factual

The Chariot Argument Against a Substantial Self

Nagasena's chariot argument in the Questions of King Milinda shows there is no self as a thing: just as 'chariot' is merely a linguistic convention for a collection of parts (not the wheels, not the parts taken together, not something beyond them), 'Nagasena' is just a label for a collection of parts, demonstrating there is no substantial self—an argument that, read alongside Descartes's Meditations, makes Descartes's case for the self look less compelling.

factualpending

Speaker

Bryan Van Norden

Evidence Quote

“the eyes interacting with visual forms create the phenomenon of vision. But that phenomenon of vision is analogous to like a wheel. It's just a one of those parts that we label Nagasena”

Source

319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:32 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...