negative income tax
Friedman's proposal to replace complex welfare programs with a single transfer that pays money to people below an income threshold, reducing the implicit tax on earning more.
As defined in Robert Chitester on Milton Friedman and Free to Choose
Other definitions
Friedman's proposed welfare reform in which people below an income threshold receive payments from the government rather than paying taxes; basis for the Earned Income Credit.
Nicholas Wapshott on Samuelson and FriedmanA redistribution scheme proposed by Milton Friedman in which people below a certain income threshold receive payments from the government (a guaranteed income floor) administered through the tax system.
Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/2007
Where it comes up · 21
- Jennifer Burns3 claims
- Angus Burgin on Hayek, Friedman, and the Great Persuasion2 claims
- Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee2 claims
- Robert Chitester on Milton Friedman and Free to Choose2 claims
- 73 - Forbidden Knowledge2 claims
- Esther Duflo1 claim
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Alex Imas and Phil Trammell – What remains scarce after AGI?1 claim
- Edward Glaeser - Cities, Terrorism, Housing, & Remote Work1 claim
and 13 more
Most important claims · 10 of 27Search all claims for “negative income tax” →
- Friedman's idea—once mass taxation arrived, deliver the minimum income through the tax system by rebating those who pay no income tax—actually came to pass as the Earned Income Tax Credit, which policy analysts consider extremely successful: it does what it's supposed to, isn't expensive, and avoids creating a redistributive bureaucracy, exemplifying his preference for cash grants over market intervention.Jennifer Burns
- Like many ideologues, Rand trained her fire not on the opposing side but on near-allies she considered insufficiently pure—condemning Hayek as 'poison' and 'pernicious' for entertaining national health insurance and unemployment provisions, and accusing Friedman and Stigler of being Communist plants for using the word 'rationing' and discussing social equality.Jennifer Burns on Ayn Rand and the Goddess of the Market
- Friedman, in a 1938 paper, advocated what we'd call a universal basic income—putting an income floor under everybody, based on income (more income, less benefit), originally pegged to the cost of food—as keeping with a liberal polity because it does not interfere with the price system, does not require a bureaucracy or qualification by protected class, unlike a minimum wage which prices out unskilled labor by interfering with the work bargain.Jennifer Burns
- Friedman's orientation — asking 'what would it look like if we let the market decide' or injected market incentives — became influential far beyond conservatives, adopted by Democrats too, with some of the biggest deregulatory moves (transportation, airlines, trucking) coming under the Carter Administration, reflecting a broad late-20th-century conclusion that first-pass federal regulation imposed big efficiency costs.Jennifer Burns on Milton Friedman
- Economists hold that head taxes (lump-sum taxes that don't change with behavior) are the most efficient form of taxation because they create no or minimal distortion effects; a BIG is essentially a negative head tax, meaning recipients keep it no matter how much they earn, removing the distortion.Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee
- Starting from a state of nature without political constraints, one could institute a single broad-based negative income tax (as Milton Friedman proposed) to provide a floor income, which would be a sufficient social safety net for people of any age, eliminating the need for separate age-based programs—though we are very far from that world.Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/2007
- If you have a free society in which people elect their government, you will inevitably have a government safety net, because human nature makes the temptation to use the power to tax to fund such a net too great for the populace to ignore; therefore the right goal is to structure welfare to deliver emergency support while letting people exit quickly.Robert Chitester on Milton Friedman and Free to Choose
- The current welfare system imposes an effective marginal tax rate well over 100% on the very poor, because earning income or getting married causes loss of stacked benefits (Section 8 housing, child support, unemployment, heat subsidies) that exceeds the new earnings; a BIG, being a negative head tax that is not lost as income rises, would reduce that marginal rate to near zero and induce more poor people to work.Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee
- UBI risks a dangerous power-sharing arrangement because people become dependent on a government check rather than on labor-derived income, making basic needs hostage to whoever is in power; universal basic capital is preferable because it gives people an ownership share and property rights, but it faces the hard problem of targeting which assets to put in portfolios.Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Alex Imas and Phil Trammell – What remains scarce after AGI?
- Giving the very poorest, most deprived parents money for basic material needs can help their children, but in general simple money transfers are not the most effective way to solve the problems associated with growing up in poor families.Susan Mayer on What Money Can't Buy