What this covers

The conversation is with Luke Burgis, who works from René Girard's account of mimetic desire and applies it to contemporary culture, religion, and technology. It begins with Girard's claim that Christianity exposed the scapegoat mechanism, so scapegoats no longer produce catharsis and violence runs unchecked. Burgis also warns that anti-mimetic contrarianism, Silicon Valley's performed version included, can harden into another mimetic identity, and that Girardianism risks becoming a fashionable badge.

The range is wide. On religion, he contrasts revealed and Gnostic truth, reading the lost-sheep parable in the Gospel of Thomas as a sign of why hidden knowledge appeals today. He also discusses Italy's drift into cultural rather than practiced Catholicism, the church's mimicry of the world on TikTok, and his claim that how often a parish offers confession is the best signal of its vitality. He founded the Cluny Institute, which draws on the medieval Cluniac network of monasteries and is meant to link Athens, Jerusalem, and Silicon Valley.

The more contested positions come on social questions. He ties Anglo-Western unhappiness to the Calvinist-inflected achievement subject, criticizes effective altruism as too materialistic, and blames technology for widening the gap between men and women through sorting and dating apps. He calls pornography corrosive and argues for adding friction to access. His policy fantasy is a jazz club in every city over 100,000, as a third place. On AI, he forecasts weaker contagion and a humanities renaissance, since AI shows us what we are not.

Sharpest takeaway

Burgis argues that mimetic social contagion is escapable and may weaken as AI shifts culture from information toward intelligence, but only if people stop applying mimetic theory as a theory of everything and return to concrete particulars.

  • Contagion-driven pessimism is self-limiting through release valves such as vibe shifts and scapegoating, though it may worsen first
  • AI enables personalized, self-directed learning that is not a mimetic process
  • Overthinking mimetic theory is itself a mimetic trap; the antidote is attention to concrete particulars

The argument · threads13 threads · 70 claims
0.71

Beauty, ritual, mystery, and enchantment draw people to faith more than argument does.

10 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Following C. S. Lewis, one should die before they die by undergoing a series of small deaths to the ego, and Burgis has had to do this several times in his life.

    “One should die before they die and die a series of small deaths to our ego.”

  • Eastern Orthodox liturgy preserves a sense of otherworldliness and mystery, such as the iconostasis hiding the consecration, better than the Novus Ordo Mass does.

    “the Eastern Orthodox liturgy preserves in a way even better than the new Mass, the Novus Ordo does.”

  • Attending a Pixar storyboard master class in Rome showed Burgis that he craved creative, artistic, aesthetic work, which drew him away from theology and motivated his later interest in artistic projects.

    “I was so lit up by that class that I realized that there was something in me that craved this creative, artistic, aesthetic thing.”

  • The best way to bring someone to faith is not argumentative apologetics but to take them to Rome, into a beautiful church and mass, and into late-night conversation, because beauty is a path to truth; faith seeking understanding comes after witnessing the saints and the tradition.

    “I think the best chance that I have to help somebody see what I see in the church is not to try to convince them of the argument of why Christianity is true”

  • Meditating on death through the memento mori tradition, such as keeping a skull on one's desk, is different from merely knowing about it, and it is a practice Burgis learned in seminary and continues.

    “meditating on it and actually going through it are two different things.”

  • Beautiful ritual and reverence, such as a church full of people kneeling shoulder to shoulder, is the aesthetic core of Catholicism for Burgis, and it is what brought him back to his faith after a long absence.

    “I actually came back to my faith through that practice. It’s not one particular thing or piece of artwork for me; it is the beauty of the ritual.”

  • Catholicism holds that truth is fully revealed in Jesus Christ, but it also accepts personal divine revelations to individuals, such as Sister Faustina's diaries, which the church has examined and deemed worthy of belief, so hiddenness exists within the faith.

    “One part of the tradition that I always find interesting is personal divine revelation to individuals.”

  • Exorcisms appear to be on the rise, according to anecdotal reports, though the church tracks them without public data.

    “Anecdotally, it seems like they’re on the rise. ... Most of it’s anecdotal.”

  • In the Gnostic Gospel of Thomas version of the lost sheep parable, the lost sheep is the smartest one, and Jesus praises it for leaving the herd rather than returning it; this Gnostic reading, which prizes hidden knowledge, is more attractive to people today than the traditional reading that the lost sinner is brought back.

    “In the Gnostic gospel of Thomas, the sheep is not a sinner that Jesus finds. The one lost sheep was the smartest sheep.”

  • The world is not becoming more enchanted; rather, people must be open to enchantment in order to perceive the enchanting things already around them, and openness to the supernatural may increase.

    “The world is not necessarily becoming more enchanted. It’s us that are perceiving and noticing the things to be enchanted by.”

0.70

Mimetic social contagion drives modern violence, demonic dynamics, and the failure of scapegoating.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Japan is more likely than any Western country to have a scapegoat, given the West's deep Christian formation.

    “It would be more likely for Japan to have a scapegoat than for any country in the West.”

  • According to Girard, the world in which a scapegoat could produce catharsis is gone, because Christianity has exposed the scapegoat mechanism, so scapegoats no longer work and that is why violence has become runaway.

    “One of his fundamental points is that Christianity has created the conditions for the runaway violence precisely because the scapegoats don’t work anymore.”

  • AI will make social contagion weaker because society is moving from the age of information to the age of intelligence, where AI enables personalized, self-directed learning that autodidacts can follow to the end, a process that is not mimetic.

    “I would bet that it’s going to make social contagion weaker.”

  • Dostoevsky's novel Demons diagnoses what happens at a psychic and spiritual level when social contagion runs rampant, and the demonic can be understood as characterized by social contagion.

    “his book Demons diagnoses what can happen at a psychic and spiritual level when social contagion runs rampant.”

  • In a socially contagious culture, every family will have to take protective actions and set boundaries with the broader culture, though the response cannot be prescriptive because each case is unique; Rod Dreher is right about the need, not about moving to a small farm.

    “every person, every family ... is going to have to probably ... take certain actions to protect themselves.”

0.56

Achievement-driven individualism causes Western unhappiness, and healthy community with diverse neighbors is the remedy.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The Anglo and Western unhappiness stems from the Calvinist-inflected 'achievement subject' who has internalized the idea that one must always be doing something, which has displaced family, children, and other foundations of a good life, and it has spread through media and business culture.

    “We’ve internalized this idea that we always have to be doing something. There is always more to achieve.”

  • Italy has economic stagnation and problems, yet Italians seem more joyful and optimistic than most doing-well Americans Burgis knows.

    “For all of the economic stagnation and problems that Italy has, do they also have something right? People there actually seem more joyful and optimistic”

  • Modern culture has swung too far toward the individual 'one,' and the challenge is to live in community with the 99 without clustering into communities that share identical values, which Burgis finds boring.

    “I think the focus has actually swung way too far in the direction of the one.”

  • Communities where everyone shares the same values are the most boring communities, and Burgis usually declines invitations to them.

    “Those are the most boring communities for me.”

  • The desire for purity is dangerous, and every time Burgis tried to flee the messy world he ended up less happy, so he prefers to roll up his sleeves and deal with it.

    “every time in my life where I’ve tried to flee it in some way, I’ve actually ended up less happy.”

0.46

Building institutions like Cluny, rather than talking, renews faith and innovation.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The original Cluny was an entirely new kind of institution, with a charter in which the benefactor renounced all rights to control its operation, and it formed a network of over 1,200 Cluniac monasteries.

    “Its original charter, the guy that gave all of the money renounced his right to have anything to do with the way that it operated. It formed a network of over 1,200 Cluniac monasteries.”

  • The Cluny Institute aims to be a talent network and artist colony for religiously open, serious, innovation-minded people, functioning as a bat signal to draw them out and integrating Athens, Jerusalem, and Silicon Valley, because religious thinking could do Silicon Valley good.

    “I want to work with people that are able to work at the intersection of what I call Athens, Jerusalem, and Silicon Valley.”

  • Cluny was the largest church in the world for about 300 years and a center of European innovation partly because its Benedictine hospitality welcomed the sick, poor, and pilgrims and interacted with politicians, builders, and masons, and it popularized the Camino de Santiago.

    “Cluny actually popularized the Camino de Santiago. They’re the first ones that would send people on the Camino de Santiago.”

  • Being an entrepreneur is incredibly difficult because nobody tells you to stop and there is always something else to do, and stepping away to study in Italy helped him rebalance his life.

    “Being an entrepreneur is incredibly difficult because nobody ever tells you to stop, and there’s always something else to do.”

  • Silicon Valley's strength is people solving real problems in small teams without sorting by political preference, and the church should similarly do more building and less talking about AI ethics.

    “wish the church did more of this, should do more building, maybe, and less talking about the ethics of AI”

  • Burgis concluded from his short Wall Street stint that efficient markets theory is nonsense, because his undergraduate business education was not used day to day and he believes hedge-fund alpha-seeking would have been more engaging.

    “I learned that efficient markets theory is BS.”

0.46

Catholic truth was fully revealed, and living near Rome tests whether faith becomes supernatural or anxious.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Theology and aesthetics go hand in hand, and beauty is one of the ways people come to truth, so the goodness and beauty of the Church are related to truth, following von Balthasar.

    “It's one of the ways that we can come to the truth is through beauty.”

  • Gnosticism holds that there is always some hidden truth and one more thing to learn for salvation, while Catholicism holds that truth was fully revealed in the person of Jesus Christ, so Gnosticism resembles movements like Scientology.

    “The alternative to that is Gnosticism, which is generally the idea that there's always some hidden truth. It's like Scientology. There's always this one more thing.”

  • Living beside the Vatican is a formative test of faith, because one encounters Rome's worldliness and either comes out with a more supernatural vision of the Church or with anxiety, and Burgis's three years in a seminary dormitory with 250 men were formative.

    “Rome can be a very difficult place to live as a person of faith.”

  • Living in Rome as a person of faith either strengthens or destroys faith because one sees the worldliness of the church, though Burgis says he came out largely unchanged.

    “Rome will either strengthen your faith or lose it as a Catholic because you will see the dark underbelly of everything.”

  • Italian Masses are relatively low-liturgy and informal, with people wandering in and out of old churches lacking heating, AC, and good acoustics, which contrasts with the high-liturgy American Catholic revival.

    “It's relatively low liturgy compared to what you see. A lot of the revival in Catholicism here in the US are high-liturgy things.”

  • Catholic practices cluster in the way political positions do, so knowing one's stance on a single issue like gun control allows an accurate prediction of many other positions, and a parish's confession practices allow prediction of its other traits.

    “If I know your position on gun control, I can, with a high degree of accuracy, predict your position on 10 other clustered things.”

0.43

The church's mimetic worldliness undermines the otherworldly alterity it needs.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The rise of antisemitism on the political right is likely a mimetic phenomenon in which being edgy spreads through influence such as Nick Fuentes's among younger people, rather than revealing long-hidden true beliefs, and it may fade once exposed.

    “It’s cool to be edgy or something like that and to say things. You’ve got Nick Fuentes.”

  • The church has become highly mimetic with the world, with priests and influencers performing on TikTok, which is unhelpful because the church needs a level of otherworldliness and alterity.

    “I think one of the things that worries me a lot about the church today is that the church has become highly mimetic with the world.”

  • The Gerasene demoniac story shows the demonic having an element of contagion, since the whole herd is infected and driven into the sea, and in a world where demons are real there is nothing Manichean about admitting the demonic element.

    “this is the quintessential gospel story where the demonic has and always has an element of contagion because the entire herd is infected”

  • The Italian ideal of sprezzatura, effortless-looking care in dress, is itself highly mimetic, and the sameness of Italian dress is charming rather than a flaw, while Northern Italy is less mimetic than the animated South.

    “Even that seems highly mimetic to me, the idea of sprezzatura.”

  • The age of pessimism will not last because negative contagion has release valves, including cultural vibe shifts, the scapegoat mechanism, and over-correction, and optimism can even arise out of traumatic tragedy.

    “I think it might get worse before it gets better. I hope it ends.”

0.43

Christian formation still shapes the West, so pessimism cycles correct and tragedy can spur renewal.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The current age of pessimism may get worse before it gets better, but Burgis does not think the pessimism can last indefinitely because cultural and societal release valves correct excess.

    “I think it might get worse before it gets better. I hope it ends.”

  • The frequency with which a Catholic church offers confession is the strongest signal of its vitality, because frequent offerings create lines and more priests then offer it; combined with adoration frequency, it predicts many other traits of the parish.

    “It turns out from every priest that I’ve talked to that if you offer confession frequently, maybe a few times a week or daily, the lines just start to form.”

  • Even very secular people in the West have adopted many Christian ideas, so the West remains a very Christian society, and some integralist right-wingers fail to realize how Christian it is.

    “I think we’re very much in a Christian society, and there are some people on the integralist right that don’t realize how Christian of a society we actually do live in.”

  • Italy has become nonreligious in formal terms because Catholicism became so familiar that it turned into cultural identity, a process Burgis links to Mussolini and the Christian Democrats, and Italians now show cultural signs like crossing themselves while rarely attending mass.

    “It seems like they’re almost tired of their Catholicism. They’ve had it for so long.”

  • Optimism can sometimes arise out of tragedy, so a severe trauma such as a major war may be what finally pushes people to build something new.

    “sometimes optimism can arise out of tragedy.”

0.41

Grand theories, including mimetic theory, should be held lightly because they over-psychologize and breed imitation.

9 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Effective altruism has not proved very successful at its aims, its definition of effectiveness varies among practitioners without enough discussion of goals, and it is too materialistic, failing to account for relationship quality, depth, and culture.

    “ultimately very materialistic and doesn’t account for things like the quality of relationships, depth, culture.”

  • Being anti-mimetic can itself become a mimetic identity, and Girard would have been mortified that mimetic theory became so mimetic and popular, as his circle joked while he was alive.

    “I think Girard would be relatively mortified that mimetic theory was very mimetic and so popular.”

  • Big explanatory ideas like mimetic theory carry the risk of becoming a theory of everything that over-psychologizes life and obscures concrete circumstances, and the way out is to stop thinking about it so much and return to particulars, though reflection itself is not to be abandoned.

    “The way out of that problem actually is to stop thinking about it so dang much and to not impose that frame on everything”

  • Burgis declined a free consulting invitation from Anthropic because he suspected the engagement was a public-relations exercise to show they had consulted Christians, and the moral-imperative framing felt off.

    “I thought that they were looking for a way to say, 'We did this thing, we conferred with some Christians, we’re the good guys, we’re building the good AI.'”

  • As with efficient markets theory, a model of social life may be better not believed in full even if it is true, because believing it changes behavior for the worse for the world and for the individual.

    “Better for the world and maybe better for you too.”

  • Girard would have been mortified that mimetic theory became so popular and imitated, and the risk of making it a fashionable frame is exactly why one should not think about it too much.

    “I think Girard would be relatively mortified that mimetic theory was very mimetic and so popular.”

  • Adopting anti-mimetic contrarianism can itself become a mimetic identity, as seen in Silicon Valley's performed contrarianism, and Girardianism risks the same fate because its popularity makes it a fashionable badge.

    “I think Girard would be relatively mortified that mimetic theory was very mimetic and so popular.”

  • The Italian ideal of sprezzatura, effortless-looking care in dress, is itself highly mimetic because it is a shared performance of seeming unconcerned, and Burgis says he has never been able to pull it off.

    “Even that seems highly mimetic to me, the idea of sprezzatura.”

  • Living in a seminary dormitory with 250 mostly younger men created a highly mimetic environment, where comedy became the main way to adapt to shared living.

    “Talk about a relatively mimetic environment where we share so much in common.”

0.29

Men and women are complementary, but technology and sorting by preference widen the gap between them.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Men and women are different but complementary, a view Burgis holds even though it is no longer very popular.

    “I believe that men and women are complementary, different but complementary, and that’s not necessarily a very popular view anymore.”

  • If Burgis were dictator, he would fund a jazz club in every city over 100,000 people run by an entrepreneurial musician, because the country lacks intermediary institutions and healthy communities depend on third places that bring people together and help men and women learn to like each other.

    “we lack mediating intermediary institutions between individuals in the state and that communities, places are healthier to the extent that they have these odd places in between”

  • Technology, especially the way it sorts people into content and matches, is largely to blame for widening the gap between men and women, because it increases political polarization and exacerbates perceived differences between the sexes.

    “I think technology is largely to blame for that, the way that it sorts things that it thinks men should see versus things that women should see.”

  • Pornography is destroying young men and women, is taboo in the sense that no one discusses it, and should be made harder to access by introducing friction, because it is now encountered by accident as a rite of passage.

    “I’m actually relatively in favor of introducing friction into the process and how easy that stuff can be found.”

  • People sort by stated preferences before ever encountering a real person of the opposite sex, so perceptions form often wrongly, and dating apps prevent the encounters that would correct them.

    “We often sort based on what we think our preferences are before we’ve had a chance to encounter a flesh and human person of the opposite sex, and perceptions are formed, often wrongly.”

0.26

AI reshapes written culture and exposes intellectual blind spots, prompting a humanities renaissance.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • AI is performing a kind of via negativa on the human person and soul by showing us what we are not, which may lead to a renaissance in the humanities as people learn more about what it means to be human.

    “I think AI is performing a kind of via negativa on the human person, maybe even the human soul, in helping us discover who we are.”

  • Protestant print culture and Catholic oral culture each produce good through tension, and AI will change the form of traditional written essays rapidly, so the future of written word is uncertain, following McLuhan's insights about media.

    “it seems to me like the traditional forms of written word, even traditional essays, that is changing incredibly fast in the world that we’re entering.”

  • Burgis finds AI valuable for exposing his own intellectual blind spots by asking it to draw out implications of his ideas across domains he does not know well, and he is repeatedly amazed by the results.

    “I've got all kinds of blind spots and limitations... I'm always amazed by what it says.”

  • Anthropic's use of virtue ethics and discernment to define AI goodness mirrors ideas Ignatius and the Jesuits developed 500 years earlier, and Burgis pressed them on what it means for Claude to be good.

    “It seems like your discovery of virtue ethics, and they were using the word discernment, is you've landed on something that Ignatius and the Jesuits had figured out 500 years ago.”

0.26

Daily meditation on death and slowing down are wiser than seeking immortality or achievement.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Daily meditation on death, as in the Benedictine memento mori practice of keeping a skull on the desk, and C. S. Lewis's idea of dying small deaths to one's ego are how one should prepare for death.

    “One should die before they die and die a series of small deaths to our ego.”

  • Bryan Johnson's live-forever campaign is contrasted with the Benedictine tradition of meditating on death daily, which Burgis regards as the more humane approach to mortality.

    “there's Bryan Johnson in the live forever campaign... directly following him as a Benedictine monk who... is literally meditating on your death every single day.”

  • As a 23-year-old, Burgis would have hated Byung-Chul Han's The Burnout Society, because he was ambitious in an achievement-driven way, and an older investment banker's advice to slow down seemed lame to him, though he now sees it as essential reading.

    “I would have hated that book as a 23-year-old. I remember having an older investment banker come speak to me when I was a senior and tell me that I was gung-ho.”

  • Burgis wants to shift from serious nonfiction to artistic work such as a novel, and suspects he will need a detox period from the world of ideas, perhaps living in Italy for a year.

    “it's not easy to write serious nonfiction, and then flip into a different mode. I don't know if that will take some kind of detox period from the world of ideas.”

0.23

Italian social behavior is mimetic, with cheerfulness and reactions shaped by status and outsider standards.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Northern Italy is less mimetic than Southern Italy because its people are more reserved and have fewer flamboyant gestures, with the flamboyant disposition of Naples being the more mimetic element.

    “I would say that because of that, it's less mimetic than the South. I think that disposition, that flamboyant way of being, is the more mimetic thing about the South, about Naples.”

  • Burgis would not disagree with Luigi Barzini's hypothesis that Italians display cheerfulness to higher-status outsiders, and he notes that Italians apply a different standard for foreigners than for each other.

    “I think they have a different standard for foreigners like me than they do for each other.”

  • Burgis uses people's reactions to Naples after visiting as his number-one test for whether he will get along with them.

    “My test for whether or not I'll get along with somebody is their reactions to Naples after they've been there.”

0.09

Place and upbringing, such as Michigan winters and Genoa's port history, shape character and judgment.

3 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Growing up in Michigan with four seasons, a working-class background, and hard winters formed character that big-city life did not remove.

    “There's something about the Midwest that I'll never be able to take it out of me, even having lived in big cities.”

  • Genoa is the most underrated city in Italy because it has a fascinating port history, was arguably the most important city during Spain's great power period, and is less touristy than other Italian cities.

    “I think it's the most underrated city in Italy.”

  • San Francisco is still the most important city in the world, particularly because of the AI boom, and its combination of talent and culture has never been replicated elsewhere.

    “San Francisco is still the most important city in the world, particularly because of the AI boom, because it's never been replicated anywhere else.”