factual

Reviewers catch only 25% of inserted errors

When the British Medical Journal under Richard Smith deliberately inserted major and minor errors into papers and sent them to standard reviewers, on average across three studies reviewers caught only about 25% of the errors; even a key error like a non-random randomization in a supposedly randomized controlled trial was found by only about half of reviewers.

factualpending

Speaker

Adam Mastroianni

Evidence Quote

“On average across the three studies that they did on this, it was about 25%.”

Source

Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:08:52 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...