prediction markets
Markets where people trade contracts whose payoff depends on the outcome of future events, effectively betting on those outcomes.
As defined in cwt_andrew-ross-sorkin
Other definitions
Markets like Polymarket or Kalshi where people bet money on the outcomes of real-world events, generating price-based probability estimates.
454 - More From Sam Minnesota Greenland Iran Sthole Countries And MoreMarkets where people can buy and sell contracts that pay off based on whether specific events occur, allowing aggregation of distributed knowledge and calibration of subjective beliefs through financial incentives
David Deutsch & Steven Pinker (First Ever Public Dialogue) — AGI, P(Doom), & The Enemies of Progress
Where it comes up · 29
- Robin Hanson6 claims
- Capital, Politics and Power: Ken Griffin on the 2024 Election and What’s Next for the U.S. Economy6 claims
- Why Bezos Silenced The Post | EP 1075 claims
- Trump Wins — ft. Anthony Scaramucci | Prof G Markets3 claims
- Third Quarter 2024 Review — ft. Aswath Damodaran | Prof G Markets3 claims
- Dan Klein on Truth, Bias, and Disagreement 03/16/20092 claims
- Balaji Srinivasan2 claims
- Nate Silver2 claims
and 21 more
Most important claims · 10 of 53Search all claims for “prediction markets” →
- A well-calibrated forecasting system that says 75% will be wrong 25% of the time, so throwing out the system every time it lands on the wrong side of 'maybe'—as Leonhardt did with prediction markets after the Obamacare ruling—would leave you with no well-calibrated forecasting systems at all.Philip Tetlock on Superforecasting
- In the IARPA forecasting tournaments, the Good Judgment Project's teams—including motivated amateurs—generated more accurate probability estimates than rival university teams, an internal prediction market (Inkling), and classified U.S. intelligence analysts who had access to secret information.Philip Tetlock on Superforecasting
- Private organizations resist prediction markets because, although people claim to value information and analysis, much corporate activity is really coalition politics, and prediction markets destroy the favorite excuse for failed projects—that everything was fine until something unforeseeable struck—by revealing that people knew early the project would fail, thereby exposing managers to accountability.Robin Hanson
- Rationalism is an EA-adjacent but more informal, scruffier movement—people using expected value to think through problems more clearly and less biasedly, not necessarily for the greater good but for any aim like a better trade or a prediction-market answer—exemplified by self-taught Eliezer Yudkowsky rather than the credentialed Oxford EAs.285 | Nate Silver on Prediction, Risk, and Rationality
- Prediction markets are a good rationalist tool because they force you to put money behind your answer and thereby quantify your beliefs, while also embodying a respected consensus that even the best forecasters find hard to beat.285 | Nate Silver on Prediction, Risk, and Rationality
- Prediction markets have real limitations: choosing what is bettable and what metrics to use is hard; deciding whose opinion to compare them against is ambiguous because some lucky individual will always have a recent winning streak; they typically pay no interest, deterring long-horizon bets; and tying policy to a measurable outcome creates 'play to the test' distortions (you get what you measure).Dan Klein on Truth, Bias, and Disagreement 03/16/2009
- Prediction (betting) markets reliably produce more accurate estimates on important topics and are cheap, demonstrable in math, lab and field experiments — yet people are consistently uninterested in them, which Hanson now explains by his own thesis: he mistakenly took people at their word about wanting accurate information when in fact, emotionally, that is not what they want.119 - Hidden Motives
- Prediction markets reduce noise because averaging does that, but they cannot reduce a general bias unless the unbiased people also know they are unbiased and can therefore invest more to move the price toward the correct answer; without that asymmetry of knowledge, a bias will persist.Daniel Kahneman
- Prediction markets do not hedge you because a prediction market is binary while real exposure is open-ended; events like wars (predicted to last two weeks but lasting years and killing billions) show that in fat-tailed domains the event is not defined by occurrence but by magnitude.Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Skin in the Game
- Betting markets make people honest because once money is on the line, the usual temptation to slide about the truth and make things sound good is replaced by an incentive to be accurate — a principle that generalizes across life: the more you arrange for others to give you incentives tied to real outcomes, the more honest and better-behaved you'll be.119 - Hidden Motives