natural belief
A belief that arises spontaneously and involuntarily from human nature and constitution rather than through reasoning or voluntary construction; beliefs rooted in the intrinsic proclivities of human beings that are universal and psychologically necessary.
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 50 Scottish Realism
Where it comes up · 2
- A History of Philosophy | 50 Scottish Realism8 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “natural belief” →
- An alternative tradition to Locke's evidentialism has developed, called Scottish realism or the natural belief approach, which holds that certain beliefs arise spontaneously and naturally in humans rather than through voluntary proportioning of assent to evidence—beliefs are not always voluntary products of deliberate reasoning but rather arise through natural belief-forming mechanisms.A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas
- This epistemology of causation—where we directly know causal connection through experience—is crucial because it will be a key point that Immanuel Kant responds to, making the question of how we know about cause and effect relations beyond present experience a fundamental issue in Kant's philosophy.A History of Philosophy | 50 Scottish Realism
- Natural beliefs or common-sense beliefs are universal human beliefs that arise spontaneously from human nature and God's design, not from reasoning processes; they are rooted in the intrinsic nature and proclivities of human beings rather than being artificial constructs.A History of Philosophy | 50 Scottish Realism
- The key difference between Hume and Reid on natural beliefs is not that both affirm them, but that Reid emphasizes the theistic justification: God made us in such a way that we naturally come to certain beliefs, whereas Hume does not provide this theological grounding.A History of Philosophy | 50 Scottish Realism
- Reid's account of natural belief has stimulus-response features resembling behavioristic psychology (though Reid predates behaviorism), and 20th century realists did appeal to stimulus-reflex mechanisms in explaining direct awareness of sense perception.A History of Philosophy | 50 Scottish Realism
- The reading of Hume as a radical skeptic (taking his skepticism as his final position rather than affirming natural belief) persisted in many circles and is likely still the popular image of him among those who do not read his work more carefully.A History of Philosophy | 50 Scottish Realism
- G.E. Moore, in early 20th century realism, maintains that natural beliefs are logically necessary because the contradiction of them is self-contradictory, exemplified by the claim that 'time is unreal,' which contradicts itself every time one says 'I've got to do something before I do something else.'A History of Philosophy | 50 Scottish Realism
- By the 20th century, realists like G.E. Moore no longer require theistic justification; Moore remains religiously agnostic, yet maintains the natural belief epistemology developed by Scottish realists.A History of Philosophy | 50 Scottish Realism
- Natural beliefs that Reid identifies include beliefs about the laws of logic, axioms of mathematics (Euclidean geometry), the existence and nature of material things, causal connections, memory, human freedom, and moral principles.A History of Philosophy | 50 Scottish Realism