original position
In Rawls's theory, a hypothetical starting point where people choose principles of justice from behind a 'veil of ignorance,' not knowing their own place in society.
As defined in 57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy
Other definitions
A thought experiment in which people choose the rules of a society from behind a veil of ignorance about their position, used to test which transactions are acceptable.
Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
Where it comes up · 6
- 220 | Lara Buchak on Risk and Rationality2 claims
- 57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy2 claims
- Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield1 claim
- Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/20101 claim
- 19 | Tyler Cowen on Maximizing Growth and Thinking for the Future1 claim
- 30 | Derek Leben on Ethics for Robots and Artificial Intelligences1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “original position” →
- Rawls and Harsanyi both treated choosing a society as choosing which society to live in behind a veil of not knowing who you will be, but diverged sharply: Harsanyi assigned equal probability to being each person and maximized expected utility (indifferent between equal and unequal distributions of the same total), while Rawls refused to assign probabilities and applied a maximally risk-averse maximin rule, picking the society with the highest minimum.220 | Lara Buchak on Risk and Rationality
- Rawls's maximin is too risk-averse because it cares only about the single worst-off person and ignores everyone else, while Harsanyi's averaging ignores distribution entirely (rating an unequal society as good as an equal one with the same total); Buchak's risk-avoidant decision theory yields an intermediate position that gives most weight to the worst-off, significant weight to the middle, and a little to the best-off, matching how many people actually think about distributing resources and being sensitive to both total wealth and its distribution.220 | Lara Buchak on Risk and Rationality
- Some choices, such as allowing a rich person to pay to shoot someone, must be taken off the table regardless of surplus gains, and a good test for identifying these is to ask whether people in an original position choosing a society would agree to such a transaction.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Rawls's original position imagines designing society without knowing who you will be, so you agree on distributions of primary goods—life, health, opportunity, essential resources—which all humans must value to pursue any goal, as distinct from secondary goods (like coffee or television) that depend on contingent preferences.30 | Derek Leben on Ethics for Robots and Artificial Intelligences
- John Rawls's 'Justice as Fairness' permits inequality only when it benefits even the least well-off, but he explicitly intended his principles to apply to a well-ordered, functioning, healthy society, treating that as a precondition.57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy
- Rawls' big mistake was being overly enamored of John Stuart Mill's stationary steady state and worrying that growth might be unjust because the first generation—the worst-off—is asked to save and grow the economy; this neglect of growth across generations is the weak spot in Rawls that most people don't discuss, and Rawls' original position arguably should have admitted it doesn't work across generations.19 | Tyler Cowen on Maximizing Growth and Thinking for the Future
- A fundamental principle of liberalism—rooted in the labor theory of value and just appropriation found in Locke but absent in Rawls—is that the good life is one which must be earned, a principle today set forth more by conservatives than by liberals.Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield
- Funding public education through local property taxes is one of the most obvious mechanisms by which the rich get richer and the poor get poorer, because children born into poor neighborhoods receive fewer educational resources from the start; it fails the Rawlsian test since no one in the original position would accept it.57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy