
Paul Collier on the Bottom Billion 01/28/2008
What this covers
This EconTalk conversation pairs host Russ Roberts with Oxford's Paul Collier, who walks through the argument of his book on the bottom billion, the people in countries that have stagnated while most of the world grew. Collier's starting point is empirical. He reports testing whether repression or other obvious grievances predict rebellion and finding no relationship, while poverty and stagnation do. That puts him against grievance theory and leads to the conflict trap: civil wars and coups persist, relapse is common, and investors stay away. He also says that weak governments fight insurgents incompetently, which feeds rebel recruitment among jobless young men.
The middle of the discussion covers resources and democracy. Collier treats the natural resource curse as a matter of timing. Botswana and Norway had good institutions before the windfall, while resource revenue that arrives first corrodes governance. Roberts presses on why vote-buying, which exists in every democracy, is so destructive here, and Collier answers that poor countries lack checks and balances such as independent courts, a free press, and transparent budgets. He argues that electoral competition without them can raise political violence, and he cites Madagascar's blockaded ports. Remedies for resource revenue include Mexico's school-bursary scheme and a Vernon Smith proposal to share Iraqi oil revenue with citizens.
The last stretch turns to outside policy, and several of these claims are contested. Collier discusses temporary trade preferences to help countries like Kenya break into textiles, citing Bangladesh's jobs and the US African Growth and Opportunity Act. He also covers the Kimberley Process for diamonds, the postwar rebuilding of Europe as a template, and his criticism that aid agencies, the World Bank included, favor pleasant middle-income countries. He further warns that US biofuel policy raises food prices for importers and that emigration and capital flight drain small countries.
Collier argues the bottom billion are trapped by four interacting traps (conflict, natural resource dependence, landlockedness without resources, and smallness with little education), and that escaping them requires outside action on governance, checks and balances, international standards, and trade access, not aid alone.
- Poverty and stagnation, not grievance, best predict civil conflict, and conflict itself creates persistent economic traps.
- Resource revenues corrupt institutions and democracy when they arrive before good governance, while democracy without checks and balances produces destructive electoral competition.
- Targeted trade preferences, voluntary international standards, and information provision can help domestic reformers more than aid alone.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Having valuable natural resources such as oil, diamonds, or other high-value extractables should be an opportunity, but in practice it corrodes and corrupts politics, producing a dysfunctional polity in which leaders compete to control the public purse instead of providing public goods.
“It actually, um, corrodes and corrupts the politics. So, even where it doesn't turn the society into violence, uh, it produces, uh, a massively dysfunctional polity”
Collier tested whether political repression or other obvious grievances predict proneness to rebellion and found no relationship; the statistics instead show that proneness to conflict is driven by poverty and stagnation.
“I tried to to just find out whether as it were, the proneness to rebellion could be related to the degree of political repression or other obvious basis for grievance. Um and I just couldn't find it.”
Dictatorships are a familiar problem in resource-rich countries, but democracies in very poor countries can also fail: resource revenues corrupt democracy so that electoral competition becomes a race to the bottom, with politicians buying votes through corruption, patronage, and violence rather than adopting good policies.
“the resource revenues have corrupted democracy. And so, we get the process that I call the survival of the fattest”
Public spending in resource-rich countries is distorted because the winning electoral strategy is to buy blocs of votes through patronage and bribery of local big shots rather than to deliver national public goods. As a result the public purse becomes a common pool resource to be looted, a tragedy of the commons.
“the winning electoral strategy... is to... buy a component of votes uh through patronage, bribery... the public purse becomes what's called a common pool resource, something to be looted”
Botswana used its diamond wealth relatively well, Norway thrives with oil, and the decisive difference is governance: good institutions established before the resource windfall lead to good outcomes, while resource revenues arriving before good institutions corrode governance and rarely allow it to improve.
“if you get good institutions before you get your oil, which is what happened in Norway, the chances are you'll do fine. If you get your oil before you get your decent institutions, the chances are you never get decent institutions”
The temptation to give public money to special interests to buy votes exists in every democracy, including the United States and UK, so the key question is why this is so destructive in poor countries; Collier's answer is the absence of checks and balances.
“In every democracy, there's a temptation to give away uh parts of the public purse to buy votes that are not very helpful to the general interest”
The US Africa Growth and Opportunity Act, which gives preferential access to African exports, has increased African textile exports to America sevenfold in five years despite its limitations, while the European scheme is largely ineffective because it covers the wrong countries and has the wrong product restrictions, excluding Kenya but including Somalia.
“African exports of textiles to America have increased sevenfold in just 5 years”
Bangladesh created nearly 3 million jobs exporting textiles despite being poorly governed, and if Kenya could achieve similar employment in textiles it would transform its economy.
“Even a country like Bangladesh, which is far from being well run, has created nearly 3 million jobs in textiles, exporting textiles. If Kenya could have 3 million jobs, it would transform the economy.”
Conflict is a trap because once a country falls into civil war or coups it is highly persistent, and even after conflict ends there is a high risk of relapse, which keeps investment low and the economy stuck.
“once you stumble into these internal conflicts, they're highly persistent. And secondly, even when you come out of them, uh, there's a high risk of going back into them”
Globalization works against the bottom billion because educated people emigrate to richer countries and their small wealth leaves through capital flight, since stagnant, risky countries lead people to move money abroad even if they do not move themselves.
“people vote with their wallets even if they don't vote with their feet. They move their money uh to America and Europe rather than keeping it in the country”
Governments in poor, small societies are poor at providing security because they lack resources and skill, and counterinsurgency is a difficult skilled task that took Britain and America a long time to learn; as a result, governments often repress rebellion incompetently, provoking outrages that fuel recruitment to rebels.
“governments try and repress rebellion extremely incompetently, provoking a lot of outrages, and that fuels the supply of recruits to the rebellion”
The Kimberley Process, which certifies the origin of diamonds, has already had a dramatic effect, with every diamond producer in the world now part of the system, showing that voluntary measures can be effective.
“every diamond producer in the world is now a part of that system”
The post-Second World War American recovery of Europe offers a model: America shifted from protectionism to openness in trade, stationed 100,000 troops in Europe for 40 years, built systems of mutual governance such as the OECD, and gave Marshall Aid, and the bottom billion needs all four kinds of commitment.
“It changed its trade policy from protectionism to openness to European markets and European products.”
Asian producers have lower costs in simple manufactures not because they pay workers less but because existing export scale drives costs down through scale economies, so a country like Kenya needs a temporary preferential advantage against Asia in rich-country markets to break in.
“Asia has lower costs of production than a country like Kenya, not because it pays its workers less, but because it's already got the scale of exports which drive costs down”
The fourth trap is small size combined with low education and poor economic policies and governance; reform is accelerated by a critical mass of educated people, which large, educated countries have and tiny bottom-billion societies lack, so they remain stuck with bad policies longer.
“reform requires a or is accelerated by a critical mass of plenty of educated people. And the tiny societies of the bottom billion with very little education just haven't had that critical mass”
Poorer countries are more likely to enter civil war, a statistical regularity Collier says he consistently finds in his research, and he is confident in this result.
“the poorer the society, the slower it's growing, the more likely it is to to enter civil war”
International aid agencies, including the World Bank, have a self-interested temptation to direct aid toward pleasant middle-income countries to visit and advise rather than the poorest countries where the bottom billion live; the World Bank has far more staff in a typical large middle-income country than in bottom-billion societies.
“they have far more staff in the typical uh middle-income country, large middle-income country, than they do in the societies of the bottom billion”
Vernon Smith's proposal that Iraq distribute oil revenue to citizens through a stock-sharing scheme was considered by the Bush administration but rejected, and Collier regards privatizing resource revenues to citizens, when politically feasible, as a step in the right direction.
“the solution or the potential for privatization of these resources, when it is politically feasible, is a tremendous step in the right direction”
Mexico's Progresa-style school bursary scheme, which uses oil revenues to reward children for going to school, is administratively simple, effective, gets money to ordinary households, and keeps revenue out of the hands of those who would compete for it destructively.
“this is school bursaries, so that the scheme which Mexico introduced, called the progressive scheme, whereby some of the oil revenues are used just to reward children going to school”
Mature democracies have layered checks and balances including a transparent budget process, public scrutiny, investigative journalism, independent courts that can prosecute embezzlement, a free press as a third estate, and independent central banks, and the bottom billion has had none of these.
“the budgetary process has to be transparent. Citizens have to be able to know how money is being spent”
Madagascar was thriving as a textile exporter as a latecomer until its president refused to step down after losing an election and blockaded the ports for eight months with supporters, destroying exports and about a quarter million jobs.
“he blockaded the port for 8 months with his supporters. That of course killed the export activities. So, uh, the great leader managed to uh destroy his own economy and uh a quarter of a million jobs”
Political violence in Africa has risen since the 1970s, with large-scale violence building to a crescendo in the 1990s; since the end of the Cold War there has been only slight easing, and the shift from dictatorship to electoral democracy has tended to escalate political violence rather than reduce it.
“the transition from dictatorship to electoral competition or democracy, which we had hoped would deliver peace, has actually tended to escalate the degree of political violence”
US biofuel and ethanol policy has driven up world food and corn prices, which is very damaging for food-importing bottom-billion countries, where poor people spend about half their income on food.
“policies which inadvertently have the effect of slamming up global food prices can be very destructive. And for poor people, about half of their income is spent on food”
Trade policy matters most for coastal, resource-scarce countries like Kenya, since oil exporters can sell anywhere, and the global economic game for these countries is trade in labor-intensive manufactures that create many jobs.
“the countries where trade where our trade policy really matters are the countries which are coastal but resource scarce. If you're exporting oil, trade policy kind of doesn't matter”
Rebel groups can easily recruit young men, and especially teenagers, from poor, stagnant societies because those young men have no jobs, income, prospects, or hope, so the supply of recruits to rebellion is high.
“if people, especially if young men, have no jobs, no income, no prospects, no hope, um there's little to stop them being recruited into a rebel group”
International standards, even if voluntary, are vital: natural resource revenue standards are needed because the current resource revenue bonanza is unprecedented and the last one in the 1970s produced no sustained benefit, and guidelines can help reformers focus on decisions such as saving revenue and avoiding white elephant investments.
“we've got the biggest natural resource revenue bonanza in world history happening right now”
Agricultural subsidies in rich countries close off export opportunities for poor countries; American cotton subsidies made it seem reasonable to persuade Chad to stop producing cotton even though there is little else Chad can produce.
“if you take um American cotton, um at one stage, um there was even a proposal that Chad should be persuaded to give up producing cotton”
Elections in poor countries need international standards backed by sanctions, because observers without enforcement cannot stop sham elections, which are themselves hugely destructive; for elections, stigma and shame are not enough.
“the guidelines on how we conduct elections really need to be backed up by some sanctions... we've got no teeth behind those observers”
Aid and natural resource revenues are analogous only in that both give governments income not raised through taxation of citizens; aid is purposively directed, comes with advice and conditions, while oil and diamonds simply bubble out of the ground, and the evidence suggests aid is more effective than resource revenues.
“as far as I can see, the evidence is that um aid is much more effective than the uh than the natural resource revenues”
Checks and balances are a special kind of public good that benefits everyone, but the government itself is the one group that does not benefit from them, so the government actively opposes building them, and therefore checks and balances must be in place before electoral competition or they will never be built.
“the one group that really doesn't benefit from them is the government itself. Yeah. And so uh the government actively opposes the construction of checks and balances.”
The development problem has shifted from the five billion poor people in developing countries to the bottom billion, because most of the developing world is now growing fast and China and India are converging on rich countries at historically unprecedented rates.
“China and India are converging on the rest on the on the rich world at rates that are just historically unprecedented”
The gap between the bottom billion and the next four billion in developing countries widened to five to one by 2000, and has widened for about 20 years at roughly 5% a year, because the bottom billion is stagnating while the middle four billion grows.
“the gap between the typical citizen of the bottom billion and the typical citizen of the next four billion had widened to five to one”
Outside Africa, landlocked resource-scarce places did not become independent countries but became parts of more fortunate neighboring countries, whereas in Africa they became countries, which contributes to their poverty.
“places that are landlocked and resource-scarce haven't become countries. They've become parts of more fortunate countries. Uh in Africa, they actually became countries.”
Promoting democracy in the bottom billion since the Cold War has forgotten that democracy has two parts: electoral competition, which is easy to establish because parties have strong incentives to contest elections, and checks and balances, which limit how governments use power and are hard to establish.
“Electoral competition just tells you how governments acquire power. And checks and balances place limits on how they can use that power.”
Landlocked countries without natural resources are among the most impoverished and slowest-growing in the world because they cannot easily export and do not control their route to the coast, and this trap affects about a third of Africa's population versus about 1% of developing-world population outside Africa.
“If we look outside Africa, only about 1% of the world's developing population lives in such countries. But, within Africa, it's about a third of the population”
The world failed to address the risks after the First World War because they were amorphous, whereas after the Second World War the risks were blindingly obvious, so the bottom billion problem will be fixed only if the West gets serious about its risks, which are not yet obvious.
“After the First World War, the risks were there, but they were amorphous. And so, they were never faced.”
The bottom billion's problems are best understood through four distinct traps, rather than a single big-picture explanation, and this move from single explanations to four traps is the main new diagnostic contribution of the book.
“moving away from the notion that there is a single explanation, rather to saying that there are only four that I think is the sort of the major step in the diagnosis”
After the Cold War, the bottom billion got instant democracies, in which only elections can be done quickly, and elections have a visual and visceral appeal that makes outsiders feel good, while the slow processes of checks and balances are neglected.
“What we got was after the end of the Cold War was instant democracies. And the only aspect of democracy you can do instantly is the elections.”
In Peru, the government bribed nearly all newspapers, radio, and television stations; the one small TV station it did not bother with broadcast footage of bribery, which brought people onto the streets and brought the government down, showing both the scale of corruption of the press and why the press is a key check.
“it bribed all the newspapers, the radio and the TV stations, um except for one TV station, which was too small to bother with”
Information provision from outsiders can help reformers in poor countries, because local people are skeptical of outsiders and governments exploit that skepticism, and information gives citizens a basis to press their governments; Nigeria's finance minister Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala published oil revenue flows in newspapers, which drove record newspaper circulation and death threats.
“she published uh in the Nigerian newspapers uh the money that not only was coming in, but that she was passing on to the 36 uh state governors of Nigeria”
Stagnation of the bottom billion is explained by four major traps rather than a single cause: conflict, abundant natural resources, being landlocked without natural resources, and being small with little education and poor policies and governance.
“there are only four that I think is the sort of the major step in in the diagnosis”
Since the fall of the Soviet Union, the spread of democracy was expected to deliver better economic performance and political rights, but in resource-rich countries democracy has not disciplined governments as hoped.
“we of course, all hoped that the spread of democracy which followed from the fall of the Soviet Union would really lead to dramatically better economic performance”
On the evidence Collier has seen, well-directed aid is much more effective than natural resource revenues, which can be beneficial only if the government is good, and the temptation to misuse aid is enormous.
“as far as I can see, the evidence is that aid is much more effective than the natural resource revenues. The natural resource revenues can be effective. It really depends upon whether the government is a good government”
The Central African Republic had no resident World Bank or IMF staff even though it was desperately short of people with economic policy competence, showing that international agencies locate staff where they are less needed.
“there wasn't a single um resident staff of the World Bank there, or a single resident staff from the International Monetary Fund, in the whole country”
Change in the bottom billion must come from within, since outsiders cannot impose it; the outside world has largely been bystanders, and it can strengthen reformers by using military interventions, international standard-setting, and trade policy, which the agencies controlling these tools currently do not apply to these problems.
“Change in the societies at the very bottom must come from within. We cannot impose it on them. ... To date, we have largely been bystanders in this struggle.”
Most of the bottom billion's problems ultimately reduce to bad governance, but Collier says this is not the whole story: landlocked resource-scarce countries are intrinsically hard to develop even with good government, and small, poor societies face logistical security problems even when competent.
“I think the problems go beyond bad governance. I think the landlocked resource-scarce countries just intrinsically problematic even where the government is good”
Information provision is the most promising outside lever: as Peru showed, a small unbribed outlet can expose corruption, and outsiders can provide information to help citizens pressure their own governments, though the ultimate struggle is internal and the criterion should be what helps reformers.
“I think there's a lot of uh opportunity there. But... these are internal struggles within these societies... what helps the people who are fighting for change”
Without effective checks and balances in resource-rich democracies, an incumbent can win an election while losing the vote, as Kenya's president did, so the democratic process becomes a race to the bottom.
“in the absence of effective checks and balances, um the incumbent president um can win the election uh without um without getting the votes”
The Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative, a voluntary standard requiring governments to report revenues to their citizens, has been signed by many governments and separates the 'sheep from the goats', giving reformers a rallying point to demand compliance.
“a lot of governments have now signed up to that. And so that very standard, even though voluntary, is separating the sheep from the goats”
The bottom billion can succeed, and the prospect of a billion people continuing to diverge from the rest of humanity is unthinkable, so there is reason for optimism over the next 20 years, with many non-aid instruments likely to be effective and the aid debate a sideshow.
“there are a lot of instruments beyond aid um that will be very effective. And so, this aid debate is a in a way a bit of a sideshow”
Aid can be divided into two types: well-intentioned development-agency aid aimed at helping citizens, and aid that is part of a nation's foreign policy aimed at achieving allies or solving other problems rather than helping citizens.
“you could think of two kinds of aid. One is well-intentioned, it's coming from a development agency. The other is really a part of the a nation's foreign policy”
The bottom billion is a group of nearly 60 countries with about a billion people, about 70% of whom live in Africa, that have failed to grow since independence while most other developing countries grew.
“they're a group of countries, um, which add up to about a billion people. Um, there are nearly 60 of them”
Reputational pressure can shift corporate behavior: publicity about violent diamond sourcing shamed De Beers, the largest diamond provider, into changing from part of the problem to part of the solution.
“De Beers, the largest uh provider of diamonds in the world, was shamed uh by the publicity around the diamonds the source of diamonds being just violent and horrifying”
Most farmers in poor countries export beverage crops such as coffee, tea, cocoa, and sugar rather than staple foods, and many of these countries are net importers of basic foods, so higher food prices hurt them more than they help.
“the sort of things that farmers tend to sell for export are not food, but they're beverages like coffee, tea, cocoa, sugar”
The World Bank's defense that it focuses on middle-income countries because they are more productive is partly valid, but there is also some self-interest in where staff prefer to be, and global organizations must remain global while the balance of effort should shift toward countries stuck at the bottom.
“I think there's a little of both going on here, of both uh productivity and and a little bit of self-interest”
Electoral fraud and manipulation also occur in stable democracies, as with Lyndon Johnson's late-arriving rural Texas vote, but in poor resource-rich democracies such fraud is decisively destructive, while in developed democracies it is merely embarrassing.
“those kind of events are embarrassments. Here they are just decisively destructive”
Rebels often claim lofty ideals such as social justice, peace, and unity, but this rhetoric should not be taken at face value because rebel groups are often motivated by material gain.
“rebels are not going to say uh we're in it for the money. Um they're going to call themselves the the movement for social justice”
Reformers in poor countries need courage, and there is a supply of such people, so outsiders should support them more competently than they have to date.
“the amazing thing is there's a there is a supply of just such people. What have to do is get behind them a bit more competently”