prudence
In classical and medieval philosophy, the virtue of practical wisdom that recognizes the limits of one's knowledge and the fallibility of human judgment, disposing one to caution, humility, and restraint in decision-making.
As defined in Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God
Where it comes up · 3
- Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God7 claims
- Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism3 claims
- Howard Marks Warning: Why I'm Getting Out Now1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “prudence” →
- Totalitarian and mass-murderous ideologies (communism, Nazism) typically spring from rationalist certainty that the leaders 'know the truth' about history or race and therefore have justification to eliminate those perceived as obstacles to the predetermined good outcome; they exemplify the absence of prudence.Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God
- David Hume, though an agnostic who rejects God, nonetheless employs the same epistemic humility and critique of dogmatism that characterizes Augustinian philosophy, suggesting that the 'cash value' of the Augustinian stance is independent of its theological scaffolding.Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God
- The virtue of Job and Augustine's response to evil is prudence—recognizing that as a non-omniscient being, one cannot judge God's justice; apparent injustices may be just from a divine perspective that humans cannot see; faith means accepting this epistemic limitation.Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God
- The American founders' prudential assumption that good people might be wrong (expressed in constitutional checks and balances) derives partly from a Calvinist/Puritan background that inherits Augustinian theology of human sinfulness and limitation.Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God
- American political history has been dominated by an ethos of prudence (inherited from Calvinism) that limits violence and restraint compared to rationalist/humanist revolutions; the American Revolution beheaded no one and tortured few Tories, whereas rationalist revolutions (French, communist) fill mass graves because they assume ideological certainty.Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God
- Dogmatism (the belief that one knows the truth absolutely) necessarily entails intolerance, because if you possess truth, there is no rational reason to listen to dissenting opinions; toleration only makes sense from an Augustinian stance that acknowledges human epistemic limits.Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God
- For Burke, as for Hume and the entire English tradition of political and moral thought, prudence is the great virtue, distinguishing English-speaking empirical philosophers from continental rationalists whose alternative great virtue is ruthlessness—the willingness to take an idea as far as it can possibly go regardless of common sense.Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism
- Rational risk minimization is a good thing and prudence is a virtue, but prudence is not the only virtue, and taken to an extreme, prudence may be sometimes a vice, whereas prudence has no understanding of the heroic virtues that attach to ruthlessness.Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism
- Prudence—the virtue of recognizing the limits of one's own knowledge and deferring to higher authority (divine wisdom)—is the fundamental virtue that prevents both theological and political tyranny, and it grounds the stability of prudent governments like the American and British systems.Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God
- Burke limits what might be called the standard deviation of virtue and vice; you don't get too bad and don't get too good, having more or less what you had before and able to make things a little better, but Burke counsels against getting out of hand or getting enthusiastic, and prudence can sometimes be a vice as well as being a virtue.Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism