What this covers
Tyler Cowen reflects on the pandemic year through conversations spanning medicine, media, economics, business, and technology. The retrospective draws out what the forced experiments of 2020 revealed about productivity, institutional capacity, and human behavior. Cowen argues that remote work proved nearly indistinguishable in quality from in-person interaction, that Operation Warp Speed and Fast Grants demonstrated how quickly problems can be solved when prioritized, and that 2020 supplied a surprising lesson: people operate on habit and short horizons rather than rational intertemporal substitution, failing to forgo activities now for greater rewards later.
The retrospective ranges across several distinct claims. On policy, Cowen argues for state capacity libertarianism—that beating back contagion through government support for vaccines and testing actually secures liberty—while acknowledging the surveillance risk such capacity creates. He defends Operation Warp Speed's ex ante brilliance in funding a portfolio of seven vaccine candidates, questions whether contact tracing could ever work at American scale, and contends that continued lockdowns shifted rather than reduced viral exposure. On economic and social change, he notes that progress in 2020—including SpaceX advances and protein-folding breakthroughs—largely escaped public notice, that regional divergence in pandemic response contradicts globalization narratives, and that roughly one-third of the shift to delivery and takeout will prove permanent. More tangential observations include remarks from former CIA head John Brennan on UFOs, why certain ethnic restaurants proved more resilient than expected, and cinema's irreplaceability as a communal art form.
Cowen argues that the pandemic forced experiments (remote work, fast-funded science, Operation Warp Speed) that revealed latent productivity and state capacity, and that the most surprising lesson of 2020 is how people fail to substitute consumption across time and how little major discoveries register publicly.
- Forced remote interviews proved nearly indistinguishable in quality, implying large remote-work productivity gains
- Operation Warp Speed and Fast Grants show problems can be solved far faster when prioritized
- People act on short horizons and habit rather than intertemporal substitution, surprising even an economist
Pandemic-era innovations in vaccine development, rapid funding, and remote work prove significant economic progress remains possible.
- Fast Grants demonstrated that you can give grants to top researchers within days using simple submission forms, scaling to about $43 million with substantial impact, proving that science funding can be far faster than the usual six-month bureaucratic process.
“the idea that you would get grants to top researchers within a number of days, and make these submission forms super easy.”
- Operation Warp Speed was the best US program of the pandemic because investing in a portfolio of seven vaccine candidates was an ex ante brilliant decision that delivered vaccines sooner and a broader choice; arguably the US should have invested even more.
“the fact that we invested in this portfolio of seven would have turned out to have been very important. As I'm speaking, we're not completely sure how important that will be, but ex ante, that was a brilliant decision, and arguably, we should have done more.”
- Being forced into remote podcast interviews showed they are nearly indistinguishable in quality to listeners, which suggests much more of the economy can be done remotely and that large productivity gains are on the way.
“I've asked a number of people, and basically, they can't tell the difference, as listeners, whether or not it's remote.”
- A lot happened in 2020 — including SpaceX advances and protein folding breakthroughs — that arguably is getting us out of the great stagnation, even though it goes largely unnoticed amid COVID coverage.
“SpaceX and protein folding. A lot happened this year that, arguably, is getting us out of the great stagnation.”
- Cowen's March 2020 prediction that vaccines would arrive by around March 2021 was bizarre and not widely made at the time, yet turned out to be very close to correct.
“At the time, that was a very bizarre prediction that was not being widely made. It turns out, it'll have been very, very close to correct.”
State capacity enables disease control but risks enabling pervasive surveillance that outweighs the public health benefit.
- The strongest case against state capacity libertarianism is that building stronger state capacity (e.g., effective contact tracing) increases the danger of pervasive state surveillance, as seen in China, so even a useful trace regime may set a bad precedent.
“if you had stronger state capacity, presumably you should worry more about state surveillance, and I do. That, to me, is the best case against state capacity libertarianism as I envision it.”
- Controlling contagious disease is a public good requiring government, so liberty is best secured by beating back the virus through measures like vaccine subsidies and government support for testing, illustrating state capacity libertarianism.
“Milton Friedman said this, too. He said, "One of the public goods you need government for is to control contagious diseases." This is that. When it happens, you will best secure liberty by beating back the virus.”
Practical barriers and structural failures made pandemic interventions like contact tracing ineffective despite good intentions.
- Contact tracing was never likely to work in the United States because the country is too big, complicated, and messy, lacks a national ID system, and lacks integrated electronic medical records compatible across systems.
“given that we don't have systematic electronic medical records compatible across all systems, odds are trace was never going to work here, in my view.”
- After the initial March shutdown (justified by uncertainty and hospital preparation), continued lockdowns are not a good idea because they mostly shift viral exposure through time rather than reducing it; the better path is winning the war via vaccines and testing.
“I think, really, lockdowns are just shifting exposure through time. What you want to do is get to the point where you are winning the war against the virus, and that you will do better with vaccines and testing.”
People are governed by habit and refuse to trade present activity for future gains, a behavioral rigidity economic models must account for.
- Cowen's main forecasting error in March was assuming unemployment would stay higher for longer and that people would stay terrified longer; in fact people resumed activities quickly, which prolonged transmission but also helped the job market recover.
“The general underlying mistake in my forecast was I thought people would stay terrified for longer than they did. They have resumed in many parts of the country in numerous ways.”
- People are far more governed by a utility function of habit formation than by intertemporal substitution, refusing to forgo activities now to do twice as many later, a behavioral failure striking enough that economic models should incorporate it.
“It's more a utility function of habit formation than intertemporal substitution than I would have thought, and I already knew the behavioral evidence on that.”
Pandemic disruptions permanently altered consumer behavior in dining and entertainment delivery, though not uniformly across regions.
- The shift to delivery and takeout during lockdown will be a permanent change to the extent that about a third of it will stick, even though Cowen personally dislikes takeout because the food tastes much worse.
“Permanent change. To some extent, I think maybe a third of that shift will stick.”
- During the pandemic, the value of comfort food is higher and complex dishes are harder to execute due to kitchen crowding and reduced staff, so ordering simpler dishes will yield better-tasting and more enjoyable food.
“While the pandemic is still on, the value of comfort food is higher. The value of complicated dishes is lower. They're harder to pull off under current circumstances.”
- Surprisingly few ethnic restaurants in Northern Virginia closed during the pandemic, suggesting they were more thickly capitalized than expected and likely sustainable, in contrast to DC where many closed.
“They must, in some way, be more thickly capitalized than I had thought.”
- The NBA's decision to shut down all games as early as March was brilliant and prescient, showing the courage to act decisively rather than dragging it out.
“That the NBA just shut down all games as early as it did in March was brilliant and prescient”
Isolation produced durable regional divergence in norms and behavior that will persist against globalization homogenization.
- Being cut off from each other produced strikingly different pandemic responses and norms across regions, which is a counter to globalization and homogenization arguments, and much of that local divergence will persist.
“It's a counter to these globalization, homogenization arguments, and I do think much of that will stick.”
Lockdowns shift rather than reduce viral exposure; vaccines and testing offer better solutions with lasting offshoots benefiting other diseases.
- Work done on COVID will benefit other medical tasks through offshoots like semi-universal vaccines, testing to detect other viruses, and using mRNA vaccine platforms to combat other diseases, but these gains must be seen through rather than abandoned.
“The notion of a semi-universal vaccine, a testing to find other viruses, using mRNA vaccine platforms to combat other things — all those will be offshoots of the COVID triumphs.”
Media choice and audience reach matter more than direct financial compensation in publishing and platform decisions.
- Cowen will not move to Substack because, although Substack writers can earn a lot of money, he would rather have the bigger audience and considers a free, ad-free, open audience a privilege greater than the money.
“I'm fully aware that people who do Substack can earn a lot of money, but I'd actually rather have the bigger audience.”
- Twitter really matters for a podcast's audience, as shown by guests like Adam Tooze and Matt Yglesias whose social-media presence corresponded with strong download performance.
“Adam and Matt are indicating Twitter really matters for your podcast audience, right?”
Unexplained phenomena like UFOs warrant serious consideration even at low probability, yet public indifference is itself remarkable.
- Former CIA head John Brennan, when pressed on UFOs, suggested that of all the explanations he did not see a better one than alien beings, though not above 50 percent probability, after thinking about it long and hard.
“I took him to be saying that the single most likely explanation was, in some way, alien beings.”
- Even granting only a 5 percent chance the UFO phenomenon is alien (Cowen thinks it's almost certainly drones), the striking thing is the lack of public interest — it won't make the front page of the New York Times — which is more remarkable than the phenomenon itself.
“But it should be a big, big thing, and it isn't. That to me is so startling.”
Cinema's communal value transcends format and economic incentives to remain worth experiencing despite pandemic disruption.
- Cinema is the greatest art form of the 20th century, and Cowen intends to stick with seeing new releases in theaters as long as he can, valuing the communal theatrical experience.
“It's the greatest art form of the 20th century. I was born in the 20th century, and I'm going to stick with that form as long as I can”
Library closures shifted pandemic podcast guest composition toward economists requiring online rather than book-based research.
- The biggest pandemic change for Cowen's podcast preparation was lost access to the library, which shifted his guest composition toward economists who require online rather than book-based research.
“That was the bigger change in going from face-to-face to remote — my reading habits.”