pragmatism
An American philosophical tradition associating the truth of an idea with its usefulness or 'cash value' for one's purposes.
As defined in ms_ama_july_2021
Other definitions
A native American philosophical tradition (associated with Dewey and Peirce) holding that departures from prior absolutes are acceptable if they prove useful for promoting good outcomes.
Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers
Where it comes up · 11
- A History of Philosophy | 64 American Pragmatism7 claims
- Psychedelics, Consciousness, and AI | Richard Dawkins | EP 2564 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 65 John Dewey3 claims
- Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/20093 claims
- Conclusion: Political, Social and Cultural Criticism and Theory3 claims
- Comte and the Origins of Sociology2 claims
- Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers1 claim
- Ask Me Anything 61 claim
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 27Search all claims for “pragmatism” →
- Pragmatism's critique of the Cartesian strategy of throwing out all beliefs and keeping only the right ones is that people cannot analyze their beliefs objectively, so they keep convenient or profitable ones; beliefs must be judged by the competitive process that has tested them, like floorboards of a boat.Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/2009
- The progressive organicist view of the state had four converging sources: (1) German graduate training in the historical school, where progressive economists earned PhDs because US programs barely existed; (2) Darwinism, whose material explanation of evolution made inalienable Creator-endowed rights seem a fiction; (3) Evangelical upbringing producing a Social Gospel that shifted Protestantism from saving the individual to redeeming the whole nation; and (4) American Pragmatism, which licensed departures from absolutes if they proved useful.Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers
- The grandmother test shows that a person who cannot give a reason for a social norm may still be right, because social norms can be the product of a competitive process that rejected other ideas, so cultural norms are not mere superstition.Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/2009
- James shifts pragmatist focus from abstract belief-fixation to psychological experience: rather than asking 'what do you think,' pragmatism asks 'how are you feeling'—examining inner tensions, satisfaction, and affective dimensions of experience.A History of Philosophy | 64 American Pragmatism
- The process of extracting meaningful conclusions from large datasets with many variables is not mechanistic: researchers can identify endless spurious correlations that are technically true but practically useless, and must use judgment to extract valid conclusions, which is where pragmatism intersects with statistics.Psychedelics, Consciousness, and AI | Richard Dawkins | EP 256
- The pragmatist epistemology developed by C.S. Peirce and William James in response to Darwin's theory of evolution holds that truth is 'true enough' if it can be used as a tool to achieve a goal in a specific space and time—the tool is adequate if it performs its intended task—and there is no truth superordinate to this pragmatic criterion.Psychedelics, Consciousness, and AI | Richard Dawkins | EP 256
- Charles Sanders Peirce initiated methodological naturalism in pragmatism through his conception of the fixation of belief, establishing that philosophical disputes should be settled by checking the empirical consequences of theories—essentially applying scientific method to philosophy.A History of Philosophy | 65 John Dewey
- Being an evolutionary biologist is conceptually incoherent without adopting pragmatism as one's epistemology, since evolutionary processes work with partial information and the question of how anything 'true' can exist given fundamental ignorance requires abandoning Newtonian or Cartesian metaphysics.Psychedelics, Consciousness, and AI | Richard Dawkins | EP 256
- Peterson's pragmatist definition of truth—that a claim is true if it helps the species survive—fails because it cannot apply to itself: the claim about truth would only be true if it aided survival, and otherwise would dissolve, revealing the concept as incoherent.Ask Me Anything 6
- Pragmatism follows the Hegelian tradition of viewing human experience through the lens of self-consciousness, finding the dialectic unfolding in human experience and projecting that dialectic onto all of reality.A History of Philosophy | 64 American Pragmatism