police power
The inherent authority of states to regulate behavior and enforce order to protect health, safety, morals, and welfare within their borders.
As defined in Richard Epstein on the Constitution
Other definitions
The state's inherent authority to regulate private conduct and property for health, safety, morals, and general welfare; Epstein argues its legitimate scope is narrower than the New Deal's use of it.
Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
Where it comes up · 3
- Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/20093 claims
- Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner2 claims
- Richard Epstein on the Constitution1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “police power” →
- The Lochner maximum-hours law was not genuinely a health and safety measure but a public-choice gambit: union bakers, using a different mode of production, backed neutral-sounding maximum-hour statutes that didn't hurt themselves but wrecked the production methods of non-union bakers (whose workers slept on the job) supplying cheaper labor, so the New York Times called the decision striking it down a blow against union dominance.Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner
- Justice Holmes's lone Lochner dissent was the most eloquent and influential yet the worst opinion when taken apart: he justified the law on health grounds with a full stop, cited only Jacobson v. Massachusetts (a vaccination case unlike the bakery situation), and famously declared the Constitution does not enact a particular philosophy like Herbert Spencer's Social Statics—but the American Constitution is not merely 'a' constitution; it is 'this' Constitution resting on principles of limited government.Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner
- The traditional police power had four heads (health, safety, morals, general welfare); health and safety justified sanitation and sewage investments in the late nineteenth century, which Epstein argues were the main driver of rising life expectancy: in England and Europe life expectancy had hovered around 40 years before 1850 and rose to about 48 in the 1900s, and in the United States it rose from about 47-48 to around 54 in the following 20 years.Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
- Health and safety police-power regulation could legitimately require exit doors to open outward in theaters and factories; had the Triangle Waist factory been subject to such rules, the 1911 fire that killed many workers would have been prevented, and mass disasters such as boat capsizes, theater fires, and the Titanic were common in the early twentieth century.Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
- Until the 1937 constitutional revolution, American courts had worked out a reasonably successful system for distinguishing legitimate property uses (ones that carry risk and deserve returns) from harmful ones such as trespass, nuisance, ultra-hazardous activities, and fishery destruction; in 1937 the Supreme Court abandoned this effort and held that whatever the state wants to do is fine.Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
- The original constitutional design limited federal power to regulate activities within states largely because of the slavery question: to bring the union together, the great compromise let southern states keep slavery and northern states keep abolition, which required powerfully limiting federal authority over intrastate activity—giving the federal government only powers like regulating foreign and interstate commerce and Indian relations while leaving the rest to state police power.Richard Epstein on the Constitution