What this covers

Timothy Taylor and Russ Roberts examine how American politics and policy have confused the economic roles of government and business. Taylor argues that we have inverted these roles: we expect firms to solve distributional problems (through wage mandates, job training, and benefits) while we rely on government to spur economic growth through stimulus and low interest rates. Instead, Taylor contends, each institution should operate within its Core Competency. Companies excel at production and innovation; government's strength lies in collecting revenue, writing checks, and enforcing rules. The conversation ranges across implications for worker welfare, corporate structure, and the design of effective policy—including how wage mandates, whether through direct mandate or minimum-wage increases, always extract costs from somewhere, costs that an honest accounting must identify and weigh.

The episode explores several territories. Taylor documents that Soft Budget Constraint problems plague government-run enterprises, which can simply request more funds when finances deteriorate, whereas for-profit firms face hard constraints that force difficult choices. He traces how policy often loads distributional goals onto producers—fuel-economy standards, trade protectionism, wage rules—because this keeps costs off-budget and avoids the political pain of raising taxes; he argues this interferes with production without properly weighing tradeoffs. Drawing on John Stuart Mill's distinction between the physical act of production and the institutional outcomes of distribution, Taylor suggests that Separation of Production and Distribution clarifies which tool fits which problem. The discussion also covers how R&D has shifted from large internal labs at firms like AT&T and DuPont toward smaller venture-backed companies bought out at the proof of concept stage, and debates whether Walmart's low wages reflect exploitation or whether wage subsidy through expanded Earned Income Tax Credit would better serve low-skilled workers than employer mandates.

Sharpest takeaway

Taylor argues that public discourse has inverted the proper roles of government and business: we wrongly look to government to generate growth and to firms to deliver justice, when in fact firms' core competency is production and government's is collecting money, writing checks, and setting rules—so redistribution should run through government, not be loaded onto companies.

  • Companies' core competency is producing and transforming goods/services; government's is collecting money, writing checks, and enforcing rules
  • Long-term prosperity comes from firms innovating, not from low interest rates and government spending after a recession ends
  • Distribution concerns should be funded through transparent government redistribution rather than mandates on producers

The argument · threads8 threads · 30 claims
0.85

Redistribution should run through government's core competency of collecting and disbursing funds, not burden employers.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • If you want to improve the lives of low-paid workers, you should not make their current employers pay for it, because doing so encourages employers to hire fewer of them; instead, if redistribution is socially valuable, it should run through the government—whose core competency is collecting money and writing checks—as with an expanded Earned Income Tax Credit, leaving the production side to operate as it does best.

    “Why would you make the people who are currently employing them pay for that? Because that encourages them not to do as much of it.”

  • Government-run enterprises operate under 'soft budget constraints'—when they do poorly they don't go broke, lay off workers, cut pay, or reduce output; they simply ask the government for more money—whereas for-profit firms like Walmart face hard budget constraints and must make their costs balance, which is why you cannot simply snap your fingers and make money for higher wages appear.

    “when government ran enterprises in Hungary back in the old days, if a company was, you know, doing poorly, the company didn't go broke; it didn't lay off workers; it didn't cut pay. It didn't even reduce output. It had a soft budget constraint.”

  • Following John Stuart Mill's 1848 distinction, production has a physical character (putting things together to make goods and services) while distribution is the outcome of human institutions and decisions; although you cannot fully separate them, when you dislike a distributional outcome it is useful to ask whether you care enough to pay higher taxes for redistribution—and if not, perhaps you don't care enough to enact it by forcing someone else to bear the cost.

    “this goes back at least to John Stuart Mill's 1848 book, where there's one book on production and another book on distribution... production has sort of a physical character... And distribution is the outcome of human institutions and human decisions”

  • Politicians prefer to blame producers for distributional problems and pass rules requiring firms to fix them—protectionist trade legislation, fuel economy standards, wage mandates—because this keeps the cost off the budget and avoids the political danger of taking money from people via taxes, but this interferes with production for distributional reasons without taking costs and benefits into account.

    “It's always nice to make a pronouncement that the problem should be fixed by someone else. And it's even better if you can pass a rule or a law that says the problem should be fixed by someone else. And you don't have to--doesn't have to be on the budget.”

0.78

Government and business have inverted roles; each should operate within its actual competency, not the other's.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • We are in danger of treating the private sector as a golden goose we can simply command to do things—provide job training, build affordable housing, clean up the environment—when what we really want firms to do is engage in the capitalistic competition of making things better, not compete on who can survive the ordeal of getting a zoning permit.

    “I think that we are in danger of looking at the private sector as that golden goose, that we can just tell it to do things.”

  • Society has inverted the proper roles of government and business: we rely on capitalism for justice (which it cannot produce, as it only generates winners, energy, and growth) and on government for economic stimulation, when reason suggests the opposite—government should channel the energy and growth produced by capitalism into socially useful avenues without stifling it.

    “We have come to rely upon capitalism for justice and the government for economic stimulation, precisely the opposite of what reason would suggest.”

  • The core competency of companies is producing, transforming, and tweaking things to sell them; the core competency of government is collecting money from people who don't want to pay, writing checks, and setting and enforcing rules—but government is often not good at the intimate, small-scale work of making, changing, and providing services, so policy should draw the line between these two competencies.

    “the real core competency of government on the other side, it seems to me, is that it can collect money; it's good at collecting money from people who don't necessarily want to pay; it's good at writing checks; and it's good at setting up a set of rules and then at some level enforcing those rules.”

0.64

Startup and entrepreneurship rates have declined for decades; popular booming narratives ignore the statistical reality of concentration.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The rate of startups in the U.S. economy has been steadily diminishing not just since the Recession but since the late 1990s, and a smaller share of the workforce now works for smaller companies than it did 10-20 years ago, contrary to the popular impression that entrepreneurship is booming because we only see the winners.

    “There is evidence out there, the last 10 or 15 years that the rate of startups in the U.S. economy has been steadily diminishing--not just since the Recession, but since the late 1990s.”

  • Over the last 20-30 years, large companies with massive internal R&D labs (like the old AT&T or DuPont) have effectively outsourced their R&D: tiny companies funded by venture capitalists and angel investors pursue innovations hoping to hit a home run, and big companies buy them out at the proof-of-concept stage, so the big firms specialize in putting it together and taking it to scale rather than basic science.

    “a lot of the big companies have in a weird way outsourced their R&D. And they are hoping to jump in at the key moment when something has an appropriate proof of concept”

  • Large companies can become fossilized and bureaucratic, making large internal R&D efforts inefficient because they are hard to monitor and spur to great work; firms like Google distinguish themselves by a venture-capital-like willingness to publicly drop and cut projects rather than ignore sunk costs and keep funding failing initiatives.

    “Google does seem to have an ability to at various times to say, 'Well, that's not working and we're just shutting that down.'... I think it's almost a venture-capital-like ability”

0.56

Government has legitimate countercyclical recession roles but should not manage long-term prosperity through spending and rates.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The federal government is essentially a health care operation, a retirement operation (Social Security), defense, and interest on the national debt—everything else is small—so casual proposals to do more on R&D or cash redistribution fall largely outside what government treats as its core responsibilities.

    “the Federal government is, it's a health care operation; it's a retirement operation with Social Security; it's defense; it's interest on the national debt. And everything else is not very big.”

  • There is a legitimate countercyclical role for government during a recession—running deficits, extra spending, tax cuts, and Fed rate cuts—but once you are out of recession and unemployment is around 5%, long-term prosperity is built on firms creating new products and services, not on low interest rates and high government spending.

    “In the long run, prosperity is going to be built on the actions of firms creating new products and goods and services.”

0.44

Economic research and public discourse suffer from hyper-specialization, lengthy articles, and difficulty translating findings accessibly.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The Journal of Economic Perspectives was created in the 1980s as a deliberately non-peer-reviewed journal that invites active researchers to write opinionated essays answering 'what do we know in your area that we didn't know 5-10 years ago and what should we be thinking about going forward,' addressing the problem that hyper-specialization made it hard for economists in one subfield to read research in another.

    “the notion was to have one journal which would not be peer reviewed. Instead, we ask the people to write... 'What do we know in your area of research that we didn't know 5 or 10 years ago, and what should we be thinking about, looking forward?'”

  • Despite the proliferation of web outlets giving gifted expositors more places to publish, it has not become easier to get accessible writing from hard-core research economists, who when taken out of their comfort zone and asked to write an explanatory essay find it very difficult—often submitting drafts twice the requested length filled with equations.

    “this week I've been working on an article where the first draft came in at 15,000 words of main text; and half of it was equations.”

  • Articles in the leading research journal, the American Economic Review, are now on average almost three times as long in page count as 30-40 years ago, more likely to have many co-authors and lengthy appendices, and more likely to be detailed empirical studies—with publication delays of 3-5 years that lead researchers to rely on working-paper versions posted online instead.

    “articles now are on average almost three times as long as they were, in page count, 30 or 40 years ago. They are also much more likely to have lots of co-authors rather than being single-authored papers.”

  • We started and won World War II in roughly a third of the time it has taken to rebuild the World Trade Center site, illustrating a decline in social flexibility and the ability to deploy resources for large projects.

    “we started and won and fought WWII in roughly a third of the time it's taking to rebuild the site at the World Trade Center.”

0.43

Market diversity across retail and business models serves real consumer needs; homogenizing businesses to one standard ignores genuine differences.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Market heterogeneity—the extraordinary variety of goods offered at upscale, downscale, and in-between levels—is valuable and attractive; not every retail establishment needs to be the kind of place an upscale critic would shop, and the desire to make everything conform to one model (e.g., 'why can't everything be like Costco') ignores that businesses are genuinely different operations.

    “he used to say, 'Everyone has a right to buy inferior merchandise.'”

  • When Steve Jobs died there was an outpouring of emotional support celebrating him despite his being as ruthless a capitalist as there has been who never gave to charity, whereas Sam Walton received no comparable praise—reflecting a class-based difference in which upscale capitalism is celebrated while downscale variety is disdained.

    “Steve Jobs was, you know, as ruthless a capitalist as there's been... at that moment, though, it was okay that he was a ruthless capitalist... when Sam Walton died, I don't know if there's the same feeling”

0.43

Government should invest substantially more in R&D and worker retraining, addressing skill and geographic immobility traps.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Beyond direct cash redistribution, government could take more seriously a role in worker training and in helping people relocate geographically from places with few jobs to places with more opportunity, addressing the legitimate sense that many people are trapped without skills, alternatives, or the ability to move—so that they feel they are getting all the disruption of the American bargain and none of the opportunity.

    “take more seriously the notion of its having a role in training; having a role in mobility and helping people get from one place where maybe there aren't so many jobs to another place where there might be more jobs.”

  • There are good economic arguments for government to support scientific research and R&D, and we should seriously consider doubling government support for R&D or more, because the risk is underspending rather than overspending—it is better to fund more across many categories than to worry about excess.

    “I actually am a supporter of the idea that we should think seriously over time about doubling our government support of research and development or more.”

0.43

Wage and redistribution mandates require tradeoffs; honest policy must specify which cost-bearing mechanism is chosen.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Airport security would work better if run by private companies with government setting rules and testing the system, rather than the current model where government workers provide the service and government administrators oversee them, because neither the workers nor administrators face the threat of being fired.

    “I would much, much prefer the old days where those were run by private companies and the job of the government was to set rules and go in there and try to beat the system and check out how well they were doing.”

  • An increase in the minimum wage requires the extra money to come from somewhere—fewer workers hired, more productivity demanded, cut job perks, higher consumer prices, or lower other wages—so any honest evaluation must specify where the cost falls and weigh that tradeoff, rather than assuming the money simply appears.

    “the extra money for that minimum wage, it has to come from someplace. And maybe it comes from hiring fewer workers or maybe it comes from more productivity or maybe it comes from cutting certain job perks or it comes from higher prices to consumers or it comes from lower wages--but it comes from some place.”