noise
Random variation in data that can be mistaken for a real effect when sample sizes are too small.
As defined in Austin Frakt on Medicaid and the Oregon Medicaid Study
Other definitions
Variability and inconsistency in human judgment and decision-making—when different people make different decisions in identical situations, creating instability and error independent of systematic bias
Daniel Kahneman & Yuval Noah Harari in conversation
Where it comes up · 9
- Daniel Kahneman8 claims
- Daniel Kahneman & Yuval Noah Harari in conversation5 claims
- Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #684 claims
- The Map of Quantum Computing - Quantum Computing Explained2 claims
- #93 Ed Thorp (A Man for All Markets)1 claim
- #222 Ed Thorp (My personal blueprint)1 claim
- Austin Frakt on Medicaid and the Oregon Medicaid Study1 claim
- Arnold Kling on Reforming Government and Expertise1 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 24Search all claims for “noise” →
- In an insurance experiment where 50 specialists priced realistic, routine fraud-risk cases, the variability between two random underwriters averaged 50% (relative to the mean premium), versus the ~10% that executives expected — meaning the underwriters were effectively wasting their time assessing risk, demonstrating that noise (random variability between supposedly interchangeable judges) is far larger than anyone imagines.Daniel Kahneman
- Noise is useful in exactly one condition: when there is a selection process, because evolution works on random variation followed by selection; but when there is no selection, noise is just a cost.Daniel Kahneman
- No rational person should base a decision on undersampled results: when a study lacks enough sample for a question, its reported estimate is not much better than noise even though it has some sample, and whether a study is underpowered is an objective, computable property of any study.Austin Frakt on Medicaid and the Oregon Medicaid Study
- The key advantage of even simple algorithms over human professionals is not superior pattern recognition but noise-free consistency: the same algorithm returns identical output for identical input, and this consistency alone allows simple imperfect algorithms to achieve greater accuracy than human experts.Daniel Kahneman & Yuval Noah Harari in conversation
- Thorp argued that friction gradually slows the roulette ball's orbit until gravity pulls it inward, so an equation could forecast its position, and that random irregularities called noise need not ruin the prediction.#93 Ed Thorp (A Man for All Markets)
- Wherever people exercise judgment there is noise, and there is more noise than people expect and more than they can imagine, because it is hard to imagine that others hold very different opinions when you believe your own opinion is correct — which is why nobody in the insurance organization had any idea the variability existed.Daniel Kahneman
- Noise in human judgment—defined as inconsistency and variability in decisions made by different people facing identical situations—accounts for as much or more error in human decision-making as bias does, yet noise has been vastly underestimated in research and organizational practice.Daniel Kahneman & Yuval Noah Harari in conversation
- The noise book will argue that noise is an underestimated problem and that there is something deep about two ways of thinking — statistical versus causal: noise is inherently a statistical way of looking at things while bias is inherently causal, and the interplay of these forms of thinking is central.Daniel Kahneman
- Noise is useless variability in judgment—when multiple underwriters at an insurance company assess the same case, they vary by about 50% in the premiums they assign, far more than expected by executives (who predict about 10%), and this variation produces no feedback or learning, just costly inconsistency.Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68
- Prediction markets reduce noise because averaging does that, but they cannot reduce a general bias unless the unbiased people also know they are unbiased and can therefore invest more to move the price toward the correct answer; without that asymmetry of knowledge, a bias will persist.Daniel Kahneman