causal

Peace Treaty Ends Any Occupation Claim

Occupation can only exist in wartime; even under Hansell's own 1977 opinion, which conceded that a peace treaty with Jordan would end any occupation, Israel's 1994 unconditional peace with Jordan would dissolve any state of occupation, just as US troops in postwar West Germany or post-2003 Afghanistan did not constitute occupation absent a state of war.

causalpending

Speaker

Eugene Kontorovich

Evidence Quote

“of course, Israel did make peace with Jordan--unconditional peace--in 1994. That would make, under Herbert Hansell's own opinion, any state of occupation that did exist in 1967--which I think did not exist--but, even in that view, it would be hard to understand how it survives the peace treaty.”

Source

Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:12:17 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...