scapegoat mechanism
Girard's theory that human communities resolve internal rivalry and violence by collectively blaming and expelling or sacrificing a single victim (the scapegoat), temporarily restoring social unity.
As defined in Cynthia L. Haven
In Girard's theory, the process by which escalating mimetic violence in a community is suddenly unified against a single victim whose death brings peace, with the violence then concealed by myth that justifies the victim as guilty.
Peter Thiel on "The Straussian Moment"In Girardian theory, the process where internal conflict within a community becomes focused on a single person or group who is sacrificed or expelled, temporarily resolving the conflict and uniting the community mythically; Christianity revealed this mechanism, making it harder to repeat unconsciously.
Are You Ready For The 1st Turning? | Michael Millerman
- Conversations with Tyler - Luke Burgis4 claims
- Peter Thiel on "The Straussian Moment"3 claims
- Are You Ready For The 1st Turning? | Michael Millerman2 claims
- Cynthia L. Haven2 claims
- Scarcity, Abundance and Bubbles1 claim
- According to Girard, the world in which a scapegoat could produce catharsis is gone, because Christianity has exposed the scapegoat mechanism, so scapegoats no longer work and that is why violence has become runaway.Conversations with Tyler - Luke Burgis
- René Girard's insight is that the secret of politics is sacrificial violence at its heart—a scapegoat mechanism where mimetic conflict is centered on one person who is killed and mythologized, temporarily uniting the political community and removing violence; but Christianity revealed this mechanism, and over time this revelation increases universally, meaning the hidden violence at the heart of politics gradually becomes known.Are You Ready For The 1st Turning? | Michael Millerman
- Girard held that Judaism and Christianity, beginning with Judaism, were the first religions to focus in such a concentrated way on competition, strife, the reasons for conflict, and the pressures to scapegoat.Cynthia L. Haven
- The unveiling of the mythical past through understanding the scapegoat mechanism opens toward a future where archaic myths are deconstructed and discredited, but unlike Hegel's synthesis, this unveiling does not automatically bring about a glorious resolution.Peter Thiel on "The Straussian Moment"
- For Girard, the secret of politics is sacrificial violence at its heart, but this secret becomes known through time—Christianity revealed the scapegoat mechanism, and the revelation increases in universality as people understand how the mechanism works.Are You Ready For The 1st Turning? | Michael Millerman
- When a well-regarded startup dies, the community strips out its specifics and reframes its death as a restoration of differentiation, privately welcoming it while publicly blaming VCs, which keeps the bubble's creative energy running without a visible crash.Scarcity, Abundance and Bubbles
- Girard did not in fact witness a lynching, because a lynching is not something one can watch from a distance—you are either among the people throwing stones or you are the victim; its very nature draws participants in rather than allowing detached observation.Cynthia L. Haven
- We now live in a world where the scapegoat mechanism has been revealed—we know that the scapegoat is not guilty as the persecuting community claimed—and this revelation breaks the mechanism because the smooth functioning of human culture depended on ignorance of the mechanism itself.Peter Thiel on "The Straussian Moment"
- Girard counters Manent's objection by arguing that the revelation of the scapegoat mechanism is not chosen but inevitable—driven by the historical working of Judeo-Christian revelation—and therefore the decision to speak or remain silent about this truth is not really a choice.Peter Thiel on "The Straussian Moment"
- The current age of pessimism may get worse before it gets better, but Burgis does not think the pessimism can last indefinitely because cultural and societal release valves correct excess.Conversations with Tyler - Luke Burgis