right to be forgotten
A European legal right requiring search engines to remove, on petition, old, invalid, or false information about an individual from search results.
As defined in Gillian Hadfield on Law and Rules For a Flat World
Where it comes up · 4
- Let Me Be Forgotten (with Lowry Pressly)3 claims
- Jimmy Wales1 claim
- Gillian Hadfield on Law and Rules For a Flat World1 claim
- Citation Needed: Provenance for LLM-Built Knowledge Graphs — Daniel Chalef, Zep AI1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “right to be forgotten” →
- Privacy compliance (right to be forgotten, retention policies) requires the ability to delete source data, but with context derived from multiple sources, the question arises: if only some source data needs to be deleted (not all), how do you safely delete without breaking derived facts?Citation Needed: Provenance for LLM-Built Knowledge Graphs — Daniel Chalef, Zep AI
- In roughly the past decade it has become common practice to Google people before meeting them—essentially turning everyone into private detectives who compile a dossier on the people they are about to meet—and this strange transformation has receded into invisibility precisely because it has become normal.Let Me Be Forgotten (with Lowry Pressly)
- Being able to forget one's past missteps, and having others not know about one's past, makes one a better, less anxious agent and makes the future seem more open and possible—the ability to be different from how one was; this applies both to individual memory and to the collective memory of society.Let Me Be Forgotten (with Lowry Pressly)
- Europe's right-to-be-forgotten ruling forces search engines like Google to adjudicate requests (reportedly around 500 a day) to remove old or false information, but because governments lack the capacity and technology to implement it, the adjudication is handed to Google to regulate itself—a problematic single private regulator rather than a competitive, accountable one.Gillian Hadfield on Law and Rules For a Flat World
- Permanently attaching the worst thing about a person's past to them—so that everyone learns it before even hearing the person's name—is a modern digital version of criminal branding, which is barbaric not because it causes physical pain or protects others (most violent crime is committed by first offenders and people the victim knows) but because it crushes the person's sense that they could ever be different, inflicting an immense injury on their sense of self as an agent.Let Me Be Forgotten (with Lowry Pressly)
- The European right to be forgotten as currently enshrined is deeply flawed because Google can be forced—without any judge involved—to delist perfectly legal content that remains on a publisher's website, which by American First Amendment logic is like banning a legal magazine from being sold in stores; if content is egregious enough to censor, a judge, not a company, should decide.Jimmy Wales