factual

Underwriters Differ 50% Revealing Hidden Noise

In an insurance experiment where 50 specialists priced realistic, routine fraud-risk cases, the variability between two random underwriters averaged 50% (relative to the mean premium), versus the ~10% that executives expected — meaning the underwriters were effectively wasting their time assessing risk, demonstrating that noise (random variability between supposedly interchangeable judges) is far larger than anyone imagines.

factualpending

Speaker

Daniel Kahneman

Evidence Quote

“You average the premium they set, you take the difference between them, and you divide the difference by the average... what we found was 50 percent, 5–0”

Source

Daniel Kahneman— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:23:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...