neo-Darwinism
The tradition of evolutionary theory that emphasizes natural selection acting on purely random variation and the passivity of the organism, banishing inheritance of acquired characteristics.
As defined in 348 | Jessica Riskin on Jean-Baptiste Lamarck and Life as Creative Agency
Other definitions
The 20th-century synthesis emphasizing natural selection acting at the level of genes as the primary causal factor in evolution.
Jessica Riskin on Life, Machinery, and the Restless Clock
Where it comes up · 6
- Jessica Riskin on Life, Machinery, and the Restless Clock2 claims
- The Magician’s Twin, with David Berlinski, Stephen Meyer, and James Orr | Uncommon Knowledge2 claims
- 348 | Jessica Riskin on Jean-Baptiste Lamarck and Life as Creative Agency2 claims
- Denis Noble: "Neo-Darwinism Is Dead" | We Need A Biology Beyond Genes2 claims
- Mathematical Challenges to Darwin’s Theory of Evolution2 claims
- 47 | Adam Rutherford on Humans, Animals, and Life in General1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “neo-Darwinism” →
- Darwin recognized in his 1871 writings that the peacock intentionally displays its feathers to convince the peahen to mate, demonstrating that Darwin attributed agency and intention to animals—a view later erased by neo-Darwinism's commitment to blind, purposeless mechanisms.Denis Noble: "Neo-Darwinism Is Dead" | We Need A Biology Beyond Genes
- Richard Dawkins is, ironically, the heir to William Paley: by treating the organism as totally passive while replacing God with natural selection, the neo-Darwinist model retains a supernaturalism built into it, outsourcing agency to an external force just as Paley outsourced it to God.348 | Jessica Riskin on Jean-Baptiste Lamarck and Life as Creative Agency
- In the 1960s-70s, Neo-Darwinism became the dominant paradigm in evolutionary biology, suppressing alternative views (like those of Barbara McClintock on genetic reorganization and of physiologists like Noble on cellular agency) that did not fit the reductionist framework.Denis Noble: "Neo-Darwinism Is Dead" | We Need A Biology Beyond Genes
- Properly understood, Lamarckism is not the parody of a giraffe stretching for fruit and passing on a longer neck, but the idea that an organism can change during its lifetime in heritable ways—and epigenetics shows organisms can transform through factors outside the genes (the cell, the body, the environment), which the extended evolutionary synthesis seeks to build back into evolutionary biology.Jessica Riskin on Life, Machinery, and the Restless Clock
- The reductive tendency in Neo-Darwinism and much 20th-21st century evolutionary biology insists on a single causal factor—natural selection at the level of the genes—but the world is a messy stew of different levels and forces, so reducing everything to one level misses much complexity; the same is likely true in social systems like economics, and emergence may be partly about recovering those filtered-out layers.Jessica Riskin on Life, Machinery, and the Restless Clock
- Lamarckian inheritance was banished from mainstream science not purely on evidence but for political reasons: in the later 19th century it carried an ill odor of radicalism, atheism and revolution (Lamarck published during the French Revolution), so Darwin's followers eradicated it to make evolution seem sober and non-dangerous.348 | Jessica Riskin on Jean-Baptiste Lamarck and Life as Creative Agency
- A 1960s MIT conference called 'Mathematical Challenges to Neo-Darwinism' was among the first to identify the mathematical problem with Darwinism, with computer scientists like Murray Eden recognizing that random search for meaningful DNA sequences would be extremely unlikely, though at the time they could not measure how rare functional proteins actually were.Mathematical Challenges to Darwin’s Theory of Evolution
- The 1966 Wistar Institute conference on Mathematical Challenges to Neo-Darwinism revealed that if you randomly alter nucleotide bases (As, Cs, Gs, Ts) in DNA, function degrades before new function emerges, making random mutations mathematically insufficient to explain the origin of new genes.The Magician’s Twin, with David Berlinski, Stephen Meyer, and James Orr | Uncommon Knowledge
- David Berlinski's 1996 essay in Commentary titled 'The Deniable Darwin' explained the mathematical challenges to neo-Darwinism posed by the DNA revolution, and this argument has not been answered adequately according to Meyer.The Magician’s Twin, with David Berlinski, Stephen Meyer, and James Orr | Uncommon Knowledge
- Thomas Nagel and others have become skeptical of neo-Darwinism because minds are real phenomena, and if one cannot give an account of where minds come from or what they do without self-refutation, the theory becomes incoherent.Mathematical Challenges to Darwin’s Theory of Evolution