personal vote
The portion of a candidate's electoral support (about 8% historically) attached to the individual through name recognition and constituency service rather than to their party or ideology.
As defined in David Brady on Health Care Reform, Public Opinion, and Party Politics 8/24/2009
Where it comes up · 2
- David Brady on Health Care Reform, Public Opinion, and Party Politics 8/24/20095 claims
- David Brady on the Electorate and the Elections of 2010 and 2012 08/15/20112 claims
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “personal vote” →
- The 'personal vote' worth about 8% emerged in the mid-1950s (documented via the O'Hara 'Democrat'-to-'Chicago' signage example), enabling candidates to build loyalty to themselves rather than their party, which explains why presidents from 1948 onward routinely faced opposite-party Congresses—a phenomenon that had not occurred since Zachary Taylor in 1848.David Brady on Health Care Reform, Public Opinion, and Party Politics 8/24/2009
- Pre-1932 incumbency was strong but attached to party and economic success (98% of Republican incumbents won 1920-30 amid prosperity, but they lost heavily when the economy collapsed in 1932); the modern personal vote shifted incumbency advantage to individuals, eliminating coattails and allowing opposite-party incumbents to do better by voting with or against the president as needed and explaining it as principled independence.David Brady on Health Care Reform, Public Opinion, and Party Politics 8/24/2009
- The personal vote is measurable via 'retirement slump' (a party loses about 7-8% of vote share when an incumbent retires) and 'sophomore surge' (a new incumbent gains about 8% in their first reelection), both of which were random before the 1950s, appeared thereafter, and remain around 6% today.David Brady on Health Care Reform, Public Opinion, and Party Politics 8/24/2009
- Modern realignments no longer occur because members of Congress learned to cultivate a 'personal vote' independent of party (a phenomenon that did not exist before the mid-1960s): pre-1964 a 6% swing to a party brought it the presidency and House together, but post-1964 huge presidential victories (Nixon 1972, Reagan 1980/1984) produced no comparable congressional coattails because members run as individuals.David Brady on the Electorate and the Elections of 2010 and 2012 08/15/2011
- The personal vote arose from two exogenous innovations: scientific polling (emerging in the 1940s, reliable by 1956) which told members their district's true leanings independent of presidential coattails, and television advertising which let candidates portray themselves vividly and independently of party label—and research shows the personal vote is higher in geographically compact districts where TV coverage is efficient (e.g., Peoria covering 96% of a district vs. New York covering 14 districts).David Brady on the Electorate and the Elections of 2010 and 2012 08/15/2011
- The exogenous innovation of scientific polling (better than the 1930s practice of party bosses estimating popularity) forced politicians to behave differently: by 1956 a Democratic congressman who knew Stevenson would lose had to position himself independently of the presidential ticket, giving rise to split-ticket voting and the modern personal vote.David Brady on Health Care Reform, Public Opinion, and Party Politics 8/24/2009
- Politicians build the personal vote through constituency service—maintaining many district offices (especially the electorally insecure), spending Friday-Monday at home, sending franking mail, baby books, constituent surveys, and Capitol-flown flags, and using local press facilities—techniques analogous to product brand loyalty that can be squandered.David Brady on Health Care Reform, Public Opinion, and Party Politics 8/24/2009