might makes right
The rule that whoever can seize something (people or resources) by force thereby gains the legitimate right to sell it; Wenar argues it is an anti-market principle once used for slavery and still applied to foreign resources.
As defined in Leif Wenar on Blood Oil
Other definitions
A cynical ethical and political doctrine arguing that morality and justice are not absolute principles but rather whatever serves the interests of the powerful, and that justice is simply the imposition of the stronger's will on the weaker—central to Thrasymachus's argument in Plato's Republic
Jeffrey Brenzel: The Essential Value of a Classic Education | Big Think
Where it comes up · 2
- Leif Wenar on Blood Oil6 claims
- Jeffrey Brenzel: The Essential Value of a Classic Education | Big Think2 claims
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “might makes right” →
- The existence of a market with prices and exchange does not prove the goods are legitimately sellable: 300 years ago there was a functioning market in human beings with emergent prices and traded property certificates, yet those sellers ought not to have had the right to sell people; likewise, today the question for oil is not whether a market exists but who legitimately has the right to sell a country's resources.Leif Wenar on Blood Oil
- The argument that 'might is right' and justice has no fixed meaning is a universally recurring argument not only throughout college dorm conversations but throughout the centuries in debates among the very best philosophersJeffrey Brenzel: The Essential Value of a Classic Education | Big Think
- Although there is no international law or jurisdiction governing who may sell foreign oil, the United States as a sovereign state already decides its own rules about whom it buys oil from; it currently uses Might Makes Right, but could instead align its laws with its own founding principle that a country belongs to its people and buy only from actors who could plausibly have the people's authorization.Leif Wenar on Blood Oil
- Thrasymachus argues that might makes right, justice is merely the interest of the stronger, all governments make laws according to their own interests and call it justice, and therefore the absolute tyrant has the best life because all people would become tyrants if they could.Jeffrey Brenzel: The Essential Value of a Classic Education | Big Think
- The United States should pass a law tapering off all imports of oil and other natural resources (blood oil and conflict minerals) from authoritarian regimes and failed states, which is feasible because free countries now have enough energy that such imports are no longer needed, and which would replace Might Makes Right with the principle that all countries belong to their people.Leif Wenar on Blood Oil
- The rule for oil is anti-market because it lets violence overseas create legal property rights in the United States: a militia can extract a mineral at gunpoint in the Congo, yet you still legally own 100% of the phone containing it—a violation of central market norms that conventional free-trade thinking overlooks.Leif Wenar on Blood Oil
- No one believes that armed men who seize an Exxon station should legally be able to sell off its oil and keep the money, yet under the current rule armed men who overthrow the government of Equatorial Guinea would be recognized as having the right to sell off the whole country's oil—revealing that on a basic philosophical level there is no free market in oil, only guys with guns selling resources that belong to the people.Leif Wenar on Blood Oil
- The same rule now used for oil—Might Makes Right, whereby whoever can seize something by force can sell it to us—was the rule that legalized the Atlantic slave trade 300 years ago, under which 12 million Africans were forced through the Middle Passage and bought legally as property; we abolished that rule for human beings but still apply it to the resources of other countries.Leif Wenar on Blood Oil