returns to skill
The wage premium earned by higher-skilled workers; debated as to whether it has collapsed post-2000 due to automation/AI.
As defined in Claudia Goldin
Where it comes up · 4
- John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate3 claims
- Claudia Goldin1 claim
- Edward Glaeser on Cities1 claim
- Ran Abramitzky on the Mystery of the Kibbutz1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “returns to skill” →
- The comeback of older cities since the 1970s was driven mostly by economic change, not city policy: globalization and new technology raised the returns to skill and the value of information-intensive industries that have always benefited from urban proximity—finance in New York (43% of Manhattan payroll in 2007), biotech and sciences in Boston, and software/retail entrepreneurship in Seattle (Amazon, Microsoft, Costco, Starbucks).Edward Glaeser on Cities
- Rising inequality persists because the normal market mechanism that equalizes returns to skill is blocked: when returns to a skill rise, people should acquire that skill (as horse-shoers became car mechanics), but America's broken education system, restrictive zoning, and restrictive immigration prevent people from moving into high-return work or locations, so inequality is a downstream symptom of these specific policy failures.John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
- Not everyone needs to enter STEM fields for equalization to occur: if the talented 10% who can do STEM move into it, that drives down the returns to STEM and raises returns to other work, and immigrants who start businesses hire low-skilled workers, so a society where people can move freely and use varied skills equalizes on its own without a bureaucracy picking which fields will be valuable.John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
- Inequality is a symptom rather than a cause of economic problems: what people actually worry about is whether the bulk of people are getting ahead, and stagnating middle incomes reflect slow growth; income is 'earned by' new people who acquired high-return skills, not 'distributed to,' so redistributing money while leaving the underlying policy distortions unfixed makes matters worse.John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
- The economy's skill demand is shifting from manual to motor to mental and now to social skills, with David Deming's work showing enormous demand for social skills; we understand the demand for social skills far better than how to increase their supply.Claudia Goldin
- When Israel transformed from a poor egalitarian agricultural economy into a high-tech innovation leader, returns to skill rose dramatically, giving talented kibbutz members far better outside options in the city and making kibbutz life relatively less attractive—a key driver of the inevitable shift away from equal sharing.Ran Abramitzky on the Mystery of the Kibbutz