non-thinking
A state of mind in zazen practice that is different from and beyond deliberative thinking; achieved by releasing one's grip on thoughts rather than suppressing them
As defined in What to Think About During Zazen (Fukan Zazengi)
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “non-thinking” →
- Dogen's statement 'think about this concrete state beyond thinking' and 'how can the state beyond thinking be thought about' and 'it is different from thinking' contains a paradox where there is a specific state that is very different from thinking; when you are letting go of thoughts and opening the hand of thought and letting them go, that state is described by Dogen as being utterly different from thinking, called 'non-thinking'.What to Think About During Zazen (Fukan Zazengi)
- The phrases 'Fushigi O' (state beyond thinking) and 'Hishadyo' (it is different from thinking) in Dogen's text are two distinct statements: 'Fu' is mild negation (as in 'non-thinking'), while 'Hi' is stronger negation (as in 'illegal' or 'immoral'), so 'Hishadyo' means totally not considering/deliberating, whereas 'Fushigi O' means the absence of deliberation without stronger denial.What to Think About During Zazen (Fukan Zazengi)
- The interpretation of 'Fushigi O' (state beyond thinking) is that it is the mild negation, 'not-thinking,' while what Dogen wants to emphasize through 'Hishadyo' is something totally different from deliberate thinking (consideration/pondering); the speaker's practical interpretation is that one sits there remembering that you're not supposed to be considering things, and that thought of non-thinking helps one remember to let go of deliberative stuff.What to Think About During Zazen (Fukan Zazengi)
- Sometimes when sitting zazen, especially before giving a talk or making a video, the speaker thinks about those upcoming activities rather than remaining in non-thinking; when the speaker remembers that they're supposed to let that go, they do let it go—this is presented as a normal and manageable occurrence in zazen practice.What to Think About During Zazen (Fukan Zazengi)