premature deindustrialization
The phenomenon where developing countries see manufacturing's share of employment decline before they reach high income levels, unlike historically industrialized nations.
As defined in Chris Blattman
Where it comes up · 6
- Dani Rodrik4 claims
- Dani Rodrik on Globalization, Development, and Employment 04/11/20114 claims
- Abhijit Banerjee1 claim
- Chris Blattman1 claim
- Doug Irwin1 claim
- Jeffrey Sachs1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “premature deindustrialization” →
- Premature deindustrialization in Africa is not first-order driven by automation or technological change; the first-order explanation is a peculiar set of circumstances making East and Southeast Asia hypercompetitive in manufacturing, drawing industry there from places like Mexican maquiladoras, and Africa will industrialize little until its state development catches up and Chinese real wages rise—just as most of a subdivided Canada would look prematurely deindustrialized like Newfoundland.Chris Blattman
- China opened up 'at the margin'—keeping existing state enterprises and their supports in place while creating new incentives (special economic zones, export subsidies) for new export-oriented investment—thereby turning toward world markets without pulling the rug from under medium-productivity industries and avoiding premature deindustrialization, whereas Latin America deindustrialized prematurely.Dani Rodrik on Globalization, Development, and Employment 04/11/2011
- China's manufacturing employment share steadily increased and only recently began to shrink, whereas Latin America experienced premature deindustrialization—manufacturing employment began shrinking too early relative to cross-country development benchmarks.Dani Rodrik on Globalization, Development, and Employment 04/11/2011
- Latin American countries experienced premature deindustrialization—manufacturing's employment share began to shrink earlier than cross-country development benchmarks predict—whereas in China manufacturing employment share steadily increased.Dani Rodrik on Globalization, Development, and Employment 04/11/2011
- China globalized successfully by opening 'at the margin'—keeping existing state enterprises and their supports in place while creating new incentives (special economic zones, export subsidies for non-traditional products) for new export-oriented investment—thereby turning toward world markets without pulling the rug from under medium-productivity industries, which avoided the premature deindustrialization Latin America suffered.Dani Rodrik on Globalization, Development, and Employment 04/11/2011
- Premature deindustrialization (Dani Rodrik's claim that some countries will never industrialize like South Korea because manufacturing is automated and services are hard to trade) is not inevitable, because production can fragment locally—just as US steel shifted from big integrated mills to dispersed mini-mills, developing countries can host efficient small-scale local industry rather than centralizing in one or two countries.Doug Irwin
- Because so much global income is concentrated and spent on high-quality, heavily designed and brand-marketed goods, the manufacturing labor and capital cost is a tiny fraction of final price (a worker may get 40 cents of a $10 toy), so manufacturing can no longer generate large earnings for workers in emerging economies.Abhijit Banerjee
- There is no special magic to manufacturing; what developing countries crucially need is to export, because exporting earns the means to import the technology (99.9% of which comes from outside) needed to develop—so import-substituting manufacturing failed where pursued to excess, export-oriented manufacturing worked, and export-oriented services, mining, or agribusiness could substitute.Jeffrey Sachs
- It will be very difficult or impossible for sub-Saharan African countries to replicate the rapid convergence of East and Southeast Asia, because that experience depended on very rapid industrialization that delivered 4-5% per capita growth for decades; without that engine, these countries will see slower growth based on the steady accumulation of capabilities, human capital, and institutions.Dani Rodrik
- The 19th-century imperial decimation of nascent textile industries (India, China, the Ottoman Empire) now has a 21st-century analogue in China swamping world markets with manufactured goods, so countries like Ethiopia that once would have made simple goods now import everything from China, reducing import-substitution opportunities—an 'imperialism of free trade'—while capital-intensification means even garments and footwear are now skill-intensive, employing far fewer workers.Dani Rodrik