referee
The expert who reviews a submitted paper for a journal; in a blind review the author does not know the referee's identity.
As defined in Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen
Where it comes up · 2
- Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen2 claims
- Timothy Taylor on Government vs. Business1 claim
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “referee” →
- When the British Medical Journal under Richard Smith deliberately inserted major and minor errors into papers and sent them to standard reviewers, on average across three studies reviewers caught only about 25% of the errors; even a key error like a non-random randomization in a supposedly randomized controlled trial was found by only about half of reviewers.Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen
- Most people misunderstand peer review as a checking process, but in fact nobody is usually looking at the data or rerunning the analysis—because doing so requires opening datasets (often not provided) and redoing analyses, which is a major undertaking—so the most important thing review could do is virtually never done; reviewers instead render an aesthetic judgment.Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen
- Articles in the leading research journal, the American Economic Review, are now on average almost three times as long in page count as 30-40 years ago, more likely to have many co-authors and lengthy appendices, and more likely to be detailed empirical studies—with publication delays of 3-5 years that lead researchers to rely on working-paper versions posted online instead.Timothy Taylor on Government vs. Business