state capacity libertarianism
Cowen's framework combining libertarian commitments with a recognition that a capable, effective state is necessary for delivering key public goods.
As defined in Conversations With Tyler 2022 Retrospective
Where it comes up · 6
- Conversations With Tyler 2020 Retrospective2 claims
- Conversations With Tyler 2022 Retrospective1 claim
- Marginal Revolution 20Th Anniversary1 claim
- Arnold Kling on Reforming Government and Expertise1 claim
- Will DOGE and Musk Make a Difference? (with Michael Munger)1 claim
- Alex Tabarrok - Prizes, Prices, and Public Goods1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “state capacity libertarianism” →
- Bureaucracy is the sine qua non, the essential form of organization for the territorially extensive state, so the real question is not whether we can make bureaucracy efficient but whether the state should be doing a given activity at all; if it should, it needs well-funded, expert, dedicated bureaucracy, and if not, the entire agency must be eliminated rather than trimmed.Will DOGE and Musk Make a Difference? (with Michael Munger)
- Cowen's coined term 'state capacity libertarianism' remains a good and durable statement of his philosophical position; he coined it precisely because it sounded absurd enough that no one would use it, yet people still do.Marginal Revolution 20Th Anniversary
- Controlling contagious disease is a public good requiring government, so liberty is best secured by beating back the virus through measures like vaccine subsidies and government support for testing, illustrating state capacity libertarianism.Conversations With Tyler 2020 Retrospective
- The US government has lost state capacity—it has become too slow, complacent, and bound by legalism and bureaucracy to do what it is supposed to do when needed—exemplified by the CDC botching the first COVID test and the FDA blocking private companies from using their own tests; this failure spans Trump, Congress (which produced no testing or vaccine plan), and the broader system, and is the central concern of 'state capacity libertarianism': wanting a small government that can nonetheless act effectively when required.Alex Tabarrok - Prizes, Prices, and Public Goods
- The strongest case against state capacity libertarianism is that building stronger state capacity (e.g., effective contact tracing) increases the danger of pervasive state surveillance, as seen in China, so even a useful trace regime may set a bad precedent.Conversations With Tyler 2020 Retrospective
- Modern life presents threats and opportunities that most people expect government to address, so it is better for government to do those things well than poorly, because a government that performs poorly ends up infringing on liberty even more—making 'state capacity libertarianism' preferable to naive minimal-state libertarianism.Arnold Kling on Reforming Government and Expertise
- Cowen wrote his New Right essay to persuade smart young people on the right—who increasingly identify with some version of the New Right—to move toward classical liberalism, recognizing what they might be correct about while arguing they are not on the proper path forward.Conversations With Tyler 2022 Retrospective