occupation
In international humanitarian law, a specific legal status arising in an international armed conflict where one country takes over and administers another country's territory, replacing its government—not merely a 'bad situation'.
As defined in Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
Where it comes up · 3
- Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)7 claims
- Mohammed El4 claims
- Omar Suleiman3 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “occupation” →
- The core principle is that you cannot occupy territory to which you have a legal claim; applying uti possidetis juris, Israel's borders at independence in 1948 were those of Mandatory Palestine (between the river and the sea, including Judea and Samaria), so the West Bank falls within Israel's legal claim and cannot be occupied territory.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- Between 1948 and 1967, Palestinians were undisputedly occupied by Jordan (West Bank) and Egypt (Gaza), yet no one demanded a Palestinian state then; Egypt never annexed Gaza, while Jordan annexed the West Bank in 1950 with only one or two countries recognizing the annexation, showing that statehood was not seen as warranted by occupation.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- Not every territorial takeover in war is an occupation; Western Sahara, taken by Morocco in 1974, is called 'disputed' or 'administered' rather than occupied by many European countries because it was not previously a country (an abandoned Spanish colony), so it fails the two-country requirement for occupation.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- Occupation can only exist in wartime; even under Hansell's own 1977 opinion, which conceded that a peace treaty with Jordan would end any occupation, Israel's 1994 unconditional peace with Jordan would dissolve any state of occupation, just as US troops in postwar West Germany or post-2003 Afghanistan did not constitute occupation absent a state of war.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- Occupation is a technical legal term within international humanitarian law, not merely a 'bad situation'; it requires an international armed conflict between two countries in which one country takes over the territory of another country and begins to administer it as the local government, replacing the prior government.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- The occupation argument (laid out in the 1977 Hansell opinion) fails because Jordan was not the sovereign of the West Bank; the US and Western European countries agree Jordan was itself an occupying power there, so the territory was not Jordan's sovereign land, undermining the claim that Israel displaced a legitimate sovereign.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- Security measures such as checkpoints and military raids do not create an occupation, which is defined by actually running the government rather than self-defense; checkpoints arose only after the First and Second Intifadas, and under UN Charter Article 51 every country has an inherent right to self-defense, so Israel's security operations would be valid even if a Palestinian state existed.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- The Israeli judiciary creates a built-in asymmetry by taking Israeli settler documents at face value without authentication while refusing to consider Palestinian, Jordanian, UN, or Ottoman-era ownership documents, making the eviction process a political and religious campaign disguised as a legal real estate dispute.Mohammed El
- The argument that Israel has a historical or divine right to the land is a red herring because no state has inherent rights; regardless of what was written in religious books thousands of years ago, no one has the right to slaughter people, remove them from their homes, and continue living in those homes, nor to keep an entire population in a cage as in Gaza and the West Bank.Mohammed El
- Gaza is an occupation by any international legal standard despite Israel withdrawing troops before October 7th, because Israel controls the movement of everyone, the air, the seas, the ability to import and export, and destroyed Gaza's airport; Israel does not get to set the terms and then define them.Omar Suleiman