348 | Jessica Riskin on Jean-Baptiste Lamarck and Life as Creative Agency
What this covers
Historian of science Jessica Riskin argues that Jean-Baptiste Lamarck has been systematically misread and unfairly discredited. Rather than proposing magical or vitalist nonsense, Lamarck advanced a rigorous materialist vision: that living organisms possess intrinsic creative agency, capable of shaping themselves and their environment from within, rather than functioning as passive machines responding only to external forces. The conversation traces how this core insight—what Riskin calls active mechanism—stands opposed to a competing strand in biology that treats organisms as entirely acted-upon. Riskin shows how Charles Darwin himself embraced inheritance of acquired characteristics throughout his work, and how the subsequent wholesale rejection of Lamarckian ideas was driven not by empirical refutation but by political ideology, theological anxiety, and the eugenic commitments of twentieth-century biology's architects.
The discussion ranges across unexpected historical ground: how the argument from design emerged from theology, making mechanistic thinkers (not Lamarck) the religiously motivated party; how neo-Darwinism inadvertently inherited William Paley's passive model while swapping God for natural selection; how Julian Huxley weaponized the Lysenko scandal to chill Lamarckian research in the West; and how fields like niche construction and the extended evolutionary synthesis now recover themes Lamarck pioneered. The episode also moves into conservation philosophy, arguing that treating humans as external to nature (as in proposals by E.O. Wilson) reflects the same passive-organism logic that has long distorted evolutionary theory. Throughout, Riskin emphasizes that science is interpretive work embedded in culture, and that acknowledging this openly—rather than pretending to view-from-nowhere objectivity—makes science more rigorous, not less.
Riskin argues that Lamarck's central insight—that living organisms possess creative agency to shape themselves and their world from within, rather than being passive machines acted on by external forces—was not pseudoscientific woo but rigorous materialism, and that this 'active mechanist' view is now being rediscovered by modern biology.
- Darwin himself was a Lamarckian who accepted inheritance of acquired characteristics in every edition of Origin of Species
- The neo-Darwinist banishment of Lamarckism was driven by theological and eugenic ideology, not purely evidence
- Modern fields like epigenetics, niche construction, and the extended evolutionary synthesis recover Lamarckian themes of behavior shaping evolution
Organisms are active self-makers, not passive machines designed and controlled by outside forces.
- The history of biology is a struggle between two models of a living being: a passive 'designed machine' acted on by outside forces (first a designer god, later natural selection), versus 'active mechanism' in which the organism is self-making and self-transforming, constantly redesigning itself rather than being acted upon from outside.
“According to one model, a living being is a kind of designed machine... The competing tradition, is one that I think of as active mechanism, in which the organism is itself self-making and self-transforming, and constantly redesigning itself, rather than being just acted upon from outside.”
- Lamarck held that living organisms are the only creative forces in the world and create not only themselves but the inanimate world around them—seizing God's monopoly on creation—citing that the surface mineral structure of Earth, like the White Cliffs of Dover and coastlines, is formed by living beings.
“He basically said living things are the only creative forces in the world. So he's seizing God's monopoly on creation, and reassigning it to living beings... the kind of surface mineral structure of the world is formed by living beings and the things they make.”
- Darwin's theory of sexual selection, in which animals choose mates according to their own standards of beauty and aesthetic sense, thereby shaping one another from generation to generation, is very much in keeping with Lamarck's emphasis on the role of animals' likes, dislikes and acts of will in shaping form.
“Darwin actually talks about sexual selection as a kind of animals exerting their standards of beauty and their aesthetic senses. So that's very much in keeping with Lamarck.”
- The 17th-century argument from design (Ray, Boyle, culminating in Paley) sought to prove a designer God from the appearance of mechanical design in nature, which means the machine model of living beings emerged out of theology—making the mechanistic engineers, not the active mechanists, the religiously motivated party.
“It's the exact opposite. These are the people who wanted to not make any appeal to a supernatural God... It was the kind of very mechanist, engineer kind of model... that tradition emerged from the argument from design. It came out of a theology.”
Lamarckian inheritance and organismal agency were banished from science for political and ideological reasons, not evidence.
- Lysenko's Soviet claims that vernalized wheat traits would be inherited were not genuine Lamarckism—like Weismann's mouse tails, they involved external exertion on the organism rather than self-driven change—and the episode was ideological on both the Soviet and Western sides, with Huxley using Lysenko to equate Lamarckism with Soviet communism and thereby chill Lamarckian research in the West.
“that, again, is not Lamarckism, really. That is more like Weismann's chopping off the tails of mice. It's an exertion of... from outside.”
- Lamarckian inheritance was banished from mainstream science not purely on evidence but for political reasons: in the later 19th century it carried an ill odor of radicalism, atheism and revolution (Lamarck published during the French Revolution), so Darwin's followers eradicated it to make evolution seem sober and non-dangerous.
“Darwin was acutely conscious that Lamarckism had this ill odor of radicalism, and revolution, regicide, atheism, because Lamarck had developed his theories during the French Revolution”
- Darwin was a Lamarckian in an important sense: he adopted the inheritance of acquired characteristics—calling it the inherited effects of use and disuse—and it appears in every edition of The Origin of Species and in everything he wrote; he was torn between Paley's passive model (with natural selection in God's role) and Lamarck's active model.
“Darwin was a Lamarckian in a very important sense. He adopted Lamarck's idea of what we now call, the inheritance of acquired characteristics... He called it the inherited effects of use and disuse, and it's in every edition of, 'The Origin of Species,'”
- Napoleon loathed Lamarck and his science partly because Lamarck's theory was about distributing creative agency and transformational power throughout the living world, which was uncongenial to Napoleon's top-down desire to control nature, and because its atheistic-sounding implications were bad PR while he courted monarchists.
“his theory was all about distributing creative agency and transformational power all throughout the living world. And again, Napoleon was not interested in that. He wanted to control nature, control the living world.”
Modern biology is recovering organism agency through epigenetics, behavioral evolution, and extended evolutionary synthesis.
- Modern research shows behavior can lead natural selection: the Grants showed behavioral isolation of Galapagos finch populations preceded reproductive/genetic isolation, and Martha Munoz's Dominican lizards, instead of evolving cold tolerance, behaviorally heat themselves on rock and evolved flat heads and short legs to hide in crevices—demonstrating behavior shaping evolutionary outcomes as Lamarck suggested.
“the behavioral isolation preceded the genetic isolation, and that is sort of behavior leading natural selection.”
- The extended evolutionary synthesis is a movement in biology that seeks to reincorporate developmental, ecological, behavioral, and even cultural elements back into evolutionary explanation, responding to the reductive modern synthesis (declared by Huxley in 1942) which confined explanation to random genetic variation and natural selection.
“these are people who are interested in trying to reincorporate developmental, and ecological, and behavioral, and even cultural elements back into the evolutionary picture... the extended evolutionary synthesis, people are trying to reopen the field of explanation beyond that.”
- Epigenetic inheritance—structures outside the DNA that affect gene expression and can be inherited across generations—represents a form of Lamarckian inheritance where acquired changes within a lifetime pass to offspring; preliminary unpublished research on giraffe and okapi cheek swabs found epigenetic differences between species.
“epigenetic changes in a given individual lifetime, can be inherited in the next generation. So those are acquired changes that can be inherited, a kind of Lamarckian inheritance.”
- Researchers in the extended evolutionary synthesis describe whales as having a culture—deciding what song to sing and how to hunt and handing those practices down to offspring—which is why they sought out a historian and philosopher of science who studies culture.
“They talk about whales as having a culture, deciding on what song they're going to sing, and how they're going to hunt, and doing that, handing that down to their offspring, these practices. That's a form of culture.”
Conservation and environmental thought wrongly treat humans as separate from nature rather than acting within it.
- Because humans are animals within the animal world and part of nature (as Lamarck and Darwin showed), conservation should be reconceived as acting from within the natural world rather than imposing an external order; efforts like eradicating invasive species or E.O. Wilson's half-Earth proposal wrongly treat humans as extricable from nature.
“We are animals, in the animal world. We are part of nature. And so I think that, somehow, we need to imagine our environmentalist conservation efforts, sort of as being from within the natural world and not from without.”
Lamarck made foundational scientific contributions across meteorology, taxonomy, and evolutionary theory.
- There is a continuous line of technological development from early modern camshafts (programming devices using pegged barrels) through automatic looms and punch cards to Charles Babbage's calculating engines and ultimately modern computing.
“And so you can see this kind of continuous line of development, from early modern camshafts, through automatic looms, through punch cards, through, of course, modern computing.”
- Contrary to popular assumption, Copernicanism was not in trouble with the Catholic Church from the beginning: Copernicus was a church canon working on the church problem of calendar reform (calculating Easter), and the Catholic Church functioned like the NSF of early modern Europe, funding astronomy and other sciences.
“Copernicus was a church Canon working on a church problem. And in fact, the Catholic Church was like the NSF of early modern Europe. It funded, especially in astronomy, but in various areas.”
- Lamarck was the first person to name and categorize the clouds, developed a science of meteorology, and set up the first government weather bureau, in addition to naming over 6,000 species and coining the term invertebrates.
“he became the first person to name the clouds, to categorize... He developed a science of meteorology and set up the first government weather bureau.”
- August Weismann's famous experiment of chopping the tails off mice for several generations and showing normal-tailed offspring was not a genuine refutation of Lamarck or Darwin—neither claimed amputations were inherited, only that organisms transform themselves from within via habits—and Weismann himself admitted it was meant only to refute the popular version of the belief.
“He himself knew that this was really not a refutation of Lamarck or Darwin, because neither of them had said that amputations were inherited... It was really sort of a gimmick, but it was extraordinarily powerful.”
- Lamarck's 'le pouvoir de la vie' (the power of life) was meant as a material force intrinsic to living matter—analogous to gravity, electricity, or magnetism—that causes matter to complexify; life begins via spontaneous generation from heat or electricity acting on inanimate matter, then this power drives ever-increasing complexity.
“he uses that phrase to name a force that he thought was intrinsic to living matter, that caused it to complexify... in fact what he meant was a very material force like the forces in contemporary physics.”
- The modern partnership between science and government, which took shape at the end of the 17th century with institutions like the Royal Society and was bipartisan in the United States, now appears to be possibly at an end or under threat in a way not previously foreseen, as evidenced by recent reporting on the destruction of science in America.
“that modern partnership seems to be possibly at an end, or anyway, under threat in a way that I absolutely didn't foresee... a piece in today's... about the destruction of science in America.”
- Richard Dawkins is, ironically, the heir to William Paley: by treating the organism as totally passive while replacing God with natural selection, the neo-Darwinist model retains a supernaturalism built into it, outsourcing agency to an external force just as Paley outsourced it to God.
“I think that Richard Dawkins, ironically, is the heir to William Paley. He doesn't see it that way, but I think that's really the case.”
- The neo-Darwinist founders (Fisher, Haldane, Huxley, Crick, Watson) were almost without exception eugenicists, and there was a eugenic logic built into the deep structure of the passive-organism model; the attraction to the reductive paradigm reflects not just a love of simplicity but a love of power and control over the natural world.
“the degree to which they were eugenicists... They were all eugenicists, pretty much without exception... there was a sort of eugenic logic built into the idea of the passivity of living beings, including human beings.”
- The conflict between Darwinian evolution and the church came to a head not immediately in 19th-century England but in America in the 1920s, showing there is no uniform progress toward greater secularism over time and that science-church relations have a complicated, non-linear history.
“the conflict between Darwinian evolution and the church, really came to a head, for the most part, not immediately in England in the 19th century, but in America in the 1920s.”
Science emerged from theology and culture, not pure objectivity; knowledge requires transparency about interpretive perspective.
- Up through the end of the 19th century the sciences were not separate from literature, art, aesthetics, and philosophy, but in roughly the 25 years on either side of 1900 there was a radical divorce between science and all other forms of knowing, which Riskin regards as impoverishing on both sides.
“there's a radical divorce between science and all other forms of knowing... I think, on some level, it is impoverishing on both sides.”
- Science is an ineradicable element of human culture and interpretation goes all the way down—everything is known from our perspective within a culture; rather than striving for an impossible view-from-nowhere objectivity, science should aspire to be as self-conscious and transparent as possible about its interpretive goals, which is still a rigorous search for truth.
“interpretation goes all the way down... rather than striving for a kind of view-from-nowhere objectivity, that's impossible... I think the thing to aspire to is to be as self-conscious and transparent as possible about what our interpretative goals are and why.”
- Humans draw on the machines and models around them to understand living beings: in the 17th century automata and clocks inspired Descartes' view of bodies as machinery, in the 18th century musical instruments served as models of living beings, and today information machines and computers play that role.
“In the way that we use information machinery, we use computers, they used clavichords, and harpsichords, and cellos, vibrating strings, and all of that. So yes, exactly. We draw on the machines or the models that are around us.”