placebo effect
A beneficial health outcome produced by a patient's belief that they have received treatment, rather than by any active therapeutic mechanism.
As defined in The Top EconTalk Conversations of 2023 (with Russ Roberts)
Other definitions
In economic context, when the announcement of a policy (even if mechanically ineffective) changes market expectations and behavior through psychological channels; people believe the policy will work, so it does through changed expectations.
The Crisis In Monetary Policy: It Doesn't Matter That Much | Mark Dow
Where it comes up · 26
- Gary Greenberg on the Placebo Effect16 claims
- Robert Burton on Being Certain4 claims
- Louis Menand on Psychiatry 05/31/20102 claims
- Katy Milkman on How to Change2 claims
- The Top EconTalk Conversations of 2023 (with Russ Roberts)2 claims
- Lex Fridman Podcast #502 - Psychiatry, Insane Asylums, Mental Illness, ECT, Lobotomies, Freud & Jung2 claims
- Ep. 1 - Awakening from the Meaning Crisis - Introduction1 claim
- #318 Alistair Urquhart (Listen to this when you’re stressed)1 claim
and 18 more
Most important claims · 10 of 48Search all claims for “placebo effect” →
- Because the human body is so complicated—cancers sometimes spontaneously heal and depression sometimes lifts on its own—even the stupidest treatment imaginable, like stroking caterpillar fur at midnight or coffee enemas, will produce at least some apparent improvements if administered to enough people, which combined with the placebo effect makes it dangerously easy to credit a worthless intervention.Megan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap
- Clinical trials of vertebroplasty—injecting cement into vertebrae to treat back pain from osteoporosis—show no difference between actually injecting cement and a sham procedure of opening the cement so the patient can smell it and then injecting saline, and lower back pain is among the conditions most responsive to placebo treatment.Gary Greenberg on the Placebo Effect
- The placebo effect is a well-demonstrated, belief-based process that is medically efficacious for pain and many other conditions yet remains poorly understood, to the point that designing drugs that beat placebos is a genuine challenge because placebos are so effective.Absolutely Mental Season Two
- Antidepressants beat placebo in statistically significant trials, but improvements of one or two points on a 60-point rating scale may not reflect meaningful clinical or quality-of-life change, and most of the benefit is shared with placebo.Lex Fridman Podcast #502 - Psychiatry, Insane Asylums, Mental Illness, ECT, Lobotomies, Freud & Jung
- The clinical trial model wrongly assumes that the total observed effect equals the drug effect plus the placebo effect (additivity), but it never tested whether a placebo might interfere with a drug, stop it from working, or make a person worse off; this unexamined assumption is a fundamental challenge to the validity of the clinical trial model.Gary Greenberg on the Placebo Effect
- Placebo effects are modulated on dopamine-related neural pathways tied to the body's ability to detect disruptions to homeostasis and restore it in both psychological and physical disorder, suggesting healing has a neural aspect beyond molecules acting on molecules, and that the placebo effect reflects a real central-nervous-system healing process.Gary Greenberg on the Placebo Effect
- Studies show that people with a particular variant of a genome region producing a specific enzyme are more likely to have a strong placebo response, a finding supported by large-scale studies (one with 40,000 participants over 10 years) extending beyond irritable bowel syndrome to prevention of heart disease and cancer, while people with a different variant may even be affected negatively by taking a placebo.Gary Greenberg on the Placebo Effect
- The human touch and connection are essential to medicine and likely explain the power of the placebo effect; study after study in placebo science shows the therapeutic action comes from interaction with the doctor—even when the doctor states it is a placebo it has no action, because it is the human factor that matters, and patients can tell when an exam is cursory and feel uncared-for.Eric Topol on Deep Medicine
- Psychiatric interventions are hard to evaluate because the placebo effect arises both from patients who want to get better and from clinicians who believe in the procedure, and people easily deceive themselves into seeing what they want.Lex Fridman Podcast #502 - Psychiatry, Insane Asylums, Mental Illness, ECT, Lobotomies, Freud & Jung
- Research associated with Daniel Kahneman on colonoscopy patients confirmed the peak-end rule: a person's judgment of an experience is largely determined by its peak intensity and its character at the end, so deliberately prolonging a colonoscopy with an unnecessary low-intensity but less-negative final stimulus reduced patients' remembered suffering and increased their willingness to return for future life-saving procedures.52 - Finding Our Way In The Cosmos