Slow | Daniel Kahneman | Talks at Google
- People are not confused about what happiness means; they know happiness is not satisfaction with dating frequency—but this is what the answer that comes to mind is anyway, due to substitution, so they are unaware the substitution has occurred.Thinking, Fast and Slow | Daniel Kahneman | Talks at Google