shadow price
The implicit market value of a good that isn't sold at an explicit price, inferred from what comparable goods fetch—here, the scalper price that reveals what a free student ticket is really worth.
As defined in The Economics of Scarcity and the UNC-Duke Basketball Game (with Michael Munger)
Where it comes up · 6
- Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 5--A Discussion of Parts III (cont.), IV, and V4 claims
- The Economics of Scarcity and the UNC-Duke Basketball Game (with Michael Munger)2 claims
- Branko Milanovic on the Big Questions of Economics2 claims
- Jeffrey Sachs on the Crisis, the Recovery, and the Future1 claim
- David Zetland on Water1 claim
- Branko Milanovic on Capitalism, Alone1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “shadow price” →
- In the moral sphere there is nothing like a price or medium of exchange—at best an implicit 'shadow price' (in Becker's sense)—so the alignment of honesty with esteem is not analogous to the equilibrating harmony of buyers and sellers in a market; the only equilibrating mechanism Smith gestures toward is that harder work and greater prudence yield commensurately greater material return.Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 5--A Discussion of Parts III (cont.), IV, and V
- Nothing desirable is truly free, because the real price of a thing includes the toil and trouble of acquiring it; a free Starbucks latte would carry an hour-long line, so a queue is just a non-monetary form of surge pricing.The Economics of Scarcity and the UNC-Duke Basketball Game (with Michael Munger)
- Unlike the market's price mechanism, the moral sphere lacks a true equilibrating mechanism: there is at most an implicit shadow price (more praise, more honor) but no medium of exchange and no property right, so the moral harmony is not directly analogous to market harmony.Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 5--A Discussion of Parts III (cont.), IV, and V
- The moral 'invisible hand' lacks a true equilibrating mechanism like prices in markets: the closest parallel is that prudence and industry yield commensurate prosperity, but in the moral sphere there is only an implicit 'shadow price' (in Becker's sense) for honor and esteem—there is no medium of exchange, no property right, nothing analogous to the price-coordinated harmony of buyers and sellers.Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 5--A Discussion of Parts III (cont.), IV, and V
- Smith develops an 'invisible hand of morals' that parallels his invisible hand in economics, but the moral sphere lacks a price mechanism: there is no medium of exchange, no property right, and only an implicit 'shadow price' for honor and esteem, so the moral harmony is structurally a level above the market harmony of buyers and sellers.Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 5--A Discussion of Parts III (cont.), IV, and V
- The most basic point of intertemporal public economics is that debt must be serviced in the future—there is no Ponzi or Madoff escape—so taking on a dollar of debt requires raising a dollar of revenue or cutting a dollar of spending later; with public debt rising from 37% of GDP in 2007 to 75% today and CBO projecting interest costs climbing toward 3.3-3.4% of GDP by the early 2020s (exceeding all civilian discretionary spending), building up debt crowds out the very public investments needed for the future.Jeffrey Sachs on the Crisis, the Recovery, and the Future
- Most Southern California water consumption does not include any price for environmental sustainability; including that shadow price would add significantly to the cost of water, and the absence of it is why the Colorado River no longer reaches its delta with normal flow.David Zetland on Water
- Personal goods that were once used only for one's own needs—a home, a car, leisure time—become what Marx calls capital once they acquire a known market or shadow price (via Airbnb, Uber, influencer monetization), because that visible price reshapes behavior and gradually draws individuals into the commercialized economy even if they were initially reluctant.Branko Milanovic on the Big Questions of Economics
- The gig economy and commercialization put a shadow price on every unit of time: whereas in the past one could not finely trade leisure for income (the economist's textbook claim that leisure's cost is the wage rate was practically unrealizable), platforms like Uber now let people sell labor in tiny packets, so jobs fragment into gig units and individuals are encouraged to treat every minute as a calculable economic choice—epitomized by lawyers billing in 15-minute increments.Branko Milanovic on Capitalism, Alone
- Constantly perceiving the opportunity cost and shadow price of favors and time turns relationships into a scorecard; just as a good marriage works by not keeping score, pervasive commercialization may make life economically more efficient but socially worse by making everything enter a mental ledger.Branko Milanovic on the Big Questions of Economics