paradox of thrift
The Keynesian idea that if everyone tries to save more during a recession, aggregate spending falls, reducing incomes and ultimately total saving—what is prudent individually can be harmful collectively.
As defined in Megan McArdle on Debt and Self-Restraint 12/07/2009
Other definitions
The Keynesian idea that if people collectively save more and spend less, aggregate demand falls and the economy stagnates, so individual prudence becomes collectively harmful.
John Papola on the Keynes Hayek Rap Videos 05/02/2011
Where it comes up · 5
- Steve Fazzari on Keynesian Economics 01/12/20096 claims
- Ricardo Reis on Keynes, Macroeconomics, and Monetary Policy 04/27/20092 claims
- Thomas Rustici on Smoot-Hawley and the Great Depression 01/04/20101 claim
- Former Chief Economist (BIS) Explains Monetary Endgame1 claim
- Megan McArdle on Debt and Self-Restraint 12/07/20091 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “paradox of thrift” →
- When a family saves by eating out less, the restaurant's lower income forces it to draw down its own savings or cut its own spending, so the net increase in household saving is exactly offset and aggregate saving does not rise.Steve Fazzari on Keynesian Economics 01/12/2009
- The paradox of thrift is hard to grasp because when an individual saves more, the individual sees rising bank balances and portfolio values, but does not see the income destroyed elsewhere in the economy by the reduced spending.Steve Fazzari on Keynesian Economics 01/12/2009
- When a household reduces restaurant spending to save for its children's college, the market sees the reduced restaurant demand and adjusts by cutting restaurant food, but does not see the decision to fund college; the bank never gets the money, so the intended reallocation does not happen.Steve Fazzari on Keynesian Economics 01/12/2009
- Individual pension funds face a paradox of thrift: each should rationally short French bonds to protect itself, but if all do so simultaneously, they precipitate the crisis they're trying to avoid, making the situation worse than inaction.Former Chief Economist (BIS) Explains Monetary Endgame
- Holding total income constant while saving rises is a logical fallacy: an increase in saving necessarily reduces total income, so there is no additional money available to finance investment unless some other process restores demand.Steve Fazzari on Keynesian Economics 01/12/2009
- Saving is not automatically the engine of growth: when a family saves by cutting restaurant spending, the restaurant's income falls, and a decision not to consume today is not necessarily a decision to consume something specific later.Steve Fazzari on Keynesian Economics 01/12/2009
- The paradox of thrift appears in the old IS-LM model, where an attempt to save more reduces output, but it does not show up in the New Keynesian model, so dropping IS-LM from teaching loses the paradox of thrift as a teaching idea.Ricardo Reis on Keynes, Macroeconomics, and Monetary Policy 04/27/2009
- The paradox of thrift only bites when savings fail to be channeled into investment; from roughly November to March the mechanisms translating savings into investment (IPOs, new bond issues) were broken, so savings became money pulled out of the economy—but such traps don't last forever because investment goods are the missing piece.Megan McArdle on Debt and Self-Restraint 12/07/2009
- If saving is the engine of future growth because saved funds finance investment, then saving should be good for the economy, and Roberts does not understand why higher saving would be harmful.Steve Fazzari on Keynesian Economics 01/12/2009
- Keynes's paradox of thrift reverses the classical view: classical economists held that saving flowed through banks into productive investment and raised real wages, while Keynes argued that aggregate saving drains spending from the circuit of transactions, so savings act like a black hole that shrinks real income.Thomas Rustici on Smoot-Hawley and the Great Depression 01/04/2010