relations of ideas
Analytic logical truths that cannot be false because they are true by definition or by virtue of the logical identity of concepts (e.g., 'a equals a'); includes definitions, tautologies, and mathematical truths
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
Where it comes up · 2
- A History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?5 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics2 claims
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “relations of ideas” →
- Hume's skepticism is mitigated, not absolute, because we do have knowledge of relations of ideas (analytic judgments with logical form); skepticism applies only to matters of fact, which are contingent rather than logically necessary and therefore cannot be demonstratively provenA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
- Hume's skepticism about the possibility of a priori proof of God's existence is based on the distinction between relations of ideas (analytic, logically necessary) and matters of fact (contingent, empirically known); since God's existence is contingent, not logically necessary, no a priori proof is possibleA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
- Hume argues that relations of ideas (a priori arguments) cannot establish matters of fact conclusions about God's existence because logical necessity does not carry over to contingent realityA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
- In Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, the three main characters (Demea, Cleanthes, and Philo) represent different epistemological approaches to knowledge of God's existence: Cleanthes employs empirical arguments (cosmological and teleological), Demea employs a priori arguments from relations of ideas, and Philo is skeptical of bothA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
- Relations of ideas are analytic judgments with the logical form 'a equals a', which include definitions, tautologies, and mathematicsA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
- For Hume, reason's role in ethics is limited to two functions: providing definitions of moral terms and relations of ideas (like defining justice, comparing benevolence and self-interest), and describing factual circumstances and consequences of actions, but reason cannot approve or disapprove actions, cannot justify appeals to utility or consequences, and cannot motivate action.A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics
- For Locke, moral knowledge is demonstrative knowledge like mathematics—claims about property rights and justice can be evaluated by comparing ideas and finding agreement or disagreement between them, making morality a matter of rational relations of ideas rather than sentiment or emotion.A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics