repugnant conclusion
Derek Parfit's result that total utilitarianism implies a sufficiently large population of lives barely worth living is better than a smaller population of extremely happy lives.
As defined in ms_207
Where it comes up · 15
- Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion7 claims
- 321 - Reckoning With Parfit3 claims
- William MacAskill2 claims
- John Gray1 claim
- Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler1 claim
- Sam Bankman-Fried1 claim
- 44 - Being Good And Doing Good1 claim
- 342 - Animal Minds Moral Truths1 claim
and 7 more
Most important claims · 10 of 24Search all claims for “repugnant conclusion” →
- The repugnant conclusion is that for any population of very happy people, there must exist a much larger population—possibly trillions—whose lives are barely worth living that is a better outcome, a conclusion Parfit found counterintuitive yet could not escape through any robust argument.321 - Reckoning With Parfit
- Parfit's repugnant conclusion shows that through a series of individually plausible steps one can move from a large population living extremely good lives to a vastly larger population living lives barely worth living, judged better; Parfit sought a coherent 'Theory X' that avoids this conclusion but never found it, and Singer believes no one has convincingly done so.342 - Animal Minds Moral Truths
- Every moral view, not just consequentialism, faces extremely unintuitive implications in population ethics—this has been formally proven—because every view must decide under what conditions bringing a new flourishing life into existence is good; so paradoxes like the repugnant conclusion don't single out consequentialism, and abandoning consequentialism over them would require something more radical like abandoning moral consistency itself.William MacAskill
- If you hold that any human life has positive value, utilitarianism quickly implies the morally right thing is simply to increase the number of people regardless of anything else—Derek Parfit's 'repugnant conclusion'—showing that maximizing an aggregate utility number conflicts with our moral intuitions.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- Parfit's repugnant conclusion follows from variable-population ethics: starting from world A with billions of very happy people, one can move stepwise through worlds of slightly lower happiness for ever-larger populations until reaching world Z with an enormous population whose lives are barely worth living—yet which, by summing total happiness, comes out as 'better,' a conclusion most find repugnant.446 - How To Do The Most Good
- The repugnant conclusion follows from a chain where each step seems an improvement: adding lower-but-positive lives harms no one, then leveling everyone toward equality at a slightly lower top raises total well-being and equality, and repeating this process drives the population toward enormous numbers of barely-worth-living lives, with no obvious point at which the chain can be stopped.321 - Reckoning With Parfit
- Parfit's repugnant conclusion — that a vast population of lives barely worth living can be better than a smaller population of excellent lives because total utility is higher — is blocked by anti-natalism, since the asymmetry denies that adding further people (who gain absent goods but incur real harms) is ever warranted, and many population paradoxes themselves stem from the non-identity problem that anti-natalism dissolves.107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living
- There are inherent limits to moral reasoning that no alternative theory will tidily resolve: we cannot fully transcend partiality because moral reasoning is embedded in a context of being partial about some things, which is why paradoxes like Pascal's wager, the 51/49 gamble, and the repugnant conclusion all kick in once reasoning is stretched far enough.William MacAskill
- Parfit's repugnant conclusion follows from utilitarianism: since more lives saved is always better and more people is better, the optimal world is one with a huge number of people all living barely above subsistence—like the slums of Bangladesh universalized—because the summed wellbeing of many barely-tolerable lives exceeds that of fewer flourishing ones.Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion
- The repugnant conclusion is not a niche academic edge case from population ethics that only manifests at extremes; it is one clear instance of how utilitarianism is constantly forced into violating obvious moral principles (like not murdering people for organs), such that repugnancy can be found even in the smallest applications.Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion