nanny state
A state that paternalistically regulates personal behavior for citizens' own good (e.g., soda-size limits, cigarette-advertising restrictions).
As defined in James Otteson on the End of Socialism
Where it comes up · 5
- David Boaz, P.J. O'Rourke, and George Will on the State of Liberty2 claims
- James Otteson on the End of Socialism1 claim
- Elizabeth Anderson on Worker Rights and Private Government1 claim
- Vivek Ramaswamy1 claim
- 14 | Alta Charo on Bioethics and the Law1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “nanny state” →
- If a classical liberal rejects the nanny state's infantilizing control even when it might save lives, consistency demands rejecting the same paternalistic, freedom-restricting control when exercised by private government in the workplace rather than applying cost-benefit analysis there.Elizabeth Anderson on Worker Rights and Private Government
- Much socialist-inclined policy goes beyond providing a minimum floor and attempts to centrally engineer a full flourishing life for people, and it is this ambitious agenda—not the basic minimum—where the knowledge problem truly comes to the fore because no distant authority can know what a fully flourishing life requires for each individual.James Otteson on the End of Socialism
- Public health law continually collides with libertarian autonomy objections: rules preventing one person from harming others (like polluting drinking water) are accepted, but rules limiting purely self-regarding risk are condemned as 'nanny state'—and the raw milk case shows the regulation actually targets the sale (the economy and profiting from a high-risk product), not the individual's right to consume.14 | Alta Charo on Bioethics and the Law
- Ramaswamy's ideology in a nutshell is to terminate the nanny state in all its forms—the entitlement state, the regulatory state, and the foreign policy nanny state (subsidizing other countries that don't pay their fair share)—which he frames as a crusade that, once accomplished, revives the republic the founders envisioned.Vivek Ramaswamy
- Earlier American government intrusions—state churches, sodomy laws, Jim Crow—were far worse manifestations of the nanny state than today's regulation of light bulbs and toilets, however outrageous the latter may be.David Boaz, P.J. O'Rourke, and George Will on the State of Liberty
- Whether the glass of liberty is half full depends on the baseline: compared to most of human history and the contemporary world, America is at least half full—at the time of the American Revolution there was slavery, and the 1950s excluded many groups and carried heavy New Deal regulation, so today is on balance freer.David Boaz, P.J. O'Rourke, and George Will on the State of Liberty