
What to Think About During Zazen (Fukan Zazengi)
What this covers
This is a talk in which a single, unnamed speaker works through Dogen's Fukan Zazengi, his instructions for zazen, roughly in the order the text gives them. It starts with the posture instructions: full or half lotus, hand placement, spine, tongue, eyes, nasal breathing. The speaker argues that the legs are not the most important part. After the body is settled comes one full exhalation and a sway left and right to find stillness. Then comes the paradoxical instruction to think about the state beyond thinking, which the talk treats as sustained awareness of non-thinking and not as deliberate thought.
The middle of the talk is about what zazen is not. It is not a concentration exercise judged by how concentrated you feel, and it is not a gradual process of "sweeping and polishing," since Dogen says the whole body already transcends dust. The speaker sets the idea of practicing in order to get an experience against Dogen's view that practice and experience are one, so that zazen is enlightenment itself. Dogen's dragon image makes the point sharply: someone who collects dragon carvings may flee when a real dragon appears, and planning to meditate is not meditating. The speaker also covers chasing special insight or clarity, which Dogen says costs you the "vigorous road of getting the body out."
The remaining themes are the "backwards step of turning light and reflecting," the rejection of ranking clever people above dull ones, and the example of the Buddha and Bodhidharma, who each sat for years. The talk ends on urgency, with life compared to a dewdrop or a flash of lightning. Along the way the speaker brings in Chiyama Roshi's phrase opening the hand of thought, which means releasing the grip on thoughts and not eliminating them.
The speaker explains Dogen's 'Fukkan Zazen Gi' to clarify what zazen practice actually is: not a technique to achieve a special state or enlightenment experience, but rather enlightenment itself, where the practice and the realization are one and the same, requiring a specific understanding of non-thinking rather than mental achievement.
- Zazen is enlightenment, not a means to enlightenment—practice and experience are inseparable
- The instruction 'do not think of good and bad' means not judging your zazen practice, and non-thinking is utterly different from and superior to deliberate thinking
- Dogen rejects the notion that zazen is a concentration exercise where you judge success by feeling concentrated; instead it is 'the peaceful and joyful gate of Dharma'
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
After settling the physical posture, the practitioner makes one complete exhalation and sways left and right to find stillness; the state to sit in zazen is 'sitting immovably in the mountains still state'—a concrete state that exists beyond thinking, yet cannot be thought about through ordinary deliberate thinking.
“when the physical posture is already settled make one complete exhalation and sway left and right sitting amove ibly in the mountains still state think about this concrete state beyond thinking how can the state beyond thinking be thought about it is different from thinking this is just the pivot of zazen”
After settling physical posture, Dogen instructs practitioners to 'think about this concrete state beyond thinking'—a paradoxical instruction that means sustaining awareness of non-thinking itself, which is utterly different from deliberate thinking.
“sitting amove ibly in the mountains still state think about this concrete state beyond thinking how can the state beyond thinking be thought about it is different from thinking this is just the pivot of zazen”
In Dogen's teaching, zazen is enlightenment itself—the practice is the experience, not a means to achieve a separate experience later; this distinguishes Dogen's approach from the idea that practice precedes enlightenment.
“when we research it the truth originally is all around why should we rely upon practice and experience that's one of the things that's kind of a sticky point there in Zen is differentiating between practice and experiences that is the idea that you practice in order to have an experience in doggins way of understanding Zaza and the practice is the experience so zazen is enlightenment”
Dogen warns practitioners not to become so accustomed to images and ideas of enlightenment that when the real thing appears, they run away from it—like a man obsessed with dragon carvings who flees when a real dragon appears.
“do not become so accustomed to images that you were dismayed by the real dragon and that's a reference to an old story in which this guy is really excited about collecting dragons carvings of dragons pictures of dragons everything he has of dragons sort of the way I collect Godzilla stuff and one day a real dragon let's say the real Godzilla shows up at his door thinking I'm gonna surprise this guy he loves dragons so much he'll love meeting a real dragon and when he sees the real dragon he runs away so it's a metaphor for the idea of thinking about doing a practice like a lot of people think like I'm gonna start meditating one of these days and actually getting down to doing it”
Many people who pursue zazen seek wonderful enlightened states—pride in understanding, special insights, intellectual achievement, and clarity of mind—but in doing so they have 'almost completely lost the vigorous Road of getting the body out,' meaning they have lost the fundamental practice itself through chasing experiences.
“we attain the truth we clarify the mind we acquire the zeal that pierces the sky we ramble through remote intellectual spheres going in with the head and yet we have almost completely lost the vigorous Road of getting the body out”
In Zen, there is a key differentiating point between practice and experience—the idea that you practice in order to have an experience is contrasted with Dogen's understanding where practice is the experience, meaning zazen is enlightenment itself, not a means to attain enlightenment.
“one of the things that's kind of a sticky point there in Zen is differentiating between practice and experience that is the idea that you practice in order to have an experience in doggins way of understanding Zaza and the practice is the experience so zazen is enlightenment”
Dogen argues that physical effort and gradual improvement (described through the metaphor of 'sweeping and polishing') are not how zazen works, because 'the whole body far transcends dust and dirt' and thus there is nothing to clean; if there is even a small gap or disagreement with right understanding, the separation becomes as great as between heaven and earth.
“the whole body far transcends dust and dirt who could believe in the means of sweeping and polishing which is a reference to an old poem...he's saying that's not what we do in general we do not stray from the right state”
Zazen is not learning zen concentration—it is not a concentration exercise where success is judged by feeling concentrated—but rather 'the peaceful and joyful gate of Dharma' and 'the practice and experience which perfectly realizes the state of Bodhi (enlightenment); the universe is conspicuously realized and restrictions and hindrances never reach it.'
“this sitting in Zossen is not learning zen concentration so it's not some kind of concentration exercise where you judge it according to whether you're feeling concentrated or not it's not what it is it is simply the peaceful and joyful gate of Dharma it is the practice and experience which perfectly realizes the state of Bodhi which is enlightenment the universe is conspicuously realized and restrictions and hindrances never reach it”
One should not abandon one's own place and seat to wander through foreign lands seeking enlightenment elsewhere, as if truth were located in a different place; if one misplaces a single step and passes over the moment of the present, one loses the opportunity, having received the precious human body which is the best condition for pursuing truth.
“why should we abandon our own seat on the floor to come and go without purpose through dusty borders of foreign lands which is about people seeking enlightenment somewhere other than where they are which is you know Philadelphia or Denver or Akron Ohio or wherever you happen to be if we misplace one step we pass over the moment of the present”
One should not become so accustomed to images and ideas (like collecting dragon carvings and pictures) that one is dismayed or fails to recognize the real thing when it appears; in other words, thinking about doing a practice (planning to meditate) is different from actually doing it, just as being a fan of dragons is different from encountering a real dragon.
“do not become so accustomed to images that you were dismayed by the real dragon and that's a reference to an old story in which this guy is really excited about collecting dragons carvings of dragons pictures of dragons everything he has of dragons sort of the way I collect Godzilla stuff and one day a real dragon...shows up at his door...he runs away so it's a metaphor for the idea of thinking about doing a practice like a lot of people think like I'm gonna start meditating one of these days and actually getting down to doing it”
To attain enlightenment, one should practice enlightenment directly and immediately, rather than studying sayings and chasing words; practitioners should 'learn the backwards step of turning light and reflecting' so that 'body and mind will naturally fall away and the original features will manifest themselves.'
“if we want to attain the matter of the ineffable we should practice the matter of the ineffable at once...we should see the intellectual work of studying sayings and chasing words we should learn the backwards step of turning light and reflecting body and mind will naturally fall away and the original features will manifest themselves before us”
To grasp the meaning that zazen is enlightenment is to be like a dragon that has found water or like a tiger in its mountain stronghold—the right Dharma naturally manifests itself before us and darkness and distraction have already dropped away in zazen.
“to grasp this meaning is to be like a dragon that has found water or like a tiger in its mountain stronghold remember the right Dharma is naturally manifesting itself before us and darkness and distraction have dropped away already”
Dogen teaches that striving for special states of insight, clarity of mind, or extraordinary spiritual experiences during zazen is a mistake because it represents a gap between practice and enlightenment, losing the 'vigorous road of getting the body out'—meaning direct embodied presence.
“proud of our understanding and richly endowed with realization we obtain special states of insight we attain the truth we clarify the mind we acquire the zeal that pierces the sky we ramble through remote intellectual spheres going in with the head and yet we have almost completely lost the vigorous Road of getting the body out”
Dogen teaches that the key to authentic zazen is learning 'the backwards step of turning light and reflecting'—a method of introspection where body and mind naturally fall away, and original features manifest themselves, without needing to deliberately aim at becoming a Buddha.
“therefore we should see the intellectual work of studying sayings and chasing words we should learn the backwards step of turning light and reflecting body and mind will naturally fall away and the original features will manifest themselves before us if we want to attain the matter of the ineffable we should practice the matter of the ineffable at once”
One should devote effort to the truth which is directly accessible and straightforward, revere people who are beyond study and without intention, accord with the Bodhi (enlightenment) of the Buddhas, and become a rightful successor to the samadhi (meditative absorption) of the patriarchs (Buddhist ancestors).
“devote effort to the truth which is directly accessible and straightforward Revere people who are beyond study and without intention accord with the Bodhi of the Buddha's the enlightenment of the Buddha's become a rightful successor to the samadhi of the patriarchs”
Ancient Buddhist sages like the Buddha (who spent six years sitting straight in Jetavana Park) and Bodhidharma (who spent nine years facing the wall at Shaolin) all practiced zazen with effort; therefore, contemporary practitioners should also make effort in zazen rather than expecting enlightenment without practice.
“we can still see the traces of the six years spent sitting up straight by the natural sage of jetavana Park that's the Buddha we can still hear rumors of the nine years spent facing the wall by the transmitter of the mind seal of Shaolin that's Bodhi Dharma the ancient Saints were like that already how could people today fail to make effort”
If one practices zazen in the state Dogen describes for a long time, one will surely become that state itself; the treasure house of enlightenment will open naturally and one will be free to receive and use its contents as one likes.
“if you practice the state like this for a long time you will surely become the state like this itself the treasure house will open naturally and you will be free to receive and to use its contents as you like”
One must never pass time in vain; we are maintaining and relying upon the pivot essence which is the Buddha's truth, and one should not idly enjoy fleeting pleasures like sparks from flint; the body is like a dewdrop on a blade of grass and life passes like a flash of lightning, suddenly it is gone in an instant and lost.
“we must never pass time in vain we are maintaining and relying upon the pivot essence which is the Buddha's truth who could wish to idly enjoy sparks that fly from a flint...the body is like a dewdrop on a blade of grass life passes like a flash of lightning suddenly it is gone in an instant it is lost”
Dogen teaches that zazen is not a concentration exercise where one judges success by how concentrated one feels; rather it is 'the peaceful and joyful gate of Dharma' and 'the practice and experience which perfectly realizes the state of Bodhi.'
“this sitting in Zossen is not learning zen concentration so it's not some kind of concentration exercise where you judge it according to whether you're feeling concentrated or not it's not what it is it is simply the peaceful and joyful gate of Dharma it is the practice and experience which perfectly realizes the state of Bodhi which is enlightenment”
Dogen teaches that intelligence and cleverness should not be valued above stupidity or dullness in zazen practice; if one single-mindedly makes effort in zazen, that truly is pursuit of truth and practice naturally becomes untainted.
“do not discuss intelligence as superior and stupidity as inferior do not choose between clever people and dull ones this I like because I'm kind of a dumbass so I like the fact that we don't worry about people who are clever as being better if we single-mindedly make effort in zazen that truly is pursuit of the truth”
One should not discuss intelligence as superior and stupidity as inferior, nor choose between clever people and dull ones; if one single-mindedly makes effort in zazen, that truly is pursuit of the truth, and practice and experience is naturally untainted and actions become more balanced and constant.
“do not discuss intelligence as superior and stupidity as inferior do not choose between clever people and dull ones this I like because I'm kind of a dumbass so I like the fact that we don't worry about people who are clever as being better if we single-mindedly make effort in zazen that truly is pursuit of the truth practice and experience is naturally untainted actions are more balanced and constant”
Dogen teaches that in zazen, one should 'cast aside all involvement,' 'give the myriad things a rest,' 'do not think of good and bad,' 'do not consider right and wrong,' 'stop the driving movement of mind,' and cease 'intellectual consideration through images thoughts and reflections.'
“cast aside all involvement s' give the myriad things a rest do not think of good and bad do not consider right and wrong stop the driving movement of mind will consciousness cease intellectual consideration through images thoughts and reflections do not aim to become a Buddha”
Dogen gives precise physical posture instructions for zazen (full or half lotus, hand placement, spine alignment, tongue position, eye openness, nasal breathing) because physical posture is a necessary foundation, though the speaker argues the legs are not the most important part.
“spread the clothing loosely and make it neat then put the right hand above the left foot and place the left hand on the right palm the thumbs meet and support each other just make the body right and sit up straight do not lean to the left incline to the right slouch forward or lean backward the ears must be aligned with the shoulders and the nose aligned with the navel hold the tongue against the palate keep the lips and teeth closed keep the eyes opened breathe softly through the nose”
Thoughts arise involuntarily from the brain, like stomach acid secretion from the stomach; trying to stop thoughts is futile, but one can practice not paying attention to them, allowing them to pass naturally.
“thoughts are like the secretion of your brain your stomach when it's in your in your gut there secretes stomach acid and you wouldn't want to make it stop secreting stomach acid because that would be bad it's the same thing with thought your brain is gonna produce thought it's in there doing stuff and your conscious perception of what it's doing is thought trying to make that stop is is a fool's errand you know you're not gonna do it but what you can do is not pay attention to it so it just kind of goes so you're not playing with words and images like he says you're just letting them go and flow out as quickly as they flow in”
Chiyama Roshi described the practice of letting thoughts go as 'opening the hand of thought'—a metaphor for releasing the grip on thoughts rather than eliminating them.
“opening the hand of thought is how chiama Roshi put it so I just try to think of it that way you know you're holding on to your thoughts with your hand well open them”
Dogen's statement 'think about this concrete state beyond thinking' and 'how can the state beyond thinking be thought about' and 'it is different from thinking' contains a paradox where there is a specific state that is very different from thinking; when you are letting go of thoughts and opening the hand of thought and letting them go, that state is described by Dogen as being utterly different from thinking, called 'non-thinking'.
“remember that you're supposed to not be thinking and when you can do that it is utterly different from thinking so there is something a state which is very different from thinking and that is non thinking when you were letting go of thoughts and you're opening the hand of thought and letting them go that is described by Dogon as being utterly different from thinking”
The practice of 'opening the hand of thought' (as described by Chiama Roshi) is the method for zazen—one is trying to let go of thoughts and ideas by releasing one's grip on them, rather than trying to suppress or stop thinking altogether, which is impossible.
“opening the hand of thought is how chiama Roshi put it so I just try to think of it that way you know you're holding on to your thoughts with your hand well open them it's impossible to make your thoughts stop”
In zazen, the instruction 'do not think of good and bad' means do not judge your zazen practice—do not think 'this isn't right, this is bad, I'm not doing it right'—rather than literally never evaluating anything as good or evil in all contexts; it is an immediate, practical instruction to avoid self-judgment during sitting.
“do not think of good and bad do not consider right and wrong sometimes people make that too big of a thing they're like don't think about right and wrong don't think about good and evil what about all you know you can go crazy I take this to mean something much more immediate than that is don't judge your zazen don't sit there thinking oh this isn't right this is this is bad”
Thoughts are like stomach secretions—the stomach naturally secretes stomach acid and you would not want to stop it because that would be bad; similarly, the brain naturally produces thoughts and one's conscious perception of what it is doing is thought, so trying to make thought stop is a fool's errand, but one can simply not pay attention to thoughts and let them flow out as quickly as they flow in.
“thoughts are like the secretion of your brain your stomach when it's in your in your gut there secretes stomach acid and you wouldn't want to make it stop secreting stomach acid because that would be bad it's the same thing with thought your brain is gonna produce thought it's in there doing stuff and your conscious perception of what it's doing is thought trying to make that stop is is a fool's errand”
The phrases 'Fushigi O' (state beyond thinking) and 'Hishadyo' (it is different from thinking) in Dogen's text are two distinct statements: 'Fu' is mild negation (as in 'non-thinking'), while 'Hi' is stronger negation (as in 'illegal' or 'immoral'), so 'Hishadyo' means totally not considering/deliberating, whereas 'Fushigi O' means the absence of deliberation without stronger denial.
“Fushigi o and then he contrasts two different things he says Fushigi oh that's nishijima and cross translate as the state beyond thinking and then he says he shead yo and that's what they translate as it is different from thinking...the Fuu is a kind of a mild negation nan thinking or not thinking and he in he she do is found in words in Japanese that are translated to things like immoral or illegal so it's more like the ill in illegal or the M in immoral so it's a stronger sort of denial”
The distinction between 'fu-shigi-o' (state beyond thinking) and 'he-she-yo' (it is not consideration) is key: fu-shigi-o is a mild negation describing a state, while he-she-yo uses strong negation and is more like what Western Zen teachers describe—totally transcending consideration.
“he says Fushigi o and that's what they translate as the state beyond thinking and then he says he shead yo and that's what they translate as it is different from thinking I saw a guy at Tassajara or somewhere give a lecture about foo Kansa ng in which he said Fushigi o and he/she yo are basically two statements of the same thing this is because he learned Japanese from books and he'd never actually been to Japan or maybe hadn't spent time there but there is a difference she do is here translated as thinking but it's more like consideration so it's more like deliberately thinking”
In Japanese, 'she-do' (渉度 or similar) means deliberate consideration or playing with images and thoughts, whereas 'fu' is mild negation (not-X) and 'he' (非) is strong negation (totally-not-X, like 'il-' in illegal or 'im-' in immoral), making Dogen's 'he-she-do' mean 'totally not consideration.'
“she do is here translated as thinking but it's more like consideration so it's more like deliberately thinking it's it's like playing with those images and things that come up in your head rather than letting them go so that's what he means by thinking she do is consideration the Fuu is a kind of a mild negation nan thinking or not thinking and he in he she do is found in words in Japanese that are translated to things like immoral or illegal so it's more like the ill in illegal or the M in immoral so it's a stronger sort of denial it's like it's totally not consideration”
The interpretation of 'Fushigi O' (state beyond thinking) is that it is the mild negation, 'not-thinking,' while what Dogen wants to emphasize through 'Hishadyo' is something totally different from deliberate thinking (consideration/pondering); the speaker's practical interpretation is that one sits there remembering that you're not supposed to be considering things, and that thought of non-thinking helps one remember to let go of deliberative stuff.
“it's totally not consideration and what I take that to mean is I sit there and remember that I'm not supposed to be considering things that's to me thinking the thought of non thinking maybe it's the simplistic interpretation of it but that's the one that works for me”
The speaker's personal practice approach is to interpret Dogen's instruction as 'the thought of non-thinking'—reminding oneself that one is not supposed to be considering things, which then helps one remember to let go of what comes up and keep focused.
“and what I take that to mean is I sit there and remember that I'm not supposed to be considering things that's to me thinking the thought of non thinking maybe it's the simplistic interpretation of it but that's the one that works for me and when I remind myself of that then I remember to let go of the stuff that comes up and keep focused on what I'm doing”
When practicing zazen, remembering that you're supposed to not be thinking helps you remember to let go of the stuff that comes up; one should not judge oneself too harshly on whether one is really focused or not, as some days are better than others, and one should just do the practice anyway.
“and when I remind myself of that then I remember to let go of the stuff that comes up and keep focused on what I'm doing I don't judge myself too harshly on whether I'm real focused or not real focus some days are better than others but you just do it anyway that's the way I think of it”
In zazen practice, you are not playing with words and images (deliberate thinking) but rather letting thoughts go and flow out as quickly as they flow in—this is easier said than done, but if you practice it you can do it.
“you're not playing with words and images like he says you're just letting them go and flow out as quickly as they flow in easier said than done but if you practice it you can do it”
The speaker interprets Dogen's instruction 'do not think of good and bad' to mean 'do not judge your zazen'—don't sit there evaluating whether you're doing it right or wrong; this is a more immediate and practical meaning than abstract ethical non-discrimination.
“sometimes people make that too big of a thing they're like don't think about right and wrong don't think about good and evil what about all you know you can go crazy I take this to mean something much more immediate than that is don't judge your zazen don't sit there thinking oh this isn't right this is this is bad you know that I'm not doing it right don't don't worry about that don't judge it just sit with it”
The legs and specific posture (full or half lotus) are not the most important part of zazen; instead, the crucial element is finding a place where you can balance your spine on top of your hips so that it stands up straight without being supported by the back of a chair or something else, and a separate video will be made about leg positioning.
“I'm gonna do a whole separate video on this I think the legs are not the important part of zazen there are a bunch of ways you can arrange your legs and Dogen is just giving two examples of the standard one the much more important part is to find a place where you can balance your spine on top of your hips so that it stands up straight without it being supported by the back of a chair or something like that”
The speaker does not judge themselves harshly on whether they achieve deep focus during zazen; some days are better than others, but the practice is to sit anyway regardless of apparent quality of experience.
“I don't judge myself too harshly on whether I'm real focused or not real focus some days are better than others but you just do it anyway that's the way I think of it”
Sometimes when sitting zazen, especially before giving a talk or making a video, the speaker thinks about those upcoming activities rather than remaining in non-thinking; when the speaker remembers that they're supposed to let that go, they do let it go—this is presented as a normal and manageable occurrence in zazen practice.
“so I just sit there and I'm trying not to think and ponder and whatever but sometimes it happens especially if I'm sitting before I'm supposed to give a talk or something I'm thinking about the talk I'm gonna give you know I'm thinking about a video I'm gonna make later that's what was going on this morning but I try to let that go when I remember that I'm supposed to let that go”
When one is actually letting go of thoughts and opening the hand of thought, the resulting state is 'utterly different from thinking'—a state of non-thinking that can be directly experienced once achieved.
“so there is something a state which is very different from thinking and that is non thinking when you were letting go of thoughts and you're opening the hand of thought and letting them go that is described by Dogon as being utterly different from thinking”
The speaker's actual zazen experience includes spontaneous thinking (e.g., about upcoming talks or videos), but their practice is to let go of such thoughts when they remember they are supposed to be letting them go.
“so I just sit there and I'm trying not to think and ponder and whatever but sometimes it happens especially if I'm sitting before I'm supposed to give a talk or something I'm thinking about the talk I'm gonna give you know I'm thinking about a video I'm gonna make later that's what was going on this morning but I try to let that go when I remember that I'm supposed to let that go”
The Buddha practiced zazen for six years sitting upright, and Bodhidharma (the transmitter of the mind seal at Shaolin) faced the wall for nine years; Dogen invokes these examples to argue that contemporary practitioners should also practice zazen without hesitation.
“moreover we can still see the traces of the six years spent sitting up straight by the natural sage of jetavana Park that's the Buddha we can still hear rumors of the nine years spent facing the wall by the transmitter of the mind seal of Shaolin that's Bodhi Dharma the ancient Saints were like that already how could people today fail to make effort”
Proper conditions for zazen include: a quiet room, moderate food and drink, casting aside involvement with myriad things, not thinking of good and bad, not considering right and wrong, stopping the driving movement of the mind, ceasing intellectual consideration through images and thoughts, and not aiming to become a Buddha.
“a quiet room is good for practicing zazen and food and drink are taken in moderation cast aside all involvement s' give the myriad things a rest do not think of good and bad do not consider right and wrong stop the driving movement of mind will consciousness cease intellectual consideration through images thoughts and reflections do not aim to become a Buddha”
When we arise from zazen, the body should move slowly and stand up calmly without hurrying or violence; moreover, transcendent realizations through sudden phenomena (a finger gesture, a pole, a needle, a wooden clapper, a whisk, a fist, a staff, a shout) as recorded in old Zen stories cannot be understood through thinking or discrimination, nor through mystical powers or separate practice-and-experience separation.
“when we arise from sitting we should move the body slowly and stand up calmly we should not be hurried or violent...the changing of the moment through the means of a finger a pole a needle or a wooden clapper in the experiences of the state through the manifestation of a whisk a fist a staff or a shout can never be understood by thinking and discrimination”
All Buddhist ancestors and patriarchs of the Western heavens (India), Eastern lands (China, Japan, Korea), similarly maintain the Buddhist posture and solely indulge in the custom of sitting zazen, devoting themselves to sitting and being caught by the still state; although there are myriad distinctions and thousands of differences among practitioners, all should practice zazen and pursue the truth.
“the buddhist ancestors of this world end of other directions of the Western heavens and of the eastern lands that's Western heavens is the India and eastern lands is China Japan Korea all similarly maintain the Buddhist posture and solely indulge in the custom of our religion they simply devote themselves to sitting and are caught by the still state although there are myriad distinctions and thousands of differences we should just practice zazen and pursue the truth”
Dogen references old Zen stories of enlightenment through sudden intervention (a finger, pole, needle, wooden clapper, whisk, fist, staff, or shout) to argue that such awakening 'can never be understood by thinking and discrimination' and 'could not be known through mystical powers or practice and experience' in the ordinary sense.
“the changing of the moment through the means of a finger a pole a needle or a wooden clapper in the experiences of the state through the manifestation of a whisk a fist a staff or a shout can never be understood by thinking and discrimination and all of those are references to old Cohen stories of people attaining enlightenment”
In Dogen's fukken zazen gi, the translations across multiple scholars are nearly identical, unlike many other Dogen texts where different translations can be so divergent they are hardly recognizable as the same piece.
“what I found interesting in looking over them just now is that fukken zazen G happens to be one of the cases where the translations are almost all pretty much identical sometimes when you look at different translations of Dogon that the translations can be so different that it's hardly recognizable as the same piece but in pucon zazen G they're they're very very close no matter who translates it”
Dogen teaches that being born as a human is the best condition for pursuing the truth, because gods enjoy beauty without suffering (so they don't seek truth) and beings in lower states are too preoccupied with survival to practice.
“that's a reference to the Buddhist idea that the best thing if you want to pursue the truth is to be born as a human if you're born as a god you can't pursue the truth because everything is too beautiful if you're born in one of the lower states you can't do it because you're too busy just you know fighting and dealing with stuff”
Fukkan Zazen Gi is a piece of writing by Dogen found in Book 1 of Dogen's Shobogenzo in the Nishijima cross translation, and it is notable for being one of the cases where different translations are almost all very similar to each other, whereas other translations of Dogen can be so different they are hardly recognizable as the same piece.
“I would like to give you a very complicated answer to that question by referencing a piece of writing by Dogon called Buchan zazen G fukken zazen G can be found in book 1 of Dogon Strobel Kenzo in the nishijima cross translation”
The correct zazen posture requires sitting with the spine balanced on top of the hips so it stands upright without external support, with specific instructions: ears aligned with shoulders, nose aligned with navel, tongue against palate, lips and teeth closed, and eyes opened with soft nasal breathing.
“the ears must be aligned with the shoulders and the nose aligned with the navel hold the tongue against the palate keep the lips and teeth closed keep the eyes opened breathe softly through the nose”
The speaker plans to make a separate video specifically on leg positioning in zazen, arguing that while Dogen gives two standard examples (full and half lotus), the legs are not the most important part of zazen posture.
“now I'm gonna do a whole separate video on this I think the legs are not the important part of zazen there are a bunch of ways you can arrange your legs and Dogen is just giving two examples of the standard one the much more important part is to find a place where you can balance your spine on top of your hips so that it stands up straight without it being supported by the back of a chair or something like that”
The speaker's income comes primarily from viewer donations via Patreon and PayPal, with book royalties and speaking fees being insufficient to cover expenses, especially during tax season.
“remember I am supported by your donations via patreon and PayPal the links to do that are below that really helps me book royalties are not sufficient to keep me going whenever tax season comes up I am again reminded how little I get for book royalties how little I get for speaking fees and that most of my income comes from you guys donating”
Long-form video explanations of Zen teachings appear to be popular with audiences, based on the speaker's observation that viewers 'seem to enjoy these long videos.'
“there you go that was another long video people seem to enjoy these long videos so I hope you enjoyed it”