natural rate of interest
In Wicksellian theory, the interest rate that balances saving and investment; when the market rate is held below it, distortions and unsustainable booms result
As defined in Bruce Caldwell on Hayek
Other definitions
In Austrian economics, the interest rate that reflects the genuine scarcity of savings and time preference in a free market; any other rate is seen as artificial and distorting.
MMT vs. Austrian School Debate
Where it comes up · 6
- Making Sense of the Market Pt.24 claims
- Scott Sumner on Money, Business Cycles, and Monetary Policy2 claims
- George Selgin on Monetary Policy and the Great Recession2 claims
- MMT vs. Austrian School Debate1 claim
- Bruce Caldwell on Hayek1 claim
- Aswath Damodaran - Making Sense of the Market Pt. 2 - [Invest Like the Best, EP.349]1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “natural rate of interest” →
- By trying to keep the Federal Funds rate artificially high through interest on reserves and sterilization, the Fed paradoxically all but guaranteed the rate would fall and stay low, because reviving credit and letting banks lend the extra reserves would have boosted spending and nominal GDP, which would eventually have pushed interest rates back up—whereas suppressing lending kept the natural rate collapsing.George Selgin on Monetary Policy and the Great Recession
- Once interest rates hit zero in late 2008, the Fed had no backup plan; despite academic Bernanke arguing the Fed could do many things at zero rates, the institutional Fed was conservative and slow to adopt radical ideas, so it had no plan to prevent nominal GDP from plummeting and staying below trend, relying instead on low rates and hope.Scott Sumner on Money, Business Cycles, and Monetary Policy
- Nominal GDP fell in 2008 due to a perfect storm: the housing bubble burst, lowering the natural rate of interest, while a simultaneous oil price spike (gasoline from $2 to $4) raised headline inflation and frightened the inflation-focused Fed into not cutting rates aggressively (rates were still 2% when Lehman failed), so by the time the Fed realized it was sliding into deep recession, rates were near zero and it lacked its conventional tool; markets then crashed when they saw the Fed had no Plan B.Scott Sumner on Money, Business Cycles, and Monetary Policy
- Interest rates are not set by the Fed; the rate is determined by the natural rate tied to expected inflation, so rate forecasts that ignore inflation expectations are, in his view, empty.Making Sense of the Market Pt.2
- Austrian business cycle theory holds that downturns occur when the market rate of interest is held below the natural rate (in Wicksellian terms), and long periods of low interest rates distort the structure of production in unsustainable ways, producing a misallocation of capital goods—a pattern the recent housing glut illustrates.Bruce Caldwell on Hayek
- Modern Fed thinking, influenced by contemporary monetary theories where it is uncool to talk about money or quantities, holds that monetary policy is fundamentally about regulating the Federal Funds rate rather than flows or quantities—an idea that treats a fixed interest rate as equivalent to letting the money supply be demand-determined, which fails because money demand does not map neatly onto any given interest-rate target.George Selgin on Monetary Policy and the Great Recession
- The natural interest rate is expected long-term inflation plus 1 to 1.5 percent, not last year's inflation, so interest rate forecasts should begin from an inflation forecast, and the Fed does not set rates.Aswath Damodaran - Making Sense of the Market Pt. 2 - [Invest Like the Best, EP.349]
- Damodaran's rule of thumb sets the natural interest rate at expected long-term inflation plus 1% to 1.5%, and interest-rate forecasts should begin from an inflation forecast because interest rates have no anchor without it.Making Sense of the Market Pt.2
- After the inflation shock and recession work through the system, Damodaran would not be surprised to end up near 2007 conditions of roughly 4% rates and 3% inflation, with markets pricing that environment.Making Sense of the Market Pt.2
- One of two prevailing narratives must be wrong: either the last 18 months are an aberration that will revert to the Fed-dominated pre-2022 regime, or they are the norm and the prior decade was the aberration, and the latter is the more reasonable assumption.Making Sense of the Market Pt.2