What this covers

Cynthia L. Haven discusses her biography of René Girard with Tyler Cowen, centering on why the book had to be written by someone outside academia. Haven argues that mimetic desire—the theory that humans copy each other's desires and converge into conformist mobs—operates as a universal feature of human nature, not a phenomenon tied to any particular political ideology. She contends that academia intensifies conformity through the pursuit of peer esteem, and that genuine independent thought often requires distance from institutional pressures. The biography itself exemplifies this dynamic: no tenured academic was willing to undertake the project, she argues, because conformist incentives made scholars reluctant to stake their reputations on a figure held at the periphery of respectability.

The conversation ranges across how mimesis manifests in contemporary life—Twitter mobs, propaganda, support for Putin and Donald Trump—and traces the same mechanisms described by Czesław Miłosz in The Captive Mind. Haven notes that Girard's theory reveals overlooked factors in human behavior after the fact rather than serving as a predictive tool, and she emphasizes his intuition for patterns of rivalry and violence. The discussion also touches on Joseph Brodsky's Russian imperialism, the puzzle of Russian citizens selectively accepting Putin's worst messages while resisting others, and how social media accelerates American conformity. Throughout, Haven and Cowen explore the tension between Girard's occasional use of absolute language and the messier reality of human behavior, and they consider why the academy is not producing a new generation of thinkers asking large questions.

Sharpest takeaway

Haven argues that René Girard's theory of mimetic desire—the idea that humans copy each other's desires and converge into scapegoating mobs—is a universal feature of human nature that explains modern conformity, and that genuine independent thought (including Girard's own biography) often must come from outside academia's conformist incentives.

  • Conformity is human nature, not a left/right or liberal/conservative phenomenon, and academia intensifies it through the desire for peer esteem
  • Girard's biography had to be written by an outsider because academics held him at a distance and would not stick their necks out
  • Modern mimesis (Twitter mobs, propaganda, Putin/Trump support) reflects the same mechanisms Miłosz and Girard described

The argument · threads7 threads · 30 claims
0.85

Mimetic desire drives humans universally to copy bad things and join mobs subliminally, regardless of political ideology or religious affiliation.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Mimesis is more universal and central in Girard than in Miłosz; it was the central point of Girard's entire body of work, treating the copying of desire as a near-universal human phenomenon.

    “It was the central point of his whole work, for René Girard. But we’re looking at human phenomena, and they’re pretty much everywhere.”

  • The labels of religions like Buddhism or Confucianism conceal millions of individuals within them, and whatever a religion preaches, mimetic behaviors persist because human behavior does not suspend itself simply because of the religious label one operates under.

    “But we use these labels of religions. There are millions of individuals within them, and whatever the religion says, there are mimetic behaviors. Human behavior doesn’t suspend itself because of the label of religion that you’re going under.”

  • People copy bad things rather than good things through mimesis because the bad things are attractive to us and we are followers; this explains phenomena like persistent support for Putin in Russia and Trump support in the US.

    “The bad things are attractive to us. We’re followers. Why has Putin still got support in Russia after what he’s doing? Why are there Trump supporters?”

  • Conformity is not inherently left or right, liberal or conservative—it is simply human nature, manifesting as a universally mimetic atmosphere (such as the pervasively Stalinist intellectual climate of postwar France) regardless of political content.

    “I don’t think conformity is left or right or liberal or conservative. It’s just human nature.”

  • People who join a mob—including internet and Twitter mobs—feel the unity and believe they are speaking up for their rights and the truth, but the momentum of a shared feeling can drive someone into a mob without their being aware that is what they are doing; it operates subliminally.

    “They think they’re speaking up for their rights. They think that what they’re saying is true.”

0.79

Academia enforces conformity through peer esteem and approval rather than fear, creating invisible boundaries beyond which innovation becomes unacceptable.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Academia permits breakthrough work only within certain confines and limits; there is an unspoken threshold past which a contribution shifts from 'innovative' to 'unacceptable or outrageous,' and the question of who decides where that line falls is itself a key constraint on independent thought.

    “one is allowed to make the great breakthrough book or whatever, as long as it’s a breakthrough within certain confines, within certain limits”

  • Academics conform not primarily out of fear of losing their jobs but because they crave esteem and approval from their peers—a desire that can be as powerful a coercive force as job insecurity.

    “One wishes for esteem. One wishes to get approval from one’s peers. That can be as powerful as the fear of losing a job.”

  • No tenured academic wrote a biography weaving together Girard's life and work because conformist incentives made people unwilling to stick their necks out and they preferred to hold him at a distance; the book only happened because Haven, as an outsider to academia, was willing to do it.

    “there had never been anything weaving together the life and the work, so the only reason that it happened is because I did it. I think that it was the core conformist thing. Nobody wanted to stick their heads out. People wanted to hold him at a distance.”

  • Being an outsider to academia, while costing the security of a salary, allowed Haven to pursue work—like the first biography of Girard—that would not necessarily have been encouraged within an academic atmosphere of strong pressure toward conformity.

    “There was an enormous pressure towards conformity within academia. Would I have been able to write the first biography of René Girard if I had been? I don’t think it’d be something that necessarily would’ve been encouraged within an academic atmosphere.”

0.65

Girard's theory reveals overlooked patterns of violence and competition but cannot predict outcomes and relies on intuition over systematic method.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Girard's theory of mimetic desire is not a prediction and cannot be used to forecast outcomes because there are too many variables in any human situation to make it foolproof; its strength is instead in revealing overlooked factors after the fact rather than in predictive testing.

    “it’s not a prediction, it’s not a way that you can predict something. I think that there are too many variables in almost any equation to make it foolproof in that sense.”

  • Girard's defining talent as a thinker was intuition—the ability to see patterns of competition, rivalry, and violence that no one else saw—culminating in his religious intuition that the New Testament moves humanity from the kingdom of violence to the kingdom of God.

    “Intuition. The way he saw these patterns, and saw patterns that no one else did, of competition, rivalry, violence.”

  • Girard's greatest flaw as a thinker was an unfortunate tendency to use absolute terms like 'always' or 'never'; under more thorough questioning he would qualify these, but the absolutist phrasing has been seized on by critics as a weakness.

    “he had an unfortunate tendency to say “always” or “never.” If you quizzed him more thoroughly, he would say, “No, not always” or whatever, but I think that that has sometimes been tackled on by people as a flaw.”

  • Peter Thiel's most enduring contribution is not his effect on Silicon Valley technology but his message about human behavior—a call for universal forgiveness, independence, and resisting the mimetic copying of others' desires.

    “his effect on human behavior, his call for universal forgiveness, his call for being more independent, not being mimetic, and all into one’s desires — I think that those are his enduring messages that are more important than the world of technology”

0.65

Literature and humanistic education, increasingly endangered by institutional decline, strengthen resistance to mimetic conformity and bad models.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Miłosz's future as a thinker is threatened because he is a poet and poetry is no longer taught as it once was; the humanities have declined, which limits his reach even though, as a non-systematic poetic thinker, he still has an enormous amount to say to people today.

    “He’s a poet, and I think that that’s a problem, as poetry — well, it’s not taught the way it was. The humanities have somewhat gone by the wayside”

  • Valuing literature, poetry, and intelligent speaking in public life increases the likelihood of good ideas getting through and reduces the likelihood of producing poor political candidates—you have a better chance of something good getting through reading Miłosz than reading Twitter feeds.

    “there’s a better chance of something good getting through if you’re reading Czesław Miłosz than if you are reading Twitter feeds. If we valued intelligent thinking, intelligent speaking in our public lives, I think we’d be less likely to get the kind of candidates that we’re getting.”

  • Aphorisms, such as Simone Weil's 'Distance is the soul of beauty,' are a powerful way to learn, even when a thinker does not cohere into a systematic worldview the way Schopenhauer or Nietzsche do.

    “Aphorisms are a powerful way to learn.”

  • American mimesis is accelerated by social media, and the national value system has become so seduced by commercial forces—crappy commercials and memes—that serious thinking is hard to find; because models like Trump shape what people imitate, only changing what Americans admire through the humanities can prevent the worst models from rising to the fore.

    “It’s our willingness to believe. I think our value system has become so seduced by commercial forces, it’s hard to find serious forms of thinking.”

0.52

Twentieth-century thinkers like Miłosz and Girard resist easy political categorization and addressed conformity's pressures through poetic and intuitive work.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Girard held that Judaism and Christianity, beginning with Judaism, were the first religions to focus in such a concentrated way on competition, strife, the reasons for conflict, and the pressures to scapegoat.

    “Christianity and Judaism — beginning with Judaism — were the first religions to focus in such a concentrated way on competition, strife, and the reasons for conflict, and the pressures to scapegoat”

  • Political terms like 'liberal' and 'conservative' shifted so quickly with the rise of Stalinism and changes in Europe that thinkers like Girard and Miłosz are hard to place politically, suggesting these categories carry more assumed fixed meaning than they actually have.

    “the terms changed so quickly with the rise of Stalinism, with what was happening in Europe, that suddenly the terms keep shifting, and it’s hard to place any of them politically”

  • Beginning in the 1970s Miłosz was preoccupied with the loss of what he called 'second space'—the religious dimension in human thinking and any notion beyond the immediate here and now—which he saw as a powerful and troubling absence in modern life.

    “He was fascinated, beginning in the 1970s, with the loss of what he called “second space,” with the loss of the religious dimension in human thinking, with the loss of any notion beyond the little here and the little now.”

  • Miłosz's The Captive Mind has been continuously in print and a bestseller since 1953 because it still speaks to present-day audiences about conformity and the pressures to comply, captured in his metaphor of the 'Murti-Bing pill.'

    “That is his only book that has been continuously in print and a best seller since it was published in 1953... about the conformity, about the pressures to what he called the Murti-Bing pill.”

0.40

Outsider status to institutional systems enables intellectual work that institutional conformity would discourage or suppress.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Starting as a teenage reporter teaches transferable skills—performing on deadline, accepting editing without ego, flexibility, and how to ask questions and conduct interviews—that carry over into serious intellectual work.

    “It teaches you to perform on deadline. It teaches you not to object to your work getting edited, which is a problem with a lot of authors. It teaches you to be flexible. It teaches you how to ask questions.”

  • The great living-legend scholars Haven profiled—figures like Robert Conquest, Joseph Frank, and Carl Weber—have died within a few years of her meeting them, and despite our mimetic culture, the academy is not reproducing thinkers who ask the big questions to replace them.

    “they all died within a few years of my getting to know them. That’s the problem of dealing with the old giants — the old giants tend to disappear. I asked the same questions you’re asking. Who replaces them? Who’s asking the big questions?”

0.18

Brodsky's poetic survival depends on translation fidelity, and Russian imperialism reflects deeper cultural patterns beyond individual leaders.

3 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Girard did not in fact witness a lynching, because a lynching is not something one can watch from a distance—you are either among the people throwing stones or you are the victim; its very nature draws participants in rather than allowing detached observation.

    “He hadn’t seen a lynching. You don’t go and watch a lynching. You’re either one of the people throwing the stones or you’re the lynchee. It has that kind of attraction; it’s not something that you can watch from far away.”

  • Brodsky will never die in Russia as one of the great poets of the 20th century, but his survival in America depends on future translations because the wordplay and inventiveness of his poems are extremely difficult to render in English.

    “In Russia, he will never die. He’s one of the great poets of the 20th century. In America, I think a lot of it depends on the future translations. The wordplay in his poems, the inventiveness is such that it makes it very difficult to squash it into the English language.”

  • Brodsky's hostility toward Ukraine and smaller nations reflected a Russian national imperialism that is not unique to Putin but runs 'all the way down' through Russian culture as a strong, persistent streak.

    “There’s a national imperialism of Russia that is not just Putin. It goes all the way down.”