causal
The Problem Is Boltzmann Yous, Not Boltzmann Brains
The real Boltzmann problem is not minimal brains but 'Boltzmann yous': in an eternally fluctuating universe there are vastly more random fluctuations matching your entire macroscopic state (including your whole past light cone) than thermodynamically sensible observers, so even granting Hartle and Srednicki their fiat exclusion of brains, you should still expect to be a fluctuation whose telescope will show no microwave background tomorrow, which falsifies their scenario.
causalpending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“there's zero principle reason to exclude observers like that from your Xerographic Distribution... their theory makes a prediction. And their prediction... I mean, they made it years ago, so it's been falsified many, many times”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:05:11 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...