primary adversary
The single most threatening enemy a state faces, which Paine uses as the key variable for predicting alignments; whoever a state most fears (e.g., whoever wants to nuke it) is its primary adversary.
As defined in Sarah Paine — The war for India (lecture & interview)
Where it comes up · 2
- Sarah Paine — The war for India (lecture & interview)4 claims
- How Hitler almost starved Britain – Sarah Paine2 claims
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “primary adversary” →
- When the Soviets asked the US in 1969 whether it was acceptable to nuke China during the border conflict and the US said no, Mao deduced that whoever wants to nuke you is your primary adversary; this shifted the alignment so that the US was no longer the primary enemy of both, but Russia and China became each other's primary adversaries, giving the US the swing position to team up with China and overextend the USSR.Sarah Paine — The war for India (lecture & interview)
- Alliances are held together not by shared ideology but by a common primary enemy that poses an existential threat; the WWII Allies (Britain, US, USSR) had mutually exclusive end goals yet cooperated because eliminating Hitler was a common way station, whereas the Axis shared fascist ideology but had different primary enemies and theaters, so they fought parallel wars and were defeated in detail.Sarah Paine — The war for India (lecture & interview)
- Common enemies cannot be conjured into existence, so before intervening one must check the actual alignments—each player's primary objective, primary adversary, and primary theater of interest—for all possible players who might crash the party, because countries sharing a primary enemy and existential threat will cooperate even if unlikely partners, while ideological allies without a shared primary enemy will not.Sarah Paine — The war for India (lecture & interview)
- Because the US shared no primary adversary with either India or Pakistan, any arms or aid given to one would be aimed at the other, so the US could not befriend both; befriending one necessarily made it the enemy of the other, leaving the US with no playable cards in the regional game.Sarah Paine — The war for India (lecture & interview)
- A useful analytical exercise is to write down each power's primary, secondary, and tertiary adversaries; doing this for WWI reveals nothing aligns—the powers were fighting parallel wars with conflicting objectives—which is why no one could exit the war without someone's primary objective being violated.How Hitler almost starved Britain – Sarah Paine
- The strategic trick today, mirroring how German invasion glued the Anglo-Soviet alliance by making Germany the primary enemy of both, is to avoid doing things that make the United States the primary enemy of both Xi Jinping and Putin—currently their primary problems are each other and their neighbors, and keeping them divided is essential.How Hitler almost starved Britain – Sarah Paine