normative

Risk-weighted theory yields an intermediate justice principle

Rawls's maximin is too risk-averse because it cares only about the single worst-off person and ignores everyone else, while Harsanyi's averaging ignores distribution entirely (rating an unequal society as good as an equal one with the same total); Buchak's risk-avoidant decision theory yields an intermediate position that gives most weight to the worst-off, significant weight to the middle, and a little to the best-off, matching how many people actually think about distributing resources and being sensitive to both total wealth and its distribution.

normativepending

Speaker

Lara Buchak

Evidence Quote

“I should give more weight to worst case scenarios, but not exclusive weight to worst case scenarios... I care a lot about how things go for the worst off, and still about how things go for the second worst off.”

Source

220 | Lara Buchak on Risk and Rationality— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...