past hypothesis
The posit (named by David Albert) that the universe began in a state of very low entropy, which grounds the thermodynamic arrow of time.
As defined in 215 | Barry Loewer on Physics, Counterfactuals, and the Macroworld
Other definitions
The posited low-entropy boundary condition of the early universe that, combined with the second law of thermodynamics, grounds the perceived arrow of time.
AMA | February 2024
Where it comes up · 26
- 215 | Barry Loewer on Physics, Counterfactuals, and the Macroworld4 claims
- 158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time3 claims
- 366 | Jim Al-Khalili on Time, Quantum, Biology, and Cosmology3 claims
- 200 | Solo: The Philosophy of the Multiverse2 claims
- AMA | February 20242 claims
- AMA | July 20222 claims
- AMA | March 20232 claims
- AMA | May 20212 claims
and 18 more
Most important claims · 10 of 39Search all claims for “past hypothesis” →
- Microphysics is time-reversible in the precise sense that evolving a state forward, reversing momenta (or taking the complex conjugate of the wave function), evolving backward, and reversing again returns you to the initial state; this reversibility means information is preserved over time at the microscopic level but not at the macroscopic level, which is why the past hypothesis of low entropy at the Big Bang is needed even if time has no fundamental direction.AMA | April 2022
- Inferring the low entropy of the early universe from observations is not circular reasoning but self-consistent: we assume the broad principle that entropy has been increasing, then use observations of light reaching us today to infer the specific low-entropy early state; this assumption could be wrong (we cannot rule out being Boltzmann brains or a last-Thursday creation) but making it produces a coherent, fruitful picture, which is the nature of science.AMA | July 2022
- Without the past hypothesis (that the early universe had very low entropy), retrodicting from the current macrostate alone would predict the past to look exactly like the future with macroscopic momenta reversed — meaning entropy would increase toward the past, radiation would converge on the sun rather than radiate away, and the asymmetry between past and future would vanish.AMA | March 2022
- Nearly every explanation of why some everyday process unfolds the way it does has the second law of thermodynamics somewhere in its causal chain, because the arrow of time and irreversible macroscopic behavior derive from increasing entropy; abstract domains like pure mathematics are the notable exception since their truths are not grounded in physical entropy.AMA | March 2023
- Although the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formalisms are equivalent, attempting to encode the past hypothesis as a 'Lagrangian of the universe' that forces a low-entropy big-bang bottleneck between two high-entropy boundaries does not eliminate the past hypothesis but merely relocates it into the chosen boundary conditions or action, so the low-entropy initial state remains an independent posited input rather than a derived consequence of dynamics.AMA | April 2026
- The Second Law that entropy increases follows from two things: the statistical definition of entropy (high-entropy macrostates correspond to vastly more microstates) plus a boundary condition of low entropy at one end of time, which we define to be the past; there is no pre-existing definition of past and future beyond the direction of lower versus higher entropy.AMA | March 2021
- The real Boltzmann problem is not minimal brains but 'Boltzmann yous': in an eternally fluctuating universe there are vastly more random fluctuations matching your entire macroscopic state (including your whole past light cone) than thermodynamically sensible observers, so even granting Hartle and Srednicki their fiat exclusion of brains, you should still expect to be a fluctuation whose telescope will show no microwave background tomorrow, which falsifies their scenario.200 | Solo: The Philosophy of the Multiverse
- Despite its name, the past hypothesis does not assume a distinction between past and future; rather, it explains what that distinction is—by orienting all of time's arrows (records, influence, entropy increase, smoke dispersal) in the same direction with their tails at the low-entropy boundary, thereby explaining why that boundary is the past.215 | Barry Loewer on Physics, Counterfactuals, and the Macroworld
- It is questionable to what extent the early universe was lower-entropy simply because it was denser, since one can imagine alternative early-universe configurations that were equally dense but had much higher entropy, which bears on the nature of the Past Hypothesis and the arrow of time.AMA | June 2024
- Time's arrow exists because entropy increases, and the explanation has two parts: Boltzmann's definition that entropy is the logarithm of the number of microstates within a macrostate, and the past hypothesis — the crucial initial condition that the universe began in a low-entropy microstate — which together account for the second law of thermodynamics.Holiday Message | Hits and Misses