solipsism
The philosophical idea that only one's own mind is certain to exist and that others may be non-conscious zombies.
As defined in 57 - An Evening With Richard Dawkins And Sam Harris 1
Other definitions
A philosophical or psychological position that only one's own mind and sensations are real or knowable; the belief that the external world exists only insofar as it is perceived or constituted by the individual subject
Great Authors - Neoclassical and Romantic Literature - Goethe, The Sorrows of Young Werther
Where it comes up · 7
- Great Minds - Part 4 - Hegel: The Phenomenology of Geist3 claims
- Barthes, Semiotics and the Revolt Against Structuralism2 claims
- 57 - An Evening With Richard Dawkins And Sam Harris 11 claim
- 181 - The Illusory Self1 claim
- 155 - Mental Models1 claim
- Great Authors - Neoclassical and Romantic Literature - Goethe, The Sorrows of Young Werther1 claim
- Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “solipsism” →
- Occam's razor (the principle of parsimony) is the foundation of scientific thinking but the devil is in what strikes you as simple; assuming only you are conscious (solipsism), or only humans are, seems parsimonious but actually smuggles in extra unexplained work—you must explain why beings 99% genetically and neuroanatomically identical to you, behaving as if conscious, somehow lack consciousness—so the genuinely parsimonious move is to attribute it.155 - Mental Models
- Hegel's solution to the solipsism problem of idealism is to claim that the world is indeed a product of mind, but not individual human mind; rather, it is the product of Geist—a vast collective subject or absolute mind that generates all of reality.Great Minds - Part 4 - Hegel: The Phenomenology of Geist
- The problem of idealism inherent in Fichte and Schelling's rejection of the thing-in-itself is that it leads necessarily to solipsism: if mind creates both the form and content of consciousness, there is nothing external to mind and potentially nothing but the individual mind's own representations.Great Minds - Part 4 - Hegel: The Phenomenology of Geist
- Kant's critical philosophy does not collapse into explicit idealism precisely because Kant holds onto the thing-in-itself (ding-an-sich) as external reality, which prevents radical solipsism, distinguishing his project from the full idealism of Fichte and Schelling.Great Minds - Part 4 - Hegel: The Phenomenology of Geist
- Hofstadter and Dennett dismissed Harding's headlessness account as a charmingly childish, solipsistic denial of mortality, but they failed to realize that Harding's account contains a precise empirical instruction—to look for the 'I' without being distracted by thought and notice what happens—illustrating how celebrated thinkers about the mind can entirely miss a first-person method of investigating it.181 - The Illusory Self
- The key difference between Goethe and Lawrence is that 'goethe is actually willing to face up to the nihilistic implications' of solipsism whereas 'lawrence is unwilling to face up to that' because 'he's far too committed to this idea' of emotion-worship, making Goethe 'a new uh verter who doesn't commit suicide' but fundamentally different in his capacity for self-critique.Great Authors - Neoclassical and Romantic Literature - Goethe, The Sorrows of Young Werther
- French intellectual culture has never been able to get out from under the shadow of Descartes; they all have a problem with either accepting their own selfhood or demonstrating the reality of the external world; it easily slips into solipsism if you start philosophical investigations from the inside, making it very hard to make the jump to outside stuffBarthes, Semiotics and the Revolt Against Structuralism
- Solipsism is not the most economical view as many first-year philosophy students think; it actually carries an additional burden of explanation, because one must explain why something biologically so similar to oneself—born and developed the same way—would not be conscious, making it more parsimonious to assume others are conscious.57 - An Evening With Richard Dawkins And Sam Harris 1
- The process of Nietzschean philosophizing with a hammer becomes intellectual vandalism when extended to all structures: the critic criticizes everything around it and then antsy starts to criticize itself, resulting in destruction where nothing is left except the ego, but there isn't even a complete self because structures of communication, knowledge, and linguistic interaction that give us hold to the external world are broken downBarthes, Semiotics and the Revolt Against Structuralism
- Lyotard's radical relativism of knowledge, speech, and language moves perilously close to solipsism, making communication and shared understanding impossible, and this problem is the subject of his book The Differend.Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition