poverty trap
A self-reinforcing situation in which low income and lack of assets prevent the investments needed to escape poverty, keeping people stuck at a low level.
As defined in Terry Anderson on Native American Economics
Where it comes up · 7
- William Easterly on Growth, Poverty, and Aid 02/11/20083 claims
- Paul Collier on the Bottom Billion 01/28/20082 claims
- Nina Munk on Poverty, Development, and the Idealist1 claim
- William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better1 claim
- Terry Anderson on Native American Economics1 claim
- Alain Bertaud on Cities, Planning, and Order Without Design1 claim
- Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “poverty trap” →
- Every household makes a tradeoff between location, price, and size of housing, and these tradeoffs are made differently by different households; planners err by concentrating on size and quality while forgetting location, which is why so much subsidized housing is placed in terrible, inaccessible locations that become poverty traps.Alain Bertaud on Cities, Planning, and Order Without Design
- The poverty trap is a myth: dividing all countries from poorest to richest shows the poorest countries grow at roughly the same rate as the richest, with no tendency for the poorest to get permanently stuck, contradicting the trap prediction.William Easterly on Growth, Poverty, and Aid 02/11/2008
- Cash transfers can have lasting compounding effects rather than just temporary consumption boosts, because there is little evidence for a 'poverty trap' in which earning more fails to lift people out; the poor have genuine opportunities to improve their income through investment.William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better
- It is unrealistic and romantic to expect cash to rescue people from a poverty trap they couldn't escape on their own; the more realistic expectation, given that hundreds of millions are already exiting poverty, is that cash accelerates people's transition along that path — letting someone buy a wheelbarrow now instead of saving five years — while also improving their quality of life in the meantime.Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly
- The apparent poverty trap is a statistical fallacy of circular reasoning: measuring who is poor at the END of a period mechanically selects countries that by definition had the worst growth, making it falsely appear the poor were stuck, when the correct test measures who is poorest at the BEGINNING and asks whether they have a higher probability of getting stuck.William Easterly on Growth, Poverty, and Aid 02/11/2008
- American Indians face a poverty trap: substantial welfare-type payments flow into reservations (subsidized housing, the BIA spending $2.9 billion a year with one bureaucrat per 322 Indians, and $20,000 per student in reservation education versus $12,000 off), so without enough education to confidently earn more elsewhere, the wall to climb over is too high and people stay.Terry Anderson on Native American Economics
- Sachs believed in a poverty trap whereby implementing a dozen science-based interventions simultaneously (high-yield seeds, fertilizer, mosquito nets, schools, health care, wells) would lift people onto the first rung of the 'ladder of development,' after which growth would become self-sustaining — like jumpstarting a stalled car.Nina Munk on Poverty, Development, and the Idealist
- The poorest group of countries is not a static, stagnant pool—there is massive turnover, with countries leaving the bottom and other countries declining into it—which is inconsistent with the static poverty-trap idea.William Easterly on Growth, Poverty, and Aid 02/11/2008
- Stagnation of the bottom billion is explained by four major traps rather than a single cause: conflict, abundant natural resources, being landlocked without natural resources, and being small with little education and poor policies and governance.Paul Collier on the Bottom Billion 01/28/2008
- The bottom billion's problems are best understood through four distinct traps, rather than a single big-picture explanation, and this move from single explanations to four traps is the main new diagnostic contribution of the book.Paul Collier on the Bottom Billion 01/28/2008