right of return
The Palestinian demand that refugees from the 1948 war and their descendants be allowed to return to homes inside present-day Israel; Friedman argues fulfilling it would make Israel an Arab-majority state.
As defined in The Challenge of Covering the Most Important Story on Earth (with Matti Friedman)
Other definitions
The Palestinian demand to reclaim lost property and homeland within the territory that is now Israel; Gur argues it is a historically unique demand for return to specific geography inside another sovereign state.
An Extraordinary Introduction to the Birth of Israel and the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Haviv Rettig Gur)
Where it comes up · 12
- Mohammed El2 claims
- An Extraordinary Introduction to the Birth of Israel and the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Haviv Rettig Gur)1 claim
- The Challenge of Covering the Most Important Story on Earth (with Matti Friedman)1 claim
- Voices from Gaza (with Ahmed Alkhatib)1 claim
- 340 - The Bright Line Between Good And Evil1 claim
- 393 - Is History Repeating Itself1 claim
- 357 - America World Order1 claim
- 351 - 5 Myths About Israel And The War In Gaza1 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “right of return” →
- The right of return should be realized largely in the West Bank and Gaza rather than inside Israel; it was a chronic failure of Palestinian leadership not to establish a state and resettle refugees in the West Bank after 1948 and 1967 when those territories were under Jordanian and Egyptian control, and Israel should compensate and help build new Palestinian communities as part of territorial swaps and the decommissioning of UNRWA.Voices from Gaza (with Ahmed Alkhatib)
- The Palestinian demand for a right of return to specific geography within another sovereign state is historically unique—while several nations (Greece, Ireland, Israel) offer fast-tracked naturalization to those of their heritage, no one claims a right of return to a geographic location inside another state, and notably nobody claims that right for the Jews displaced from Arab lands in the same conflict at the same time.An Extraordinary Introduction to the Birth of Israel and the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Haviv Rettig Gur)
- The Jews in Israel are an indigenous people with a continuous presence in the land for thousands of years, unlike colonialists who have somewhere to return to; most recent Jewish immigrants were driven from Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Libya and other Muslim-majority countries by their neighbors after 1948 as collective punishment, yet no one discusses their right of return while only the Palestinian right of return has become a global fetish.340 - The Bright Line Between Good And Evil
- Based on nearly 30 years as a journalist there, Friedman holds that there are very few Palestinians who genuinely support a two-state solution and those who do have almost no significance to political outcomes; Hamas is openly committed to eradicating the Jews, and the Fatah-dominated Palestinian Authority pays lip service to two states while demanding a 'right of return' that would turn Israel into an Arab state — a demand that necessarily precludes two states.The Challenge of Covering the Most Important Story on Earth (with Matti Friedman)
- Jews are among the indigenous people of the region given a continuous presence for thousands of years, and Israel is not unique in being created by outside powers drawing lines on maps — Pakistan was created the same year and the same way without anyone questioning its right to exist, while the world contains over 50 Muslim-majority states and only one Jewish state, which alone must perpetually defend its legitimacy.351 - 5 Myths About Israel And The War In Gaza
- When you've controlled an area since 1967 you can no longer call it an occupation but an annexation, because Israel—not Hamas—is the sovereign and final decision maker over the biggest questions in Gaza, which undermines Israel's claim to be a democracy when millions cannot vote over who rules them.Dave Smith
- Hamas now talks about a right of return rather than elimination of Israel, though deep anti-Semitic rhetoric and hate speech continue to emanate from Hamas.Rory Stewart Attempts to Explain the History of Israel-Palestine in 10 Minutes
- A negotiated Israel-Palestine peace deal already exists on the shelf with the Saudis, Palestinians, Israelis, and even Hamas roughly agreeing: Israel exits the West Bank and Gaza but keeps a percentage for settlements, no general right of return (only symbolic), in exchange for safety and an end to rockets; the number one person blocking it is Netanyahu, who publicly opposes a two-state solution.Cenk Uygur
- The book 'Israel on the Brink' imagines a 2048 transition to a single post-Zionist democratic state through a series of detailed diary entries (4th and 5th Intifada, Palestinian right of return, land redistribution, street renaming, monument removal, settlement dismantling/repurposing), showing that even for Zionists who fear this outcome, the practical mechanisms are imaginable and possible.Ilan Pappé on Israel and Epstein and Why Zionism has No Moral Limits
- Justice comes about through recognition, return, and redistribution: recognition of the Nakba, the right of return for millions of Palestinian refugees to their homes, and redistribution of land and wealth, including reversing the 1960s classification of 90% of historic Palestine as state-owned land that was taken from Palestinian farmers.Mohammed El