factual

Holmes's Lochner Dissent Eloquent but Worst Reasoned

Justice Holmes's lone Lochner dissent was the most eloquent and influential yet the worst opinion when taken apart: he justified the law on health grounds with a full stop, cited only Jacobson v. Massachusetts (a vaccination case unlike the bakery situation), and famously declared the Constitution does not enact a particular philosophy like Herbert Spencer's Social Statics—but the American Constitution is not merely 'a' constitution; it is 'this' Constitution resting on principles of limited government.

factualpending

Speaker

Richard Epstein

Evidence Quote

“the American Constitution is not just a Constitution; it's this Constitution. It has a very different bearing and demeanor about it, and does for its success rest upon principles of limited government”

Source

Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:19:52 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...