Pre-1932 incumbency was strong but attached to party and economic success (98% of Republican incumbents won 1920-30 amid prosperity, but they lost heavily when the economy collapsed in 1932); the modern personal vote shifted incumbency advantage to individuals, eliminating coattails and allowing opposite-party incumbents to do better by voting with or against the president as needed and explaining it as principled independence.

causalpending

Speaker

David Brady

Evidence Quote

“those coattails disappeared with the rise of the personal vote”

Source

David Brady on Health Care Reform, Public Opinion, and Party Politics 8/24/2009— EconTalk
Created: 6/16/2026, 2:50:17 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...